Liverpool FC Forum

[Ola Mr Benitez]

I would rather we lost Aqua or Mereiles than Lucas.  He was probably our best player for the last 2 seasons, just doing his job!

[only me]

I would rather we lost Aqua or Mereiles than Lucas.  He was probably our best player for the last 2 seasons, just doing his job!

Our best player by far is Reina. Lucas was and is a poor player. That just improved from Terrible to beareble...

[KennyisGod....still]

fails to amuse me that havin played for his country regular (albeit a far from 1970 Brazil) and having played under 3 consecutiv managers at Liverpool so many people think Lucas cant cut it..... hmmm, is there a reason these managers are paid the big bucks and we just sit back and watch I wonder....

[tommycockles]

fails to amuse me that havin played for his country regular (albeit a far from 1970 Brazil) and having played under 3 consecutiv managers at Liverpool so many people think Lucas cant cut it..... hmmm, is there a reason these managers are paid the big bucks and we just sit back and watch I wonder....

I agree. He takes a lot of stick and still gets on with his job. He doesn't have the flair of Ronaldo but then that's not his job. He tracks back, tackles, rarely loses the ball and when asked to go forward he's scored the odd goal. What more do you want? He's not the best in his position but then we don't have the cash to buy anyone better. For his price he's a great player and wouldn't be in the brazil team if he wasn't.

[only me]

fails to amuse me that havin played for his country regular (albeit a far from 1970 Brazil) and having played under 3 consecutiv managers at Liverpool so many people think Lucas cant cut it..... hmmm, is there a reason these managers are paid the big bucks and we just sit back and watch I wonder....

I agree. He takes a lot of stick and still gets on with his job. He doesn't have the flair of Ronaldo but then that's not his job. He tracks back, tackles, rarely loses the ball and when asked to go forward he's scored the odd goal. What more do you want? He's not the best in his position but then we don't have the cash to buy anyone better. For his price he's a great player and wouldn't be in the brazil team if he wasn't.

Like i already said before Lucas is in Brazil because he plays for Liverpool ,We are his ticket to the national team. The last Copa America was the first Big tournment he played in and we all now how it ended for them...I have many Brazilian friends which can't understand how he got the spot.

He does NOT score the odd goal ,and many of his tackles result in penalty kicks which resulted in goals against us. He is no Alonso ,No Mash and No Haman. Benitz and Roy are no longer here due to their Bizzar player selection and Kenny is in the process (i believe) of building a quality squad in which Lucas will not have a starting position.

[Greavesie]

I honestly believe if he's in the line up we'll concede less. That simple in my eyes

[red till i die!!]

i dont rate the lad very highly but he has improved and has done enough to stay here next season.
last year was tripe and he stood out above average but credit to him he had his best season ever for us and signed a new deal which doesnt make sense of the rumours surrounding him.bit silly as it would cost more to replace him with a less experienced option.
he should be kept to bolster the squad.

[jacdaniel]

Lucas does a very good job for us and deserves to stay.  However, If we qualify for CL I wouldnt be surprised if we went for a DM in the Mascherano/Hamann league. (world class).   

Lucas is a good player, but not a great one.

[aCe']

We are short on holding midfielders and while I definitely think that Lucas could be improved on (and Biglia IS an improvement), we shouldnt even be entertaining the thought of allowing Lucas to leave unless two established holding midfielders are lined up... Hes had a decent season last time around and if nothing else you know what to exect from him week in week out... If he stays (and I have no doubt he will) he will be one of the first names in the teamsheet for me simply due to a lack of options in his position... Crazy if true !

[damjan193]

So is the rumour about him going on loan or being sold? Because I've heard about both and I have to say I agree with neither. Never was his biggest fan but last season him, Kuyt and Meireles were our best players and we shouldn't even think about getting rid of them, atleast not until next season. A better holding midfield could and should be signed but for now I think it would be better to hold on to Lucas and I'm sure that he'll do a fine job anyway. We've signed quite a few players in the last 7-8 months and maybe there are still more to come and having a completely different squad isn't the best idea. This summer transfer window was about replacing players that HAD to be replaced and replacing Lucas with someone else isn't that urgent, at least for now.

If it's about having too many midfielders and we're not willing or not able to get rid of Aquilani and would rather loan a player or two I say we loan Shelvey and if that's not enough than we should loan Henderson. Why? Because he was never a player that had to be bought right now, he's one for the future and we already have enough players on our attacking positions in our midfield (Gerrard, Meireles, Aquilani, Adam), while we're a bit short on midfielders that can defend (Lucas and Spearing, not counting Poulsen).

[damjan193]

Another solution for the defensive midfield, on which some would definitely agree on, is playing Gerrard as a defensive playmaker. We all know that he's way past his best and that we'll probably never see Gerrard leading the team the way he did and wining games and even titles all by himself. He'll probably never be able to do things like that in the future but the way things are going now I'm sure that he won't even have to. Now he can play in the back of the midfield creating the game and controling the flow of the play. He will also have to provide cover for the defenders and hold the midfield and I believe that he's capable of that, therefor, having all these abilities I think that playing him as a defensive playmaker is worth a try.

I have to add however, even if this happens I still wouldn't aprove selling/loaning Lucas.

[anti-hero]

He shouldnt go anywhere else but the centre of the park for Liverppol.

[Zidane]

Shocked by how may people STILL don't see how good he is.  Even I am have realized he's class. Our best CM by a good margin, even ahead of Stevie who is the closest, everyone else is far behind.

[ethanr]

played fantastic in the short time he had today, especially considering he hasn't been playing.

[Reg]

If this loan talk is true then I am truely baffled.  I trust Kenny, I trust Steve Clark, but I'm still baffled.