My indictment of the rafa benitez regime

Liverpool Football Club - General Discussion

Postby ruskiy playmaker » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:22 pm

puroresu wrote:
ruskiy playmaker wrote:
metalhead wrote:True s@int, but one the games was the F.A cup, against Havant

Key players this season were hardly rotated when Benitez learned that he can't drop them after the portsmouth game. Only during F.A and carling cup games our key players were rested.

However, this complete rotating of the squad players is bollox.

Very true, but I think the reason he rotates the wide players so much is because there's not enough quality in those areas.  It may be Rafa's fault but I think that if he was allowed to buy Alves and Simao we would rarely see them get rotated.

There is no maybe about it.  He persists with Harry Kewell even though Kewell has done nothing.  He paid to much for pennant and for that money could of found someone else.  He signs Babel for £12 mil and he doesnt know what to do with him. He gives him a go out on the left and then drops him. A few weeks later its Babel's time again.  He signed Leto who seems to have dropped from the face of the earth.  He signed Gonzales who was supposed to be the next big thing and within a year his sold.  He bought Yossi who has never been and will never be a true winger.  We have had problems in the wide positions for years and Rafa has not resolved these problems.

All I'm saying on this is, if it were not for that Clown running the negotiations we would have guys like Malouda and Alves right now instead of Pennant and Yossi.  And I don't think that Rafa would rotate them.
[img]http://i42.tinypic.com/lkw42.gif[img]
User avatar
ruskiy playmaker
 
Posts: 2159
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 8:29 pm
Location: USA

Postby megabomberman » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:31 pm

This whole Rafa not wanting the league thing is now bordering on ridiculous....

Some fans here are impatient, they believe rafa isn't good enough to guide liverpool and I respect your opinions on that, they are valid...

But when this bullcrap about rafa not wanting to win the league come out, you have to think its so pathetic, the anti rafa brigade will twist and turn at anything to heap everyone against him to force him out...

Rafa doesn't want the league! What a load of BS... Reina, Hypia, Carra, Gerrard, Masch and Torres have practically played everygame in the league this season, and don't come balling to me about fratton park where torres got a solitary rest by god he could do with one now, but of course all you lot would be on here ranting about it in 2 months time saying remem when benitez rested torres! Rafa obviously cares about the bread and butter, we're just not good enough yet, how could we be, Rafas fighting against a hill, Arsenal/chelsea/man utd all have advantages in one way or another, in terms of squad value, manager time spent there, youth set ups or transfer kittys... For Rafa to overcome this he needs time..

Like the way his most expensive winger is babel for around 10mill (the amount chelsea pay for fullbacks), and most expensive left back signing was how much? FREE! Get a grip, the funds will be transfered to where he needs it most in due time! You hardly expect him to go and fill every position with quality right away with the money he's been given, whilst trying to get cover for injuries...

When Rafas finished, we won't be able to argue that the team doesn't care about the league because the squad will be so awesome it won't be possible to come accross that way..
megabomberman
 
Posts: 10
Joined: Mon Feb 04, 2008 3:32 pm

Postby ruskiy playmaker » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:38 pm

megabomberman wrote:This whole Rafa not wanting the league thing is now bordering on ridiculous....

Some fans here are impatient, they believe rafa isn't good enough to guide liverpool and I respect your opinions on that, they are valid...

But when this bullcrap about rafa not wanting to win the league come out, you have to think its so pathetic, the anti rafa brigade will twist and turn at anything to heap everyone against him to force him out...

Rafa doesn't want the league! What a load of BS... Reina, Hypia, Carra, Gerrard, Masch and Torres have practically played everygame in the league this season, and don't come balling to me about fratton park where torres got a solitary rest by god he could do with one now, but of course all you lot would be on here ranting about it in 2 months time saying remem when benitez rested torres! Rafa obviously cares about the bread and butter, we're just not good enough yet, how could we be, Rafas fighting against a hill, Arsenal/chelsea/man utd all have advantages in one way or another, in terms of squad value, manager time spent there, youth set ups or transfer kittys... For Rafa to overcome this he needs time..

