Liverpool FC Forum

[Stu.Murph]

PSV

Finnan - 3
Gerrard - 2
Mascherano - 1

[RichardLFC1]

PSV

Finnan 3 points           Good assists for two of the goals

Gerrard 2 points          Great finish and brings liverpool forward

Agger 1 point             Solid at the back again

[Ace Ventura]

PSV game

Finnan
Mascherano
Gerrard

[Sabre]

Right, for this second standings table I've used the suggestion Joe made. Every game will deliver 100 points among our players, who'll receive them depending on the total votes received that game. From the voters view, nothing changes, they still have to give 3,2 and 1 points respectively.

I've made a simple round-ups and downs in order to avoid fractions. If you get 45,5 or greater then you receieve 46. If you have 46,4 then you receive 46. Due to this, it may happen that the delivered points are slightly more or less than 100, but since it's the same rule for every player, we can overlook that error.

Thus the Standings of The Arsenal game

----------------------------------------
1.-Crouch............ 49 pts (59 votes)
2.-Fabio Aurelio......27 pts (32 votes)
3.-Mascherano.......17 pts (20 votes)
4.-Pennant............7 pts  (8 votes)
5.-Arbeloa.............1 point (1 vote)

----------------------------------

Standings for the PSV game (They'll be rechecked soon)

1.-Finnan........... 40 points
2.-Mascherano.... 30 points
3.-Gerrard...........22 points
4.-Crouch............3 points
5.-Alonso............1 point
6.-Agger..............1 point
---------------------------

**************
General Standings
**************

1.-Crouch...........52 points
2.-Mascherano.....47 points
3.-Finnan............40 points
4.-Fabio Aurelio....27 points
5.-Gerrard...........22 points
6.-Pennant..........7 points
7.-Arbeloa...........1 point
8.-Alonso............1 point
9.-Agger.............1 point
-----------------------------------


Below this post, the points of the game against Reading (thank you Joe)

Comments are welcome. Suggestions that won't imply much more work for me will be accepted.

Keep voting!

[JoeTerp]

I think you mean the game against Reading.  Wigan is on the 21st.

[RichardLFC1]

The team didnt play too weel but

Arbeloa 3 points
Gerrard 2 points
Mascharano 1 point

[Stu.Murph]

The team didnt play too weel but

Arbeloa 3 points
Gerrard 2 points
Mascharano 1 point

Gerrard - 3
Arbeloa - 2
Pennant - 1

[Bad Bob]

Arbeloa 3
Pennant 2
Gerrard 1

[Stu.Murph]

Arbeloa 3
Pennant 2
Gerrard 1

Pedantic bastard!

[Bad Bob]

Arbeloa 3
Pennant 2
Gerrard 1

Pedantic bastard!

I wanted to be different!   Besides, Pennant made a huge difference when he came on and deserves the recognition.

[bigmick]

Gerrard 3, Arbeloa 2, Kuyt 1. FWIW I did think Pennant made a difference when he came on though, and he made the winner for Kuyt obviously.

[Fowler_E7]

3-Gerrard 
2-Arbeloa
1-Kuyt

[dward]

Arbeloa
Gerrard
Pennant

[Raoul]

I saw it a bit differently:

1. Carra
2. Gerrard
3. Arbeloa

Agree with everyone about Pennant though.  Looks good like this Sabre.

[Sabre]

I've seen the game again, in a better image quality than the online internet channels.

In this game I liked: Arbeloa, Reina, Carragher, Gerrard, Pennant, Kuyt, Mascherano, Crouch

Average: Hyypia (bad 1st half though), Gonzalez, Finnan, Riise, Bellamy

Didn't like: Sissoko

I know who I'll give the 3 points, but I had a hard time deciding who got away with 2 and 1 points. I ruled out the subs because the other 3 made a whole 90 mins good game.

3 points  Carraguer, No mistakes I can remember, men like this wins this matches.

2 points Mascherano, Lots of grey and not showy stuff that makes you win a game. His touch to recover the ball that eventually led to our goal for instance.

1 point Reina, I remember one mistake in the min 60 in a well taken free kick, but otherwise he gave security to the team, he kicked the ball well, and provoked 3 good counterattacks, for instance in the minute that their keeper got a yellow card.

Gerrard also deserved points, but he receives credit more often. Same for Arbeloa, great goal in a part of his game he won't use often, finishing. Decent game of 90 mins, he deserves a point but... hard luck. Crouch did an enormous work aswell.