Liverpool FC Forum

[The Manhattan Project]

What are the chances of Keane and Defoe leaving their clubs?

And how much would they cost?

Ideally I'd like Defoe and Huntelaar.

One Prem proven, one foreign hotshot.

Get rid of Crouch and Kuyt

Voronin can be replaced by a free or cheap older and experienced Brit striker too.

[LFC2007]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

He did well in his first few seasons at spurs . Defoe i mean

Irrelevant.

SPurs have always been in the top 6 and have gotten results against top sides

Disclaimer this was when jol took over up till this season ****

He's not proven at the top level.

[god_bless_john_houlding]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

He did well in his first few seasons at spurs . Defoe i mean

Irrelevant.

SPurs have always been in the top 6 and have gotten results against top sides

Disclaimer this was when jol took over up till this season ****

He's not proven at the top level.

Keane 150 goals for spurs in 6 seasons. That's around 25 goals a season in all comps. 15 goals in the league last season...I think 10 this season. It's a decent record for somebody who isn't "proven" at this level.

[LFC2007]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

He did well in his first few seasons at spurs . Defoe i mean

Irrelevant.

SPurs have always been in the top 6 and have gotten results against top sides

Disclaimer this was when jol took over up till this season ****

He's not proven at the top level.

Keane 150 goals for spurs in 6 seasons. That's around 25 goals a season in all comps. 15 goals in the league last season...I think 10 this season. It's a decent record for somebody who isn't "proven" at this level.

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

[Kharhaz]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

[LFC2007]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

[Kharhaz]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

Wheres the wankworld thread that made me laugh !

[Toffeehater]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

u're like a fecking broken radio

instead of saying oh he's not provena t top lvl , put foward some names , who are proven at top lvl in the premiership and are fesiable signings

[LFC2007]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

u're like a fecking broken radio

instead of saying oh he's not provena t top lvl , put foward some names , who are proven at top lvl in the premiership and are fesiable signings

How about, read the thread again and see what my original point was?

Cheers.

[JC_81]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

How the fu.ck is Robbie Keane not proven at the top level?? What more does he have to do to prove himself? 

He's shown season after season that he's a good premiership player and this season has also improved his goals per game ratio.  He's also proven himself at international level for Ireland.

[The_Rock]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

How the fu.ck is Robbie Keane not proven at the top level?? What more does he have to do to prove himself? 

He's shown season after season that he's a good premiership player and this season has also improved his goals per game ratio.  He's also proven himself at international level for Ireland.

If keane is not proven in the top flight...i don't know what to make off kuyt, voronin, alonso (who only had a great 1st season IMO), benayoun, babel...etc... This is a joke.

I will take robbie keane anyday over kuyt, voronin and crouch....

[Ola Mr Benitez]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

u're like a fecking broken radio

instead of saying oh he's not provena t top lvl , put foward some names , who are proven at top lvl in the premiership and are fesiable signings

How about, read the thread again and see what my original point was?

Cheers.

How about you all read the thread again and get back on topic??

[maguskwt]

It's a good record, but he's still not proven at the top level.

I disagree there, that is a good record and he is consistent at a top level. i certainly wouldnt disagree with rafa signing him. I rate him very highly.

It's besides the point I was making originally, but just to say it again: he's not proven at the top level. 

u're like a fecking broken radio

instead of saying oh he's not provena t top lvl , put foward some names , who are proven at top lvl in the premiership and are fesiable signings

How about, read the thread again and see what my original point was?

Cheers.

How about you all read the thread again and get back on topic??

yes... pls get back to the topic...

I would take Obafemi Martins over Robbie Keane   

[LFC2007]

Keane is the only feasible signing there, and he's not proven at the top level.

He was playing well when at leeds as i rmb they amde it to the champiosn league and were a top side when they were run by o leary . Very difficult to beat , One more name i'll throw would be the recently signed pompey striker Jermaine defore , fast , Skillfull , very good finisher , proven and adapted to the premier league

He hardly played for Leeds ffs! He had a good spell on loan, before having an average period with them after a permanent deal was made. He isn't proven at the top level. Jermaine Defoe isn't proven at the top level either.

How the fu.ck is Robbie Keane not proven at the top level?? What more does he have to do to prove himself? 

He's shown season after season that he's a good premiership player and this season has also improved his goals per game ratio.  He's also proven himself at international level for Ireland.

How the f.uck is he proven at the top level?

He's not played for a top-four team, he's not played regular Champions League football, he is not proven at the top level and that's a fact. The dynamics of playing in a top four team are completely different to those other teams face.

[The Manhattan Project]

Crouch should do some modelling.