Liverpool FC Forum

[damjan193]

Newkit player of the month OCTOBER

Games:

Sion (H)
Everton (A)
Tottenham (A)
Rubin Kazan (H)
Southampton (H)
Bournemouth (H)
Chelsea (A)

Candidate:                        Rating:                   Games played:

Simon Mignolet                      6.7                         6 
Martin Skrtel                          6.2                        6 (started 5)
Mamadou Sakho                     7.4                         5
Lucas Leiva                            6.5                         6 (started 4)
Roberto Firmino                     6.5                         4 (started 2)



And the winner is..........    MAMADOU SAKHO - A no-brainer for this month that's for sure. The ovations he got from the fans after every match says enough.

[ycsatbjywtbiastkamb]

Great work as per usual mate! 

FC RUBIN V LIVERPOOL

MINGOLET - 6 barely had anything to do
CLYNE - 7 starting to get forward more which is great to see, looking more comfortable on the ball too
LOVREN - 7 played well
SAKHO - 7 one or two misplaced passes but this fella is absolutely key to how we play, great player
MORENO - 6 played well
ALLEN - 7 worked hard and did well
CAN - 7 same as ALLEN, put a real shift in
MILNER - 6 unlucky with effort that hit the post
IBE - 7 looking more like his old self and well taken goal
FIRMINO - 7 starting to look a class act, his link up play is very impressive
BENTEKE - 6 tried hard to get on the scoresheet but wasn't quite his night

[SkippyRed]

Mignolet - 6 - Clean sheet. Was probably bored out of his brains.
Clyne - 7 - Better defensively, got forward nicely.
Lovren- 7 - Good game from him.
Sakho - 8 - Beast. Hopefully his limp was nothing more than a slight knock.
Moreno - 6.5 - I just don't see it in this guy.
Allen - 7 - Worked hard, played the Lucas role very well.
Can - 7.5 - Worked his ***** off. Getting better and better as time goes by.
Milner - 6 - Apart from one shot on goal was again a pain in the *****.
Ibe - 8.5 - Very good game. Scored off a direct run.
Firmino - 8 - Absolute class act. 2 Assists in 2 games now. Starting to get his comfort zone.
Benteke - 6.5 Tried hard, good to get a decent run for his legs. Probably deserved a goal just wasn't his night.

Lallana - 6 - Does what he does best. Run and make a nuisance of himself.
Lucas N/A
Skrtle N/A

[andy_g]

i'm giving everyone a 7
nice, snappy and energetic performances all round. if the forwards and mids had done better with some of those final balls then there would be a couple of 8s.

[C-R]

MINGOLET - 6
CLYNE - 6
LOVREN - 6
SAKHO - 8.5 - hope Klopp makes him captain
MORENO - 6
ALLEN - 5
CAN - 6
MILNER - 4
IBE - 8
FIRMINO - 7
BENTEKE - 6

[only me]

MINGOLET - 6 ;unemployed
CLYNE - 7 ;another energetic display
LOVREN - 7; surprisingly solid
SAKHO - 8 - standard
MORENO - 5 avarage
ALLEN - 7 should be the starting CM
CAN - 6 energetic with no end product
MILNER - 5 heavy on the ball
IBE - 8 MOTM
FIRMINO - 7 involved but lacked sharpness
BENTEKE - 6 ok

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 6
Clyne - 7
Lovren - 7
Sakho - 7
Moreno - 6
Allen - 6
Can - 7
Milner - 6
Ibe - 8
Firmino - 7
Benteke - 6

Subs:
Lallana - 6

[damjan193]

i'm giving everyone a 7
nice, snappy and energetic performances all round. if the forwards and mids had done better with some of those final balls then there would be a couple of 8s.

I'll take this one, but from now on everyone who wants to have their ratings considered in the averages will have to post them in the standard form like everybody else does it. Don't want to lay down any "rules" but we have to have some.