Like the way his most expensive winger is babel for around 10mill (the amount chelsea pay for fullbacks), and most expensive left back signing was how much? FREE! Get a grip, the funds will be transfered to where he needs it most in due time! You hardly expect him to go and fill every position with quality right away with the money he's been given, whilst trying to get cover for injuries...

When Rafas finished, we won't be able to argue that the team doesn't care about the league because the squad will be so awesome it won't be possible to come accross that way..

I completely agree, people who bash Rafa seem to forget that the other teams are also improving and their managers have much better support from their owners.  How they don't see that is impossible for me to understand.
[img]http://i42.tinypic.com/lkw42.gif[img]
User avatar
ruskiy playmaker
 
Posts: 2159
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 8:29 pm
Location: USA

Postby nobybob » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:40 pm

Remembering also that his options to rotate have been limited by injuries to Alonso, Agger, and the atrocious form of Kuyt and Voronin.


In my opinion it is BECAUSE of injuries to ALONSO and AGGER and the bad form of KUYT and VORONIN that rafa has rotated so much this season. I feel Alonso and agger injury free and in form would be nailed on to start every game.
rafa is still trying to find the ideal partner for Torres (who plays every game now incidentally) hence the swapping from the out of form KUYT and voronin with the less than ideal crouch. non of these  IMO will in the long run provide the answer.

pennant is a difficult one because at times he really impresses only to swiftly fall back into mediocrity. I think much of the right wing problem is down to GERRARD because rafa has previously come under a lot of stick, for using GERRARD on the right and not in the centre were he is undoubtedly one of the best in the world. SO  rafa has given in to the pressure and played him in the middle . OK but he is also our best option on the right by a long way, he should go back right even if he does moan about it because with Alonso macha and Lucas we would still have a great midfield and the team would be so much more balanced
User avatar
nobybob
 
Posts: 418
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 1:36 pm
Location: liverpool

Postby heimdall » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:40 pm

megabomberman wrote:This whole Rafa not wanting the league thing is now bordering on ridiculous....

Some fans here are impatient, they believe rafa isn't good enough to guide liverpool and I respect your opinions on that, they are valid...

But when this bullcrap about rafa not wanting to win the league come out, you have to think its so pathetic, the anti rafa brigade will twist and turn at anything to heap everyone against him to force him out...

Rafa doesn't want the league! What a load of BS... Reina, Hypia, Carra, Gerrard, Masch and Torres have practically played everygame in the league this season, and don't come balling to me about fratton park where torres got a solitary rest by god he could do with one now, but of course all you lot would be on here ranting about it in 2 months time saying remem when benitez rested torres! Rafa obviously cares about the bread and butter, we're just not good enough yet, how could we be, Rafas fighting against a hill, Arsenal/chelsea/man utd all have advantages in one way or another, in terms of squad value, manager time spent there, youth set ups or transfer kittys... For Rafa to overcome this he needs time..

Like the way his most expensive winger is babel for around 10mill (the amount chelsea pay for fullbacks), and most expensive left back signing was how much? FREE! Get a grip, the funds will be transfered to where he needs it most in due time! You hardly expect him to go and fill every position with quality right away with the money he's been given, whilst trying to get cover for injuries...

When Rafas finished, we won't be able to argue that the team doesn't care about the league because the squad will be so awesome it won't be possible to come accross that way..

I have never said that Rafa doesn't want to league but he is better suited at managing us in Europe where he is very good, no question.

What I blame Rafa for are his baffling decisions like playing Kuyt and Kewell week in week out, I bet you here and now that Kuyt starts against Chelsea. But also weird decisions like in the Reading game where he took off Stevie and Torres when we needed goals.

