Liverpool FC Forum

[leeroy74]

Mignolet - 7 - Looked OK
Clyne - 8 - decent job done
Skrtel - 6 - still a decent defender despite an unlucky OG
Lovren - 6 - average to poor
Moreno - 7 - hmmm not a bad show.
Allen - 3 - sell him in Jan. woeful.
Lucas - 3 - sell him in Jan. How many passes to the oppo or out of touch? should not wear the red shirt again.
Milner - 4 - looked tired
Ibe - 7 - Lively little player, at least had a go
Firmino - 3 - tripe.
Benteke - 4 - sell him in Jan

[Penguins]

Mignolet - 6 - did ok
Clyne - 7 - lots of energy but lost the ball by going by himself high up the field
Skrtel - 6 - did ok
Lovren - 6 - Ok I guess
Moreno - 6 - looks good but still a liability at the back
Allen - 4 - bleh
Lucas - 3 - ugh, slow, never liked him
Milner - 5 - looked tired, didn't get much done
Ibe - 6 - energy but too selfish at times
Firmino - 4 - works better with Coutinho and in a counter attacking team
Benteke - 5 - becomes invisible with low service

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 6
Clyne - 6
Skrtel - 6
Lovren - 7 - surprised no one else mentioned Lovren. Thought he was really good yesterday, hardly lost a duel
Moreno - 6
Lucas - 5
Allen - 5
Milner - 5
Ibe - 6
Firmino - 4 - I have a hard time understanding this guy
Benteke - 5 - another "Balotelli" game. Service to him was non-existent though

Subs:
Lallana - 6
Sturridge - 6
Origi - 6

[redshade]

Mignolet - 6
Clyne - 7
Skrtel - 6
Lovren - 6.5
Moreno - 6
Allen - 5
Lucas - 4
Milner - 5
Ibe - 6.5
Firmino - 4
Benteke - 4

Subs

Lallana - 6
Studge - 6
Origi- 5.5

[damjan193]

Newcastle vs. Liverpool player's average (by 11 voters):

Mignolet – 5.9

Clyne – 6.4
Skrtel – 5.4
Lovren - 6
Moreno – 6.1

Lucas - 3.9
Allen - 5

Milner - 4.6
Ibe - 6.2
Firmino - 3.7

Benteke – 4.2

Subs (by 7 voters):

Lallana - 6
Sturridge - 6.1
Origi - 5.6


Newkit man of the match: Nathaniel Clyne
Newkit flop of the match: Roberto Firmino

[RED BEERGOGGLES]

Liverpool v WBA

MIGNOLET -5 Flapped a bit ,but no real help from his defensive backline.
CLYNE -6 Pick of the FB's ,looked to charge forward whenever the opportunity arose.   
SKRTEL -5 Failed to pick up his man and wandered a touch.   
LOVREN -7 Pick of our defence ,intelligent play and looked composed. 
MORENO- 5 Some lovely crosses ,but all over the place at the back ,pulled out of position a few times.
CAN -6 Looked sapped of any real energy 
HENDERSON -7 Took his goal well and tried to support the attack when he could, but needs to break up play more when he's sitting deep.
MILNER -4 Slower than coastal erosion
LALLANA -8 Top man and looked our best chance at grabbing a goal
COUTINHO -6 Lost without Firmino
BENTEKE - 2 Practically excruciating watching him drag our game from what we witnessed at City to this !

[leeroy74]

vs WBA...


MIGNOLET -3 dog Sh*t
CLYNE -6 decent enough 
SKRTEL -5 could've walked if he'd made contact. Looked rushed.   
LOVREN -6 improved, get well soon. 
MORENO- 5 average game
CAN -5 average game
HENDERSON -7 Looked up for it!
MILNER -4 dog Sh*t
LALLANA -8 good game
COUTINHO -6 not sure, average at best
BENTEKE - 2 dog Sh*t

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 5 - has to be his goal but he doesn't get any help from our defenders
Clyne - 6
Skrtel - 5
Lovren - 6
Moreno - 5
Can - 5
Henderson - 7
Milner - 4 - useless player. I think I might have a better first touch than him
Lallana - 7 - at least Adam seems to have found some consistency under Klopp. That one on one miss was horrible though. Had he scored we might have won it.
Coutinho - 6
Benteke - 4 - missed plenty of chances and not even close to the same wavelength with Coutinho and co.

