Liverpool FC Forum

[GYBS]

sorry i meant to say ''to say Kuyt is better then Berba is out of this world''

then you need to read back my friend and you will see i said berbatov is a better striker than kuyt and you replied - joke of the day

i havent said kuyt is a better striker than berbatov

i feel Berba is a better player, not just a striker. he has his attitude issues. but so did Cantona, Roy Keane, Totti, Cassano, etc.

i feel ability wise yes he is better than kut but feel kuyt will brings much more to the liverpool team . not just berbatovs attotude which is and all about hiself - his work ethic , his teamwork all shocking .

i get what you mean. but Kuyt doesnt have a moment of sheer individual brilliance which could win you a match, which could get you points which would bring you closer to the title.

and berbatov has done that ? his moments of brilliance didnt do much for spurs did they ? and kuyts moments enabled us to beat massive teams in europe and in the prem .

Do you seriously believe the things you type ?

where am i wrong then ? what did berbatovs great moments of brilliance achive for spurs ? and how many important goals or assists did kuyt get for us against big teams last year and this year ? and even season before ?

[Zidane]

It's just GYBS' opinion no need to make him feel as if he's wrong for thinking so.  Most teams would pay a lot more for Ronaldo because he is more skillful than Gerrard, does that mean we should think Ronaldo is that much better?  Didn't think so.

[GYBS]

Ahem.

*goes for the third attempt*


Is Kuyt a better player than Berbatov or not?

considering everything i think they are about even .

Who do you think would pay £30m for Dirk then?

i dont care - just cause the alkie manc wants to pay 30 mil for him doesnt make him gods gift .

so are we believing managers opinions now then ? or picking and choosing when it suits best ?

[maypaxvobiscum]

sorry i meant to say ''to say Kuyt is better then Berba is out of this world''

then you need to read back my friend and you will see i said berbatov is a better striker than kuyt and you replied - joke of the day

i havent said kuyt is a better striker than berbatov

i feel Berba is a better player, not just a striker. he has his attitude issues. but so did Cantona, Roy Keane, Totti, Cassano, etc.

i feel ability wise yes he is better than kut but feel kuyt will brings much more to the liverpool team . not just berbatovs attotude which is and all about hiself - his work ethic , his teamwork all shocking .

i get what you mean. but Kuyt doesnt have a moment of sheer individual brilliance which could win you a match, which could get you points which would bring you closer to the title.

and berbatov has done that ? his moments of brilliance didnt do much for spurs did they ? and kuyts moments enabled us to beat massive teams in europe and in the prem .

Do you seriously believe the things you type ?

where am i wrong then ? what did berbatovs great moments of brilliance achive for spurs ? and how many important goals or assists did kuyt get for us against big teams last year and this year ? and even season before ?

its easier to count Kuyt's bit as there is less 

[GYBS]

It's just GYBS' opinion no need to make him feel as if he's wrong for thinking so.  Most teams would pay a lot more for Ronaldo because he is more skillful than Gerrard, does that mean we should think Ronaldo is that much better?  Didn't think so.

and also for what gerrard brings to the team as well makes him better than ronaldo in my opinion .

[Jimmy the Weasel]

Ahem.

*goes for the third attempt*


Is Kuyt a better player than Berbatov or not?

considering everything i think they are about even .

Who do you think would pay £30m for Dirk then?

i dont care - just cause the alkie manc wants to pay 30 mil for him doesnt make him gods gift .

so are we believing managers opinions now then ? or picking and choosing when it suits best ?

I've only asked about this example, so nothing you can accuse me of I'm afraid!!

But didn't you say that top managers' opinions are more reliable than posters on here though? You said something about Van Basten and Rafa I think.

So Slur Alex's opinion is possibly more worthwhile than yours, using your terms I mean.

Nobody would pay £30m for Dirk would they? Be honest.

[GYBS]

sorry i meant to say ''to say Kuyt is better then Berba is out of this world''

then you need to read back my friend and you will see i said berbatov is a better striker than kuyt and you replied - joke of the day

i havent said kuyt is a better striker than berbatov

i feel Berba is a better player, not just a striker. he has his attitude issues. but so did Cantona, Roy Keane, Totti, Cassano, etc.

i feel ability wise yes he is better than kut but feel kuyt will brings much more to the liverpool team . not just berbatovs attotude which is and all about hiself - his work ethic , his teamwork all shocking .

i get what you mean. but Kuyt doesnt have a moment of sheer individual brilliance which could win you a match, which could get you points which would bring you closer to the title.

and berbatov has done that ? his moments of brilliance didnt do much for spurs did they ? and kuyts moments enabled us to beat massive teams in europe and in the prem .