Rafa makes far too many mistakes in the league for my liking and he has had plenty of money to buy good players but keeps buying the wrong ones. I mean what is his fetish with central midfield players, how many do we really need??
User avatar
heimdall
 
Posts: 4971
Joined: Tue Oct 24, 2006 1:51 pm
Location: London

Postby puroresu » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:45 pm

Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.
User avatar
puroresu
 
Posts: 3070
Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2006 10:30 am

Postby nobybob » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:50 pm

puroresu wrote:Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.

yes he has spent money but he did not have the option to spend vast amounts on one player like some of the other teams he has had many positions to fill and has done the  best he could with the money available to spend on that position
User avatar
nobybob
 
Posts: 418
Joined: Sun Jul 01, 2007 1:36 pm
Location: liverpool

Postby account deleted by request » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:53 pm

OK but he is also our best option on the right by a long way, he should go back right even if he does moan about it


Why does everyone condemn Gerrard for wanting to play in his best position, yet Carra was clearly very upset at having to play full back "for the good of the team", yet no one seems to want to mention that?
account deleted by request
 
Posts: 20690
Joined: Sun Apr 30, 2006 5:11 am

Postby puroresu » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:54 pm

nobybob wrote:
puroresu wrote:Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.

yes he has spent money but he did not have the option to spend vast amounts on one player like some of the other teams he has had many positions to fill and has done the  best he could with the money available to spend on that position

Kuyt - Waste.  Could of got better.
Pennant - Could of got better
Vorinin - Free.  Waste of space
Aurelio - Free.  Waste of space
Babel - overpriced but has potential if Rafa finally understands how to use him.

U may think Rafa has done all he can do in the transfer market but I think his failed to find gems on the cheap with the money his had.  He knew what his budget would be like when he came here and has failed to use the funds to find enough quality.  Instead wasting it on poorer players.
User avatar
puroresu
 
Posts: 3070
Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2006 10:30 am

Postby account deleted by request » Tue Feb 05, 2008 2:58 pm

nobybob wrote:
Remembering also that his options to rotate have been limited by injuries to Alonso, Agger, and the atrocious form of Kuyt and Voronin.


In my opinion it is BECAUSE of injuries to ALONSO and AGGER and the bad form of KUYT and VORONIN that rafa has rotated so much this season. I feel Alonso and agger injury free and in form would be nailed on to start every game.
rafa is still trying to find the ideal partner for Torres (who plays every game now incidentally) hence the swapping from the out of form KUYT and voronin with the less than ideal crouch. non of these  IMO will in the long run provide the answer.

pennant is a difficult one because at times he really impresses only to swiftly fall back into mediocrity. I think much of the right wing problem is down to GERRARD because rafa has previously come under a lot of stick, for using GERRARD on the right and not in the centre were he is undoubtedly one of the best in the world. SO  rafa has given in to the pressure and played him in the middle . OK but he is also our best option on the right by a long way, he should go back right even if he does moan about it because with Alonso macha and Lucas we would still have a great midfield and the team would be so much more balanced

You have as much chance getting Rafa to stop rotating as Kuyt scoring 20 goals this season.

Alonso in front of Mascherano..... bit like picking Voronin infront of Torres

Torres (who plays every game now incidentally


And this is different to him picking Kuyt every game last season....... how?
account deleted by request
 
Posts: 20690
Joined: Sun Apr 30, 2006 5:11 am

Postby ruskiy playmaker » Tue Feb 05, 2008 3:08 pm

puroresu wrote:Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.

I agree with you on this but there are very few known managers in the world who could do what Wenger does.  Sure I'd like to see Rafa go out and buy the next Hleb instead of Pennant, but you have to understand that even the best managers like Fergie need lots of money to buy quality talents nowadays.  When Rafa buys Babel-10.5,Lucas-8, Fergie buys Nani-14,Anderson-18.  How do you expect us to overtake Man U, when it's clear that they have a much bigger budget than us?
[img]http://i42.tinypic.com/lkw42.gif[img]
User avatar
ruskiy playmaker
 
Posts: 2159
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 8:29 pm
Location: USA

Postby dawson99 » Tue Feb 05, 2008 3:37 pm

wwouldnt call aurelio a waste of space by far.
but we have had decent funds, and overall we have spent badly. we could have had malouda but rafa goes for quantity not quality
0118 999 881 999 119 7253
Image
User avatar
dawson99
>> LFC Elite Member <<
 
Posts: 25377
Joined: Mon Apr 19, 2004 12:56 pm
Location: in the mo fo hood y'all

Postby Bammo » Tue Feb 05, 2008 3:44 pm

Not sure we could have had Malouda once Chelsea declared their interest. In interviews he was positive about Liverpool, then when Chelsea announced they wanted him theywere suddenly the only team for him.

