by LFC2007 » Sun Oct 03, 2010 8:52 pm
Whether Roy succeeds or not, the decision to change manager was the correct one in my view. This season, Carragher said of the end of Rafa's reign that it was "time for a change" (before anyone thinks I've plucked the quote from an obscure internet article, no, he said it in a TV interview after the Arsenal game, I saw it myself) and it's hard to believe others key players were not of the same opinion. Understandably so; we were in decline for a whole season, finished 7th and failed to turn more corners than I can ever remember.
What happened thereafter with the choice of a new manager is a judgment independent of the decision to part company with Rafa. What you might say though is that, to date, Roy's appointment appears to challenge the idea that almost anyone could have come in and done a better job than Rafa. That isn't to say that Kenny, Pellegrini, MON, Deschamps or others couldn't have done a better job. Chances are they could and would.