[kazza]

Mignolet - 7
Clyne - 7
Lovren - 7
Sakho - 8
Moreno - 6
Allen - 7
Can - 7
Milner - 6
Ibe - 8
Firmino - 7
Benteke - 6

Subs:
Lallana - 6

[damjan193]

Rubin Kazan vs. Liverpool player's average (by 7 voters):

Mignolet – 6.3

Clyne – 6.9
Lovren - 6.9
Sakho – 7.6
Moreno – 6.1

Allen - 6.6
Can – 6.8
Milner – 5.7

Ibe - 7.8
Firmino - 7.1

Benteke – 6.2

Subs (by 3 voters):

Lallana - 6
Lucas - N/A
Skrtel - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Jordan Ibe
Newkit flop of the match: James Milner

[C-R]

Liverpool V Crystal Palace - Sunday 8th November - EPL

Mignolet - 4 - responsible for 2nd goal, cost us the game (again)
Clyne - 6 - thought he had a decent match
Skrtel - 6 - solid
Sakho - 6 - solid before his injury, hope he is back soon
Moreno - 4 - another woeful defence performance
Lucas - 6 - decent match without being more than average
Emre Can - 4 - not a great performance, responsible for not clearing the ball for their first goal
Lallana - 6 - did well enough, seemed to duck under the ball when he had a chance to score
Ibe - 6 - really good in first half, seemed to have run out of steam in the second half
Coutinho - 7 - really decent performance, worked hard, got a nicely taken goal
Benteke - 5 - very poor taken, poor finishing, poor hold up play

Subs:
Lovren - 6 - solid enough
Firmino - 5 - cameo appearence
Origi - 4 - not really on long enough to rate properly, can only remember one play where he gave the ball away

[SkippyRed]

Migs - 5 - ***** game
Clyne - 7.5 - Great defender, needs to find his offensive mojo again
Skrtle - 6 - Went into a shelter when Sakho went off
Sakho - 5 - Did nothing wrong, just injured.
Moreno - 4 - Really don't rate him. For a fullback he is absolutely terrible.
Lucas - 5 - One of his worst performances of the year.
Can - 5 - See Lucas
Coutinho - 8 - Nice goal, only player who looked threatening
Lallana - 7 Good game, but he still does things that annoy the ***** out of me.
Ibe - 7 - Played direct and made some nice runs. Needs work on his crosses and passing into the box. Great movement.
Benteke - 5 - See Can and Lucas

Lovren - 6 - Makes me nervous
Firmino - 6 - Needed to come on earlier, but not for Can.
Origi N/A

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 5
Clyne - 6
Skrtel - 6
Sakho - 6
Moreno - 5
Lucas - 6
Can - 4
Lallana - 6
Ibe - 7
Coutinho - 7
Benteke - 5

Subs;
Lovren - 6
Firmino - 6

[damjan193]

Liverpool vs. Crystal Palace player's average (by 3 voters):

Mignolet – 4.7

Clyne – 6.5
Skrtel – 6
Sakho – 5.7
Moreno – 4.3

Lucas – 5.7
Can – 4.3

Lallana – 6.3
Ibe - 6.7
Coutinho – 7.3

Benteke – 5

Subs (by 3 voters):

Lovren – 6
Firmino - 5.7
Origi - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Philippe Coutinho
Newkit flop of the match: Alberto Moreno and Emre Can

[ycsatbjywtbiastkamb]

Liverpool vs. Crystal Palace player's average (by 3 voters):

Mignolet – 4.7

Clyne – 6.5
Skrtel – 6
Sakho – 5.7
Moreno – 4.3

Lucas – 5.7
Can – 4.3

Lallana – 6.3
Ibe - 6.7
Coutinho – 7.3

Benteke – 5

Subs (by 3 voters):

Lovren – 6
Firmino - 5.7
Origi - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Philippe Coutinho
Newkit flop of the match: Alberto Moreno and Emre Can

Cheers mate, I only listened to the game on the radio and wasn't really in a position to give player ratings. Thanks for your efforts though, much appreciated