Subs:

Ibe - 5
Origi - 6
Firmino - n/a

[ycsatbjywtbiastkamb]

MINGOLET - 4 starting to become a liability, needs to up his game significantly
CLYNE - 6 played quite well I thought
SKRTEL - 5 probably his worst performance in a good while, could have easily have gone for a two footed challenge
LOVREN - 7 on form currently our best CB, on the end of a horror tackle
MORENO - 6 steady enough
HENDERSON - 6 plenty of energy and did well for the goal but touch seemed a bit off
CAN - 5 tried hard but just lacked that spark
MILNER - 4 I'm actually surprised Klopp plays him in so many big games
LALLANA - 6 played well but I deducted a point for that miss, £25m players have got to be putting one on ones away.
COUTINHO - 6 not at his best but great to have him back
BENTEKE - 5 gets an extra point for the superb through ball to put Lallana through but generally wasn't at the races

[SkippyRed]

Mignolet - 2 - Terrible. He basically had one thing to do all game and he ***** it. And why didn't he let the ball go for a throw in.
Cyne - 5 - Needs a longer rest. Looked ***** on the ball.
Skrtle - 6 - Ok
Lovren - 5 - Not his best game. Hope the injury isn't nasty.
Moreno - 5 - Did he play?
Milner - 5 - *****
Henderson - 7.5 - Great to have him back.
Can - 6 - Solid without being spectacular.
Lallana - 6 - Meh
Coutinho - 7 - Our only spark
Benteke - 5 - Needs to be on the bench

Subs

Ibe - 4 - No impact
Origi - 7 - Full of energy and a nice goal.
Firmino - n/a

[redshade]

Mignolet - 2
Cyne - 5
Skrtle - 5.5
Lovren - 5.5
Moreno - 5
Milner - 4
Hendo- 6.5
Can - 6
Lallana - 6
Coutinho - 6.5
Benteke - 4

Subs

Ibe - 5
Origi - 7
Firmino - n/a

[damjan193]

Liverpool vs WBA player's average (by 6 voters):

Mignolet – 3.5

Clyne – 5.7
Skrtel – 5.2
Lovren - 6.1
Moreno – 5.2

Can - 5.5
Henderson - 6.8

Milner - 4.2
Lallana - 6.8
Coutinho - 6.2

Benteke – 3.7

Subs (by 3 voters):

Ibe - 4.7
Origi - 6.7
Firmino - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Jordan Henderson and Adam Lallana
Newkit flop of the match: Simon Mignolet

[C-R]

Watford V Liverpool - EPL - 20/12/15

Well let me start this off

Bogdan - 2 - not an upgrade on Mong, we definately need a new keeper, no further discussion required
Clyne - 4 - poorest game for us
Skrtel - 4 - poor before he went off, poor defending for their 2nd goal
Sakho - 3 - could tell he had been out for a while and looked well off the pace
Moreno - 5 - thought he was better than the other 3 but still not good enough
Henderson - 6 - made some decent passes, could have scored but for a great save
Lucas - 3 - utter Sh*t, boy against men
Can - 4 - poor
Lallana - 3 - inaffective, 25 million
Coutinho - 5 - must be wondering what it's like in Madird or Barcelona
Firmino - 1 - can i rate a zero ?

Subs...

Ibe - 5 - no time to impact match
Origi - 5 - no real time to impact but looked way better than Firmino
Benteke - 5 - nothing for him today

[Penguins]

Bogdan - 3 - even worse than mig, says everything
Clyne - 4 - ugh
Skrtel - 4 - just bad
Sakho - 2 - worst performance in a red shirt
Moreno - 5 - wasn't pisspoor
Henderson - 6 - did what Henderson always do.
Lucas - 2 - never liked this overrated conman
Can - 4 - always either or with him. A risk taker no matter where on the field.
Lallana - 3 - so weak, 0 goal threat
Coutinho - 5 - never got into the game
Firmino - 1 - unless he starts to learn that you get stuck in in this league, he can pack his bags.

Subs
Ibe - 5 - no time
Origi - 5 - meh
Benteke - 5 - Heskey did what Heskey does

[Thommo's perm]

Bogdan - 3 - nervous and ineffectual. Should have held on to the ball for the first goal, but had no chance with the second and third. Made a good save, but generally poor
Clyne - 2 - getting worse
Skrtel - 3 - looking more and more fragile as pressure builds on him to perform
Sakho - 4 - tried hard, some good passing but nowhere near good enough
Moreno - 3 - little bit better than usual
Henderson - 4 - tried hard but too erratic
Lucas - 2 - back to square one
Can - 3 - needs to control his temper and concentrate on the game rather than moaning at the ref
Lallana - 3 - ran round quite a lot
Coutinho - 4 - needs to do more and stop blaming others
Firmino - 1 - virtually anonymous and a waste of a place on the pitch

Subs...

Ibe - 3 - no firm plan
Origi - 3 - not really as threatening as he should be
Benteke - 3 - has lost any confidence he had and looks like he deosnt know what to do