Do you seriously believe the things you type ?

where am i wrong then ? what did berbatovs great moments of brilliance achive for spurs ? and how many important goals or assists did kuyt get for us against big teams last year and this year ? and even season before ?

its easier to count Kuyt's bit as there is less 

really ? did berbatov help get his team in the cl ? did he help them get to the semi finals ? name me important crucial bits of brilliance berbatov did then that won massive games for his club or helped win massive games for his club ?

[Jimmy the Weasel]

It's just GYBS' opinion no need to make him feel as if he's wrong for thinking so.  Most teams would pay a lot more for Ronaldo because he is more skillful than Gerrard, does that mean we should think Ronaldo is that much better?  Didn't think so.

I'm trying to understand the reasoning behind the opinion that's all - it's just a discussion....

[account deleted by request]

Nothing like a reasonable debate............ and that was nothing like a reasonable debate.

[GYBS]

Ahem.

*goes for the third attempt*


Is Kuyt a better player than Berbatov or not?

considering everything i think they are about even .

Who do you think would pay £30m for Dirk then?

i dont care - just cause the alkie manc wants to pay 30 mil for him doesnt make him gods gift .

so are we believing managers opinions now then ? or picking and choosing when it suits best ?

I've only asked about this example, so nothing you can accuse me of I'm afraid!!

But didn't you say that top managers' opinions are more reliable than posters on here though? You said something about Van Basten and Rafa I think.

So Slur Alex's opinion is possibly more worthwhile than yours, using your terms I mean.

Nobody would pay £30m for Dirk would they? Be honest.

yes his opinion may well be worthwhile as opposed to mine .

of course no one would pay 30 mil for kuyt - that doesnt make him or not good enough . many times teams have paid over the odds for flashy players . im sure was it hamburg wanted him and were willing to pay 15 mil plus for him .

[Ace Ventura]

Not goin to bother quoting GYBS, Berbatov is on another level to Kuyt. If you cant see it then you are without kicking off mentally challenged.
Dirk tries hard and we all love him for that, but if we could swap the two and you would take more than 00000.32 seconds to consider it then you need more vitamins 

[Yooj Bigullz]

This is like the twilight zone or something. Either that or GYBS is a comedy genius

[GYBS]

Not goin to bother quoting GYBS, Berbatov is on another level to Kuyt. If you cant see it then you are without kicking off mentally challenged.
Dirk tries hard and we all love him for that, but if we could swap the two and you would take more than 00000.32 seconds to consider it then you need more vitamins 

im sorry but do you see me insulting you or your opinion ?no you dont so please refrain from doing so , by all means debate against my opinion by at least be grown up enough to do it without insults.

[Jimmy the Weasel]

Ahem.

*goes for the third attempt*


Is Kuyt a better player than Berbatov or not?

considering everything i think they are about even .

Who do you think would pay £30m for Dirk then?

i dont care - just cause the alkie manc wants to pay 30 mil for him doesnt make him gods gift .

so are we believing managers opinions now then ? or picking and choosing when it suits best ?

I've only asked about this example, so nothing you can accuse me of I'm afraid!!

But didn't you say that top managers' opinions are more reliable than posters on here though? You said something about Van Basten and Rafa I think.

So Slur Alex's opinion is possibly more worthwhile than yours, using your terms I mean.

Nobody would pay £30m for Dirk would they? Be honest.

yes his opinion may well be worthwhile as opposed to mine .

of course no one would pay 30 mil for kuyt - that doesnt make him or not good enough . many times teams have paid over the odds for flashy players . im sure was it hamburg wanted him and were willing to pay 15 mil plus for him .

No, but the original point was that Kuyt scored the same number of goals as Berbatov one season a few years ago - and where we've got to now is the understanding that that fact is completely and utterly irrelevant when it comes to assessing Kuyt's ability.

Case closed.

[puroresu]

Ahem.

*goes for the third attempt*


Is Kuyt a better player than Berbatov or not?

considering everything i think they are about even .

Who do you think would pay £30m for Dirk then?

i dont care - just cause the alkie manc wants to pay 30 mil for him doesnt make him gods gift .

so are we believing managers opinions now then ? or picking and choosing when it suits best ?

I've only asked about this example, so nothing you can accuse me of I'm afraid!!

But didn't you say that top managers' opinions are more reliable than posters on here though? You said something about Van Basten and Rafa I think.

So Slur Alex's opinion is possibly more worthwhile than yours, using your terms I mean.

Nobody would pay £30m for Dirk would they? Be honest.

yes his opinion may well be worthwhile as opposed to mine .

of course no one would pay 30 mil for kuyt - that doesnt make him or not good enough . many times teams have paid over the odds for flashy players . im sure was it hamburg wanted him and were willing to pay 15 mil plus for him .

No that was the insane fee the media said Rafa wanted.  £15 mil for Kuyt.lol