He gave the distinct impression he was moving for money and not just football. If we want top players then we need to offer something other teams can't. It won't be a regular starting place :p and we're underperforming at the moment. The spanish element attracts players from Spain but what else is there to offer? History appeals to fans but not players.
Twitter[url=http://twitter.com/IanBamford[/URL]Lego Pirates:
[URL=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v....o0]http[/url]

Scallies: http://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=SRWxvm_HNQU
User avatar
Bammo
LFC Super Member
 
Posts: 995
Joined: Tue Mar 06, 2007 3:26 pm
Location: Chester

Postby puroresu » Tue Feb 05, 2008 3:52 pm

ruskiy playmaker wrote:
puroresu wrote:Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.

I agree with you on this but there are very few known managers in the world who could do what Wenger does.  Sure I'd like to see Rafa go out and buy the next Hleb instead of Pennant, but you have to understand that even the best managers like Fergie need lots of money to buy quality talents nowadays.  When Rafa buys Babel-10.5,Lucas-8, Fergie buys Nani-14,Anderson-18.  How do you expect us to overtake Man U, when it's clear that they have a much bigger budget than us?

Man Utd have had a bigger budget than us for years.  Before Nani and Anderson they were paying £30 mil for Rooney and Rio Ferdinand.  Man Utd will always have a bigger budget than us but the team who spends the most doesnt always win. We dont need to be able to match Man Utd pound for pound to beat them.  Martin Jol at Spurs spent more money than anyone other than Mourinho and still couldnt break the top 4.  Compare his spending to his rival Wenger at Arsenal and u see that its not just about spending.  Any Inter Milan fan can vouch that for years they spent millions and millions and won nothing.  Its not simply about money.  Like I have said before even if Rafa had more money I'm still not convinced he would still find the right players.  If Rafa had the money I doubt he would ever dare to buy an Anderson or Nani for the money Man Utd spent.  Those sort of players are to risky for Rafa.
User avatar
puroresu
 
Posts: 3070
Joined: Fri Feb 17, 2006 10:30 am

Postby ruskiy playmaker » Tue Feb 05, 2008 4:06 pm

puroresu wrote:
ruskiy playmaker wrote:
puroresu wrote:Yes he hasnt been able to spend £15 mil on Malouda.  However the point I'm trying to make is with the money his had his bought to many poor players.  U can find good players with the money his had.  Wenger seems to do it just fine.  Rafa just aint the best judge of players.

I agree with you on this but there are very few known managers in the world who could do what Wenger does.  Sure I'd like to see Rafa go out and buy the next Hleb instead of Pennant, but you have to understand that even the best managers like Fergie need lots of money to buy quality talents nowadays.  When Rafa buys Babel-10.5,Lucas-8, Fergie buys Nani-14,Anderson-18.  How do you expect us to overtake Man U, when it's clear that they have a much bigger budget than us?

Man Utd have had a bigger budget than us for years.  Before Nani and Anderson they were paying £30 mil for Rooney and Rio Ferdinand.  Man Utd will always have a bigger budget than us but the team who spends the most doesnt always win. We dont need to be able to match Man Utd pound for pound to beat them.  Martin Jol at Spurs spent more money than anyone other than Mourinho and still couldnt break the top 4.  Compare his spending to his rival Wenger at Arsenal and u see that its not just about spending.  Any Inter Milan fan can vouch that for years they spent millions and millions and won nothing.  Its not simply about money.  Like I have said before even if Rafa had more money I'm still not convinced he would still find the right players.  If Rafa had the money I doubt he would ever dare to buy an Anderson or Nani for the money Man Utd spent.  Those sort of players are to risky for Rafa.

So puroresu who do you think can replace Rafa and overtake Man U and Chelsea with our budget?
[img]http://i42.tinypic.com/lkw42.gif[img]
User avatar
ruskiy playmaker
 
Posts: 2159
Joined: Sat Oct 13, 2007 8:29 pm
Location: USA

PreviousNext

Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion

 


  • Related topics
    Replies
    Views
    Last post

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 63 guests

  • Advertisement
ShopTill-e