Liverpool FC Forum

[RED BEERGOGGLES]

Mingolet - 6 A better game for Mignolet today ,little to do ,but reacted well when called upon. 
Manquillo - 6 Decent, solid,and dependable .its all you can ask from a RB   
Lovren -7 Best premiership game thus far
Skrtel - 6 Definitely the man to partner Lovren
Moreno - 7 Lukaku is a real handful but this kid really shown the defensive side of his game is equal to his offensive.
Gerrard - 5 Significantly better game than his last and decent free kick ,but better teams than the Bitterz will target his inertia
Henderson - 8 My man of the match,slowly crawling back to last seasons form
Lallana - 6 Handed  us back the ingenuity we have been missing of late.
Sterling - 6 His final ball is appalling ,but with work he can become the complete player
Balotelli - 6 Looked slightly overawed with the importance of the occasion,but competed well and should have scored. 
Markovic - 5 Put your money on the Slow burners ,they always turn into Kop favourites.

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 6
Manquillo - 7 - opposition couldn't get past him, fantastic defender this lad
Skrtel - 7
Lovren - 7 - good game, let Lukaku get behind him on one occasion but other than that a great game
Moreno - 7
Gerrard - 7 - OK game, point plus for the goal
Henderson - 7 - I think he did the job of 3 players. He passed it well and ran his socks off.
Lallana - 6 - looking like he's settling in
Sterling - 6 - agreed with what others are saying, should work on his final ball. Still an ok game though
Markovic - 5 - had some decent runs but obviously not used to the league yet
Balotelli - 6 - worked hard but should have really scored at least one

Subs:
Coutinho - 6 - looked lively. Should start against Basel IMO

[LFC1990]

Mig- 5 Had nothing to do but when did seem to fucvk it up
Manquillo - 7 Played very well defensive and attack
Lovren - 7 Commanding starting to look the player we bought
Skrtel - 7 Dominated defence with his partner
Moreno - 7 Justmisses out on My motm but played very well
Gerrard - 6 looked alot better as noone was picking him up took the free kick well
Henderson - 7 Another candidate for MOTM controlled the midfield and links defence to attack well
Lallana- 8 For me the best player on the pitch If Balotelli had his shooting boots on this kid would have had a few assists to his name
Markovic- 4 A real lack of confidence
Sterling - 5 Not his best game for us
Balotelli - 5 only got as high as a five as he nearly scored but for a great save by howard constantly out of position and only wants to shoot from 20 yards +

[woof woof !]

If a member finds their post has been deleted in this thread it's probably because they've ignored a simple request.

REMINDER

Give your player rating and try to keep your "comment" brief. More in depth analysis (and argument) can be explored in actual match or individual player thread.

[woof woof !]

Mignolet - 6 - ok
Manquillo - 6 - ok
Skrtel - 6 - ok
Lovren - 6 - ok
Moreno - 7 - generally did well
Gerrard - 7 - good game, great freekick
Henderson - 7 - good game none stop chasing and harrying
Lallana - 7 - good game, hopefully there's more to come
Sterling - 6 - did well but not quite up to his usual standard
Markovic - 4 - poor, should have been taken off much much earlier
Balotelli - 6 - disappointing, again !

Subs:
Coutinho - 6 - did ok,

[damjan193]

Liverpool vs Everton player's average (by 7 voters):

Mignolet - 5.5

Manquillo - 6.1
Skrtel - 6.2
Lovren - 6.7
Moreno - 6.1

Gerrard - 6.1
Henderson - 6.7

Sterling - 6.1
Lallana - 6.5
Markovic - 4.1

Balotelli - 6.1

Subs (by 4 voters):

Coutinho - 6

Newkit man of the match: Dejan Lovren and Jordan Henderson
Newkit flop of the match: Lazar Markovic

[ycsatbjywtbiastkamb]

