Liverpool FC Forum

[Zidane]

Score a goal and do your damn cartwheel Robbie!  If he did that bet fans would be like FECK YEAH!

[GYBS]

yep exactly zidane - if he was playing well and scoring goals then we wouldnt be having this debate

[Fowler_E7]

and seen plenty games where keane has played and been utter rubish and have come off and we have scored .

yeah he subbed when he scores and plays well, where is the logic in that? he's dammed if does and dammed if he dont

[GYBS]

did he play well in the last game he played ? how many times has he played really well ?

[Fowler_E7]

No your are directly comparing them - constantly bringing up kuyt when this s a thread about keane - FACT about keane - he has played plenty of minutes buthasnt scored enough or done enough so far for us .

for one i wasnt the person who mentioned Kuyt that was Lando, and two seeing as Keane is usually dropped in favour of Kuyt i cant see the harm in comparing them

[Fowler_E7]

did he play well in the last game he played ? how many times has he played really well ?

how many times has he completed the 90 mins, how many times has he played two games in a row?

[GYBS]

dropped in favour of kuyt ? he was dropped yesterday in favour of torres ? the game before he played .

[GYBS]

did he play well in the last game he played ? how many times has he played really well ?

how many times has he completed the 90 mins, how many times has he played two games in a row?

well didnt he play 16 games in a row ? hasnt he been mainly subbed because he wasnt scoring ?

[Fowler_E7]

dropped in favour of kuyt ? he was dropped yesterday in favour of torres ? the game before he played .

how so? Torres when fit is gonna play everygame and rightly so he is our second best player and one the best in the world. The competion is for who is going to partner him, we have either Keane, Kuyt or N'gog and i know who i would pick everytime.

The problem is we barely play a 4-4-2 anyway, we usually play 4-5-1 with Gerrard behind Torres, which is waste of a good player in Keane IMO, we could drop kuyt put Gerrard on the right and play Keane and Torres together or put Benayoun/El Zhar out there and have gerrard in the centre of Midfield and Play Torres and Keane up top.  Its worth a shot IMO, as were not scoring or creating enough at the moment, we might give ourselves a chance if we put some players on the pitch who have the abilty to score or create chances.

[GYBS]

we tried 442 and it didnt work so its either torresor keane up front

[Fowler_E7]

did he play well in the last game he played ? how many times has he played really well ?

how many times has he completed the 90 mins, how many times has he played two games in a row?

well didnt he play 16 games in a row ? hasnt he been mainly subbed because he wasnt scoring ?

he hasnt played 16 in a row, thats the amount of Premiership appearances he has made, he's played 27 in total including appearances as a sub

[GYBS]

and how many games have we played so far this season ?

[Sir Roger]

did he play well in the last game he played ? how many times has he played really well ?

how many times has he completed the 90 mins, how many times has he played two games in a row?

well didnt he play 16 games in a row ? hasnt he been mainly subbed because he wasnt scoring ?

The obvious question has got to be:
Has Kuyt been scoring? If not why wasnt he subbed?

[GYBS]

ask in the kuyt thread

[Fowler_E7]

and how many games have we played so far this season ?

35, and whats your point? in the games he has played he hasnt had a enough time on the pitch when he has played to get his confidence going, maybe if Benitez showed some confidence in him he might show some confidence himself, who knows? if Keane had been a regular all year, id be criticising just as much as the next man, the fact is he hasnt played to build up some confidence and go on a scoring run. He has a proven goalscoring record in the premier league, so he has the quality it cant have disappeared over night