Liverpool FC Forum

by **columbia** » Sun Feb 12, 2006 9:06 pm

LiverpoolMadman wrote:IF Cisse, Mori and PC not perfoming as Striker or NOT scoring goal , Rafa have to look for new striker for next season.

As for me , I will sell all of them and buy , maybe Torres or David Villa or Defoe to play with Sinama .

i dont understand you. youve said you would sell cisse, morientes and peter crouch and simply listed 3 players youd buy to replace them. why dont you give reasons for your argument, you make a point and dont back it up with anything. Ok, so you dont like morientes, why not? how do you think he could improve his game? do you think its to do with the physicality of the premiership? or perhaps the teams style doesnt suit him? he's lacking in confidence maybe? Basicaly why do you think he should be replaced and what do you think the person that your suggesting we bring in would give to our team that he doesnt.

If you structured your posts in some way like this you would be taken more seriously at least, dont you think.

i think yes, what about you?

by **RAFABENITEZ** » Sun Feb 12, 2006 9:21 pm

Its clearly Robbie.

by **LiverpoolMadman** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 2:02 am

i dont understand you. youve said you would sell cisse, morientes and peter crouch and simply listed 3 players youd buy to replace them. why dont you give reasons for your argument,

My answer is simple. If a player NOT performing to his standard , he should be sold at the end of this season .

so you dont like morientes, why not? how do you think he could improve his game? do you think its to do with the physicality of the premiership? or perhaps the teams style doesnt suit him? he's lacking in confidence maybe? Basicaly why do you think he should be replaced and what do you think the person that your suggesting we bring in would give to our team that he doesnt.

I dont said that I dont like him ... I just saying that Mori is NOT suitable for EPL. For almost 2 season he only manage to score less than 20 goals for Liverpool and that shows that he just NOT good in EPL. He will be good in France League or in Spain.

In short , you can be good in other league , doesnt mean you are good in EPL.

by **babu** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 6:50 am

LiverpoolMadman wrote:
i dont understand you. youve said you would sell cisse, morientes and peter crouch and simply listed 3 players youd buy to replace them. why dont you give reasons for your argument,

My answer is simple. If a player NOT performing to his standard , he should be sold at the end of this season .

so you dont like morientes, why not? how do you think he could improve his game? do you think its to do with the physicality of the premiership? or perhaps the teams style doesnt suit him? he's lacking in confidence maybe? Basicaly why do you think he should be replaced and what do you think the person that your suggesting we bring in would give to our team that he doesnt.

I dont said that I dont like him ... I just saying that Mori is NOT suitable for EPL. For almost 2 season he only manage to score less than 20 goals for Liverpool and that shows that he just NOT good in EPL. He will be good in France League or in Spain.

In short , you can be good in other league , doesnt mean you are good in EPL.

That's just plain scary.

by **gato_busta** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 6:56 am

Morientes has been here for almost two seasons already

? I thought he joined liverpool on january 2005, that would mean he's been in the team for a little over a year... isn't a season a year long?

I think yes, how about you?

kinda catchy

by **dawson99** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 12:28 pm

i think yes what about you kinda catchy? hmmmm

anyways, how can u people vote crouch. ok hes a great goal maker, but striker? come on, hes scored what...5 goals this season?

If we are talking about strikers, then its the one up front whos scored most, and thats cisse.

and 48 people say fowler? methinks some of u live slightly in the past. hes looked good no doubt, but until he scores at least one goal he cant be our best

by **115-1073096938** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 12:32 pm

dawson99 wrote:i think yes what about you kinda catchy? hmmmm

anyways, how can u people vote crouch. ok hes a great goal maker, but striker? come on, hes scored what...5 goals this season?

If we are talking about strikers, then its the one up front whos scored most, and thats cisse.

and 48 people say fowler? methinks some of u live slightly in the past. hes looked good no doubt, but until he scores at least one goal he cant be our best

Thats like saying if we signed Gallas tomorrow he couldn't be better than Traore till he's played.

Fowler's the best striker we have, he's got the most ability. Cisse is the worst footballer we have in that position, he has the least ability. Form is temporary, class is permanent.

by **dawson99** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 12:37 pm

the question is striker, not forward, so how can u say cisse is worse than mori or crouch?

i'll give u the fowler thing, he is class, but i wanna see him play a bit befire i say hes the best striker in our team officially

by **115-1073096938** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 12:47 pm

I've seen about 300 and odd games live with Robbie playing. I've seen him on t.v. since he came back and looks more or less the same player in nearly every way with the exception he's lacking a touch of confidence.

Strikers and fowards are the same position.

If you're on about purely goals, Cisse's only got 4 in the prem, 2 penalties, Crouch has 4 and Morientes has 3.

Goals against sides Burscough could compete with in the cl qualifiers don't convince me he's a good player mate.

by **dawson99** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 12:50 pm

ive missed u and your 'ive seen more games than u so na na na na na na'

theres people who have seen more ian rush games than both of us, and just because hes in decent shape doesnt mean hed be our best striker.

robbie was fantastic i agree, and talent like that isnt lost by age. back problems do occur tho, plus he needs the extra yards in his head now.

and the only thing u have proven to me about the other 3 is that as strikers they are all pants lol

i just dont like crouch, everyuone here knows i dont, and its just my opinion.

by **Espionage** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:08 pm

stu_the_red wrote:Fowler's the best striker we have, he's got the most ability. Cisse is the worst footballer we have in that position, he has the least ability. Form is temporary, class is permanent.

I agree, but based on that should Nando have also been a success? There is no doubting his class...
I know that Fowler is proven in the premier league, but i am yet to be convinced if he can still cut it at Liverpool (though i have every hope in the world). As we seem to have a knack for ruining perfectly good strikers these days

by **115-1073096938** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:18 pm

dawson99 wrote:ive missed u and your 'ive seen more games than u so na na na na na na'

theres people who have seen more ian rush games than both of us, and just because hes in decent shape doesnt mean hed be our best striker.

robbie was fantastic i agree, and talent like that isnt lost by age. back problems do occur tho, plus he needs the extra yards in his head now.

and the only thing u have proven to me about the other 3 is that as strikers they are all pants lol

i just dont like crouch, everyuone here knows i dont, and its just my opinion.

Just because you don't like someone doesn't mean they aren't a good player and just because you don't like a players style doesn't mean that either.

I don't like Sissoko's style if i'm honest and he's not the sort of midfielder i'd want to build a side around, but at the end of the day he's a good player.

Different players bring different things to the game.

by **dawson99** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:20 pm

agreed, but if u think cisse is SO bad, what extra does mori bring to the game?

i personally like sissoko, i like the players that try. im a heart fan, not a head fan tho. thats why i always liked biscan and even traore. its stupid i know, buts its me

by **Sabre** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:21 pm

I don't like Sissoko's style if i'm honest and he's not the sort of midfielder i'd want to build a side around, but at the end of the day he's a good player.

Different players bring different things to the game.

I agree this, Stu, but then in Hamman we have a not showy player that who makes our defensive play more solid in general. He's one of those players who are not people's fav, but are appreciated by coaches. I think he's been underused compared to Sissoko, although I don't know what are the stats of appearances of this two players.

by **dawson99** » Mon Feb 13, 2006 1:26 pm

hamman a few years ago had opta stats that kicked the :censored:

ou of viera (fact) not saying which is a better player, but it does show just how under rated didi has been for us

Liverpool FC Forum

Who is our best striker ? - Vote now !

Who is our best striker ? - Vote now !

Who is online