Liverpool FC Forum

[stmichael]

,

absolute rubbish hes doing far better than i expected with the total dross of a squad that rafa had left him. Judge him at the end of the season where i expect we will finish no lower than 5th whereas rafa will be unemployed and unemployable after making such a mess of a great squad in italy.

so losing 7 league games out 17 and getting dumped out of the league cup at home by northampton is doing "better than you expected"? bloody hell your expectations must have been really high at the start of the season.

I think it depends on how much sh'it you think the club was in when Hogson took over as to whether or not hes surpassed or even reached expectations. It depends on what your expectations were for a club that was in meltdown, turmoil and on the brink of disaster.
If you thought this is the way we were in the summer and feared for our very existence then you may well think Hodgson has done well getting us up to 9th and possibly breaking into the top 6 through Christmas.
If however you believe we werent that bad, it was a blip and Roy had taken over a decent squad which just needed tweaking, then you will obviously think he has under achieved.
Where you finish often depends on where you start

my expectations were dumbed down at the start of the season and understandably so, but roy has failed to even meet them so far.

and as for this "dross squad", yeah look at all the dross that benitez left here - not one international. what the hell was he playing at?  perhaps look at getting some players in that played in the world cup or something.

[Thommo's perm]

,

absolute rubbish hes doing far better than i expected with the total dross of a squad that rafa had left him. Judge him at the end of the season where i expect we will finish no lower than 5th whereas rafa will be unemployed and unemployable after making such a mess of a great squad in italy.

so losing 7 league games out 17 and getting dumped out of the league cup at home by northampton is doing "better than you expected"? bloody hell your expectations must have been really high at the start of the season.

I think it depends on how much sh'it you think the club was in when Hogson took over as to whether or not hes surpassed or even reached expectations. It depends on what your expectations were for a club that was in meltdown, turmoil and on the brink of disaster.
If you thought this is the way we were in the summer and feared for our very existence then you may well think Hodgson has done well getting us up to 9th and possibly breaking into the top 6 through Christmas.
If however you believe we werent that bad, it was a blip and Roy had taken over a decent squad which just needed tweaking, then you will obviously think he has under achieved.
Where you finish often depends on where you start

my expectations were dumbed down at the start of the season and understandably so, but roy has failed to even meet them so far.

and as for this "dross squad", yeah look at all the dross that benitez left here - not one international. what the hell was he playing at?  perhaps look at getting some players in that played in the world cup or something.

So you fall into the second category then

I personally feel there were very good players, good players an sh'ite that he left. It was because he couldnt go further with them that he went.
It was always going to be tough no matter who took over, unless they had a magic wand to change things overnight...

[rocky29]

im sorry the proof is in the pudding roys man management skills are way better than rafas lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa. Wereas inters players are a total mess at the moment.

[Greavesie]

im sorry the proof is in the pudding roys man management skills are way better than rafas lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa. Wereas inters players are a total mess at the moment.

who gives a feck about Rafa. I couldnt care less what Roy does better than Rafa. It doesn't matter how good Lucas plays he is not LFC quality even at his best, nor is Maxi. Babel might be but his attitude is sh!te anyway

Roy is not good enough, if you think he's doing a better job than rafa then fair enough but FFS we aren't where we should be. Our aspirations haven't changed, that's why Rafa left, because he wasn't achieving what we aimed for. Neither is Roy, it was nothing to do with Rafa, nothing. Stop hiding behind Rafa to shield Roy

[rocky29]

im sorry the proof is in the pudding roys man management skills are way better than rafas lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa. Wereas inters players are a total mess at the moment.

who gives a feck about Rafa. I couldnt care less what Roy does better than Rafa. It doesn't matter how good Lucas plays he is not LFC quality even at his best, nor is Maxi. Babel might be but his attitude is sh!te anyway

Roy is not good enough, if you think he's doing a better job than rafa then fair enough but FFS we aren't where we should be. Our aspirations haven't changed, that's why Rafa left, because he wasn't achieving what we aimed for. Neither is Roy, it was nothing to do with Rafa, nothing. Stop hiding behind Rafa to shield Roy

im not hiding behind anyone. All im saying is its very unfair the critisicm roy has received so far. Yes hes made mistakes but for fecksake some of the abuse hes gotten is way out of line. Its way to early to judge if roy is good enough.

[Greavesie]

I honestly don't think early at all. He's been sh!t away from home for 30 years, showing no signs of change so far at Liverpool. If we want to be up there that has to be sorted its that simple and IMO its not going to be with him here. That for me is criticism that's far from unfair, its based on fact (obviously not the 'its not going to change part').

Some of him comments are completely cringeworthy and make me wonder if he even knows the stature of the club he's managing at all because he doesn't seem to understand that at all.

