
devaney » Thu Feb 13, 2014 12:32 pm wrote:Yakka I've never been convinced by your somewhat over the top analysis of Gerrard's demise. Yes his form has been questionable but as usual he is expected to be Captain Fantastic and do the work of three players. Fortunately Rodgers knows at Stevie's age that is unrealistic and has allowed Gerrard to reinvent himself in a new role.I really don't know how many times I have to make the point that his presence on the pitch is critical wether he is playing well or not. To think that some of you guys were beginning to convince me that Lucas should be selected ahead of Stevie is a massive cause for concern. I could count on one hand the number of truly creative balls Lucas has played since joining Liverpool. To be frank he is not in the same fkg stratosphere.
Just don't choke on the humble pie Yakka and save a bit for RBG
devaney » Thu Feb 13, 2014 11:32 am wrote:Yakka I've never been convinced by your somewhat over the top analysis of Gerrard's demise. Yes his form has been questionable but as usual he is expected to be Captain Fantastic and do the work of three players. Fortunately Rodgers knows at Stevie's age that is unrealistic and has allowed Gerrard to reinvent himself in a new role.I really don't know how many times I have to make the point that his presence on the pitch is critical wether he is playing well or not. To think that some of you guys were beginning to convince me that Lucas should be selected ahead of Stevie is a massive cause for concern. I could count on one hand the number of truly creative balls Lucas has played since joining Liverpool. To be frank he is not in the same fkg stratosphere.
Just don't choke on the humble pie Yakka and save a bit for RBG
ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Thu Feb 13, 2014 1:30 pm wrote:devaney » Thu Feb 13, 2014 11:32 am wrote:Yakka I've never been convinced by your somewhat over the top analysis of Gerrard's demise. Yes his form has been questionable but as usual he is expected to be Captain Fantastic and do the work of three players. Fortunately Rodgers knows at Stevie's age that is unrealistic and has allowed Gerrard to reinvent himself in a new role.I really don't know how many times I have to make the point that his presence on the pitch is critical wether he is playing well or not. To think that some of you guys were beginning to convince me that Lucas should be selected ahead of Stevie is a massive cause for concern. I could count on one hand the number of truly creative balls Lucas has played since joining Liverpool. To be frank he is not in the same fkg stratosphere.
Just don't choke on the humble pie Yakka and save a bit for RBG
But no one ever said that Lucas was a better player than gerrard, all anyone said was that he was more mobile than gerrard and that mobility is what our midfield needed. I've probably watched Gerrard live more than 90% of the people who post on here and I have said repeatedly he is the best player I have ever seen play for this club and when you consider that the first time I went to anfield was in 1975 that's about as high praise as you get.
But before the revisionism really kicks into overdrive the reason behind our great season has been our superb forward line which has by and large carried a very average defence and midfield.
Again last night we had to score 3 goals to win away, against stoke we had to score at least 4 (we ended up scoring 5), if lavish praise is going to be thrown about it should be heaped on our strikers who have been performing since August.
ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Thu Feb 13, 2014 3:09 pm wrote:I'm not particularly a huge fan of Lucas, I don't think he has been the same since his injury and I think he lacks athleticism but it's more revisionism to suggest that we have looked better when he has been out of the side, some of our most impressive performances have been when he was in that DM role and it was Gerrard out out the side (Spurs away, City away).
I don't think there's a simple 'one size fits all' answer to our midfield problems, some weeks certain players play well and other weeks it's other names that play well, some weeks we are all over teams like a rash and other weeks teams over run us, one week a certain combination of players look great the next week it looks terrible, the one constant through all that erratic form though is that our forwards have performed week in week out, what ever the combination.
Wether Luis has been out or Danny has been out our front line has really stepped up to the plate in a massive way this season. They have been the Hero's this year.
Stu the Red » Thu Feb 13, 2014 2:20 pm wrote:ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Thu Feb 13, 2014 3:09 pm wrote:I'm not particularly a huge fan of Lucas, I don't think he has been the same since his injury and I think he lacks athleticism but it's more revisionism to suggest that we have looked better when he has been out of the side, some of our most impressive performances have been when he was in that DM role and it was Gerrard out out the side (Spurs away, City away).
I don't think there's a simple 'one size fits all' answer to our midfield problems, some weeks certain players play well and other weeks it's other names that play well, some weeks we are all over teams like a rash and other weeks teams over run us, one week a certain combination of players look great the next week it looks terrible, the one constant through all that erratic form though is that our forwards have performed week in week out, what ever the combination.
Wether Luis has been out or Danny has been out our front line has really stepped up to the plate in a massive way this season. They have been the Hero's this year.
Fair enough.
I do tend to agree, its obvious player of the season is Luis Suarez but its also good that we can sit here and give shout outs to Flannagan, Sturridge and in parts Coutinho.
Also, a major shout out to Raheem Sterling who's really starting to prove his doubters wrong and is looking a threat and working his balls off in every game we play.
Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot] and 60 guests