Ciggy wrote:Espionage wrote:But at the end of the day I seriously doubt that Rafa saw anything in Gerrard's recent performances there that would lead him to rethink it as an option.
Its not an option though is it?
Its putting the shackles on our best player, the same as Sven trying to fit Lampard and Gerrard into midfield when it doesnt work.
Play Gerrard on the right or CM let him do the job he is best at bombing forward and scoring cracker goals drawing fouls in and around the area.
We havent had a captain IMO this season because the captain is p.issed off and I dont blame him.
Why not play Alonso or Sissoko out wide?
Why is Gerrard being asked to play in 3 positions this season?
Its doing Liverpool no good, the fans in the Gerrard camp hate it.
Play him where you can get the best out of him or dont play him atall.

stmichael wrote:I was thinking about England''s latest example of how not to play football and I was thinking that much of it boils down to a lack of creativity in the centre of the park. At present Lampard and Hargreaves/Carrick/Parker are stationed there, none of whom have the ability to beat a player and none of whom are great at playing subtle through balls (perhaps Carrick is the exception but as he sits in front of the back four he isn't really in the position to do this).
In some ways this problem is echoed at LFC, where we also stick Gerrard out on the right. The centre is patrolled by Alonso and Sissoko, neither of whom waltz past players for fun. I think Alonso could be a great playmaker if he were higher up the pitch, but as he is mainly around the centre circle he doesn't have the opportunity to split a well-drilled defence. For the moment at least Sissoko simply doesn't have the guile required to do this.
This leaves us with a problem then, as we rely heavily on Gerrard and Gonzalez (or whoever is on the left) for real creativity.
If we compare ourselves with Arsenal and United you can see how they have more creative options through the centre in Scholes and Fabregas, while they also have skilful players in wide positions (Giggs, Ronaldo, Hleb, Ljungberg etc). By sticking with Alonso and Sissoko I think that we can't help but narrow our possibilities of scoring as we don't create enough real chances to score. Although Arsenal haven't been great over the past two seasons they have always created great opportunities, while United struggled when Fergie fiddled with a winning system.
My concern is that to win the league now you have to win more games than ever before, and that means you have to create more opportunities than ever before. While Sissoko and Alonso bring a great stability to the side, I think that they also narrow our options, and could affect our title chances.
Here are some possibilities that I think could be explored:
1) Swap Alonso and Sissoko. Right now Momo doesn't have the awareness to be a flat out DM, but he could surely pick this up. This would allow Alonso to play higher up the pitch and slie balls through to the striker.
2) Rip up the plan and bring in a real DM, like Hargreaves.
3) Play a flat out 4-2-3-1 by either buying a top right winger who scores goals, or by bringing in a Riquelme-like man and keep Gerrard on the right of the 3.
TBH I think all of these options have huge flaws, but I really can't see the current line-up doing enough to win the league.

stmichael wrote:I was thinking about England''s latest example of how not to play football and I was thinking that much of it boils down to a lack of creativity in the centre of the park. At present Lampard and Hargreaves/Carrick/Parker are stationed there, none of whom have the ability to beat a player and none of whom are great at playing subtle through balls (perhaps Carrick is the exception but as he sits in front of the back four he isn't really in the position to do this).
In some ways this problem is echoed at LFC, where we also stick Gerrard out on the right. The centre is patrolled by Alonso and Sissoko, neither of whom waltz past players for fun. I think Alonso could be a great playmaker if he were higher up the pitch, but as he is mainly around the centre circle he doesn't have the opportunity to split a well-drilled defence. For the moment at least Sissoko simply doesn't have the guile required to do this.
This leaves us with a problem then, as we rely heavily on Gerrard and Gonzalez (or whoever is on the left) for real creativity.
If we compare ourselves with Arsenal and United you can see how they have more creative options through the centre in Scholes and Fabregas, while they also have skilful players in wide positions (Giggs, Ronaldo, Hleb, Ljungberg etc). By sticking with Alonso and Sissoko I think that we can't help but narrow our possibilities of scoring as we don't create enough real chances to score. Although Arsenal haven't been great over the past two seasons they have always created great opportunities, while United struggled when Fergie fiddled with a winning system.
My concern is that to win the league now you have to win more games than ever before, and that means you have to create more opportunities than ever before. While Sissoko and Alonso bring a great stability to the side, I think that they also narrow our options, and could affect our title chances.
Here are some possibilities that I think could be explored:
1) Swap Alonso and Sissoko. Right now Momo doesn't have the awareness to be a flat out DM, but he could surely pick this up. This would allow Alonso to play higher up the pitch and slie balls through to the striker.
2) Rip up the plan and bring in a real DM, like Hargreaves.
3) Play a flat out 4-2-3-1 by either buying a top right winger who scores goals, or by bringing in a Riquelme-like man and keep Gerrard on the right of the 3.
TBH I think all of these options have huge flaws, but I really can't see the current line-up doing enough to win the league.





stmichael wrote:it's fair enough saying that we now have more width but we still look as if we don't know how to use it correctly. we don't get in behind teams enough and our wide men tend to cut inside a lot of the time. i like pennant but he has to be encouraged to have more discipline and keep his shape a lot better.
when we get wide in the attacking third we score goals. look at galatasaray as the prime example of this. a lot of the time however, we seem to cross the ball from too deep.


stmichael wrote:
Just bringing this back to the top because I think it's relevant again after yesterday's game.
Once again, if you look at our play, despite controlling the game for long periods, most of our play was in front of their midfield and defence. Not once did we look to get in behind them We had very little penetration, and when we break, we don't seem to counter with much pace, which allows teams to get bodies behind the ball, and then we just stroke the ball around in front of them again.
Contrast this with Manure against Blackburn the other day. Their game is simple but effective. Carrick and Scholes out to Ronaldo or Giggs and then into the box. They are also lightning on the counter attack.
I just don't see us doing this because we don't have any real pace in the side.
Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot] and 312 guests