by GunGod » Sun Sep 18, 2005 2:58 pm
Actually what;s wrong with the team is the midfield, not the strikers. Rafa opted to play 4-5-1 even at home, and it gets a bit too predictable with 70% of balls looking for Crouch's head, though I must add that Crouch won most of them and played well.
If we consider Garcia a midfielder, then altogether the midfield's terribly bad. Alonso's been really overhyped (just my opinion). Im not saying Alonso's not a decent player, I mean, we rave about Alonso like he's the best midfielder in England, but he hasn't done anything marginally close to the likes of Bergkamp or Lampard. One reason for Alonso's relative ineffectiveness is that he's been dominated by Gerrard. I am not sure till now who's the defensive midfielder, the one in front of the back four when both of them play together. Its like both of them have to compromise something of their game in order to accomodate the other.
Then we have to use Riise and sinama who not pure wingers and sinama. Sinama did look lively though at first, but then I started to wonder whether he's Baros v2 with his aimless clinging on to the ball.
So we have a midfield that does not know who's supposed to do what, and a midfield captain who thinks he has to do too much. It shows when we have no ideas in going forward. No slick passing, and often forced out to the wings to cross in a hopeful ball to Crouch. There simply isnt good communication amongst the midfielders themselves, nor between the striker and midfield.
The defence is our saving grace though. And I am very happy we have such a cohesive unit. Hypia may be slow, but he wins just about every ball in the air. Carragher is playing well and while Finnan and Traore/Warnock make the occasional mistake, they share an understanding with the centre-backs. (Warnock was dissapointing today though).
I must add that Reina is looking rather jittery from all the games which I have seen him play. Edwin VDS really commanded his zone and came out like 5 times to act as an effective sweeper. That's probably due to experience, and while we must give Reina more time, currently he doesn't look like he commands a lot of trust from his defenders..3
Lastly, Garcia. He's the point while all attacks stop. He gives the ball away too frequently. Ok, he produces a moment of brillance once every third game. But is that enough for this level. You decide.