BASEL V LIVERPOOL

Mingolet - 7 had a good game tbh, made some good saves and was unlucky with the goal
Manquillo - 7 probably the pick of the back 4 on the night, gets caught upfield every now and then but that's the price of having fullbacks that like to press high up the pitch and join in attacks
Skrtel - 5 not sure what he was doing for their goal
Lovren - 6 steady performance
Enrique - 5 all the trouble seemed to come down his flank, not his best game
Gerrard - 5 doesn't offer the team much these days, looked laboured when the opposition ran at him
Henderson - 5 part of a midfield that didn't impose themselves on the game
Coutinho - 6 not back to his best yet but there were one or two signs that he's on his way back
Sterling - 3 had a 'mare, probably his worst performance as a pro
Balotelli - 6 linked up well but living off scraps ATM
Markovic - 5 made a couple of good driving runs with the ball but poor end product

[only me]

ingolet - 6, not much to do had a couple of good saves.
Manquillo - 5 ,not much to do but handled his side pretty ok
Skrtel - 4 typical skertel ,the little he had to handle he failed
Lovren - 4 had enough of this wnker he can work on his confidence on the bench
Enrique - 3 was overrun all day long
Gerrard - 3 total lack of leadership in addition to another poor performance
Henderson - 4 ,if you want to run lad join the marathon ,football has more to offer then just running.
Coutinho - 4 another up and down performance ,lacked composure and focus ,working with a lazy striker makes his life difficult
Sterling - 2 couldn't have a worse game if he designed one ,The Boro match and this match reduced the lad to rubble.
Balotelli - 4 if football was an Island MArio would be Greenland ,but as this is a group game he is just par average idiot.
Markovic - 3 maybe he doesnt want to play for liverpool FC or just lacks a pair of balls.

BR - Wake up man your team is failing on all fronts ,on the pitch ,off the pitch ,Mentally ,tactics ,everything is wrong and guess what? You are responsible.

[LFC1990]

Mig - 5  wasnt really tested
Manquillo - 7 Our best player last night Defensive and attack
Lovren - 6
Skrtel - 6
Enrique - 3 Not sure if its because he hasnt played for a while but doesnt look like a footballer
Henderson - 5 Not a good game
Gerrard - 3 No point in keep saying it byt the guy needs to have a spell on the bench
Coutinho - 6 He started well got a great passing range drifted off
Markovic - 6 again he started well and seemed to battle more
Sterling - 2  /ill put it down to burn out
Balotelli - 4 It seems as if its either he scores or noone is allowed. Rarely moves and will not pass

[RED BEERGOGGLES]

Mignolet - 6 Made some important stops.   
Manquillo - 7 A sprig of hope betwixt the nettles.
Lovren - 5 Decent performance 
Skrtel - 4 Seemed OK until the involuntary spasms that accompany the obligatory 'set piece' 
Enrique - 2 Completely dire ,Instagram must have missed his input    Another strange inclusion.
Henderson - 4 Never really pushed the game like he's capable of ....lacklustre
Gerrard -3 Disappointed he leaves his rants at the team till he's off the pitch in front of Sky cameras ,we need a captain who voices his opinions on the pitch. 
Coutinho - 5 Looked less hurried ,but still way off the pace though ,and his inclusion was a complete head scratcher.   
Markovic - 6 Again he showed glimpses ,but playing in a team that currently look like strangers and devoid of confidence.   
Sterling - 2 Frustratingly it seems like Raheem has reverted back to falling over and losing  the ball with annoying regularity.   
Balotelli - 6 Worked hard ,but he would have to be 'Christ like' to score with the service he is currently receiving .

[damjan193]

Basel vs Liverpool player's average (by 4 voters):

Mignolet - 6

Manquillo - 6.5
Skrtel - 4.7
Lovren - 5.2
Enrique - 3.2

Gerrard - 3.5
Henderson - 4.5

Sterling - 2.2
Coutinho - 5.2
Markovic - 5

Balotelli - 5


Newkit man of the match: Javier Manquillo
Newkit flop of the match: Raheem Sterling

[C-R]