I agree calling him a kunt and things like that is harsh though because nobody deserves that (well I can think of a few people ) but he face rub against Newcastle doesn't help him quash the 'budgie' and 'owl' tags

[stmichael]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

[rocky29]

ok we sack roy tomorow who do we bring in plus it all depends on how much the new owners are gona spend in january. I still believe any manager with the same players as we have now wont do any better than roy. We have to spend at least 50 million to get things going again.

[Ben Patrick]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

Lucas has without a shadow of a doubt moved up a notch this season.
He was steady last season, this season he has been possibly our best player.
Give Roy maybe a tiny bit of credit hey ?

[rocky29]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

Lucas has without a shadow of a doubt moved up a notch this season.
He was steady last season, this season he has been possibly our best player.
Give Roy maybe a tiny bit of credit hey ?

you see im always right 

[stmichael]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

Lucas has without a shadow of a doubt moved up a notch this season.
He was steady last season, this season he has been possibly our best player.
Give Roy maybe a tiny bit of credit hey ?

credit for keeping him in the team but not for improving him as a player. that's purely down to lucas himself.

the thing that has changed is that now the team's woeful performances are buried and the pretty average ones are lauded from the rooftops, the complete opposite of last season. last season everything lucas did wrong was magnified a million times now it is not. he was never as bad as people made out.

[Ben Patrick]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

Lucas has without a shadow of a doubt moved up a notch this season.
He was steady last season, this season he has been possibly our best player.
Give Roy maybe a tiny bit of credit hey ?

credit for keeping him in the team but not for improving him as a player. that's purely down to lucas himself.

the thing that has changed is that now the team's woeful performances are buried and the pretty average ones are lauded from the rooftops, the complete opposite of last season. last season everything lucas did wrong was magnified a million times now it is not. he was never as bad as people made out.

How do you know its down to Lucas ?
He played all of last season and was steady and consistant but wasnt one of the best players in the side.
He did not produce any performance like the Chelsea one or impose himself on games like he has this season.

Its an assumption on your part that its down to Lucas himself, obviously some of its down to hard work but it might also be to do with whatever the new manager has said to him or been doing with him in training.

[Thommo's perm]

lucas maxi and even babbel have played much better under roy than they ever did under rafa.

what a load of guff. maxi i'll give you but the other two not a chance.

infact lucas hasn't been performing much differently from last season. he's basically achieved what he has by knuckling down and not whinging when he wasn't a first teamer and he was getting booed by a section of our own moronic supporters. the main problem last season was him and mascherano didnt complement each other at all.

as for babel, he was excellent in his first season here but his deficiencies since have been as much to do with his own poor attitude than anything else.

Lucas has without a shadow of a doubt moved up a notch this season.
He was steady last season, this season he has been possibly our best player.
Give Roy maybe a tiny bit of credit hey ?

credit for keeping him in the team but not for improving him as a player. that's purely down to lucas himself.

the thing that has changed is that now the team's woeful performances are buried and the pretty average ones are lauded from the rooftops, the complete opposite of last season. last season everything lucas did wrong was magnified a million times now it is not. he was never as bad as people made out.

Whos been burying the teams woeful performances? On here even their decent performances are highlighted, analysed and criticised.
As for Lucas, out the 143 (yes thats right he has played for us 143 times!) performances I can safely say that at most 3 of them were good, 10 were average and 130 of them were either sh'ite or useless.
Most of those good/average games have been since Roys been here

[RED BEERGOGGLES]

How do you know its down to Lucas ?
He played all of last season and was steady and consistant but wasnt one of the best players in the side.
He did not produce any performance like the Chelsea one or impose himself on games like he has this season.

Its an assumption on your part that its down to Lucas himself, obviously some of its down to hard work but it might also be to do with whatever the new manager has said to him or been doing with him in training.

Lucas in the early part of last season was our best player Ben ,
and until Mascherano came back to  reality and realised throwing a strop would not push his plans of donning the Barcelona shirt any quicker ..... he remained so
So surely given Lucas's consistent improvement over the seasons we should give him the credit of believing  this may be a result of the Lads own volition

[Ben Patrick]

How do you know its down to Lucas ?
He played all of last season and was steady and consistant but wasnt one of the best players in the side.
He did not produce any performance like the Chelsea one or impose himself on games like he has this season.

Its an assumption on your part that its down to Lucas himself, obviously some of its down to hard work but it might also be to do with whatever the new manager has said to him or been doing with him in training.

Lucas in the early part of last season was our best player Ben ,
and until Mascherano came back to  reality and realised throwing a strop would not push his plans of donning the Barcelona shirt any quicker ..... he remained so
So surely given Lucas's consistent improvement over the seasons we should give him the credit of believing  this may be a result of the Lads own volition

he deserves credit no doubt.

what i am saying is he has improved further under Roy.