Liverpool V WBA - 4th October

Mignolet - 5 - did ok, why does he persist in parrying the ball instead of catching it ?
Manquillo - 5 - not great and was subbed as a consequence
Moreno - 6 - looked a bit better today
Lovren - 5 - still not looking like a 20 million £ player, shaky again
Skrtel - 6 - did ok, better of the pair
Gerrard - 7 - thought he had a decent match today
Henderson - 8 - getting back to his best and took his goal well
Lallana - 9 - my man of the match, played really well, chased every ball and scored an excellent goal
Coutinho - 6 - getting back to his normal quality
Sterling - 6 - was ok, seemed defenders were doubling up on him at times, wastes a couple of decent chances
Lambert - 4 - poor all round

Substitutes:

Johnson - 5 - did ok, better off he left though
Lucas - 5 - same as Johnson, very greedy and wasted 2 good chances
Balotelli - 4 - poor again

[damjan193]

Mignolet - 6
Manquillo - 6 - did well defensively as usual but awful going forward and his inexperience showed for their goal
Skrtel - 6 - part of a really dodgy defense but did better than Lovren at least
Lovren - 5 - starts to ***** me off a bit. It's not just that he can be really dodgy sometimes, but it seems to me that he doesn't accept his mistakes and blames everyone else instead
Moreno - 6
Gerrard - 7 - a really good game for him, good passing and played well defensively tracking back players. Loved his little cameo further forward as well
Henderson - 9 - MOTM no doubt. Performed well, made an assist and scored a goal.
Sterling - 7 - needs a rest as soon as possible. Good assist though
Coutinho - 6
Lallana - 8 - getting better and better. Performed well and scored a good goal
Lambert - 5 - found himself in some good positions but didn't contribute a lot

Subs:
Johnson - 6 - did OK, hopefully he won't replace Manquillo though
Lucas - 6
Balotelli - 6 - I though he did pretty good, worked very hard, found himself in some good positions and linked up well with the others

[only me]

Mignolet - 6 , did ok ,not much required but was alert when needed
Manquillo - 6 - ok
Skrtel - 6 - ok
Lovren - 4 - Bench him already ,not only the penalty but also lost his player a couple of times which could have resulted in a goal.
Moreno - 6 - ok
Gerrard - 7 - Much Better today ,involved positive really dictated good pace
Henderson - 8 - Great effort ,involved in both goals.
Sterling - 4 - Poor again ,confidence really down.
Coutinho - 5 - I don't know if it's the formation but he isn't really making an impact.
Lallana - 9 - my MOTM ,all over the place with a goal to show for ,really showed passion and desire ,an easy pick as a starter for me.
Lambert - 5  - Formation doesn't help him but could have made much more of the chance he was given today.

Subs:
Johnson - 5 - i don't care ,shouldn't be playing.
Lucas - 5- see johnson
Balotelli - 6 - ok

[ycsatbjywtbiastkamb]

Mingolet - 7 decent performance again, not his biggest fan but he has upped his game in recent weeks
Manquillo - 6 steady performance, gave the ball away for their goal but a lot still had to happen, it wasn't a clanger.
Skrtel - 6 still looks a bit rusty but a solid enough display
Lovren - 4 bit unlucky with the pen but his propensity to dive into tackles was always going to come and bite us on the @rse one day. Lucky to be seen as nailed on starter IMO.
Moreno - 6 one of his quieter days but still solid
Gerrard - 7 best performance so far this season IMO, still a bit worrying how much of the play West Brom's midfield had though
Hendo - 7 gets extra marks for the winner but like Gerrard a good individual performance must be tempered by the fact that one of the lesser lights of the division came to Anfield and had a lot of the ball.
Coutinho - 5 trying hard to find his game but not quite there yet
Sterling - 5 trying hard himself but his touch and ball control seem to have completely deserted him.
Lambert - 5 I think he'd be more suited to games where we are dominating and have teams pinned back in their own box. West Brom had too much of the ball to suit his style.
Lallana - 8 he looks the best player at the club ATM, terrific goal, silky skills and a willingness to put a real shift in. He's stood up to be counted when there's been a lot of flak flying around too so he's obviously got a bit about him in terms of character.