Sabre wrote:The thing I like most of JoeTerp's post is how he address the signing ups, always understanding the signing up as someone who's gonna be part of a context, making the pertinent questions about how he'll mix together into the team. Just the opposite to that other Real Madrid-esque or Football Manager computer game player-esque view of "the more expensive and rated players I buy the better". So despite I disagree some of his points, I congratulate him because of how he asks the question.
I won't put a starting a formation like this:
X-----X-----X-----X
---------X
or even like this
X----------------X
-----X-----X
--------X
We could do wedges, and other nice shapes but that is not important once the game starts and the players are moving.
a 4-4-2 used by Spain, and a 4-4-2 used by Liverpool might be similar when we see it in the screen before the match, but that's all the resemblance (even if you played all the 4 reds in the Spanish team at the same time!)
Why I disagree his point? If we hadn't a team to play 2 strikers, or we weren't close to it, Joe, Rafa would have never used a 2 strikers system these years, and he has. So if you ask me if I want Villa, yes, please. (But I don't think we will)
The only problem I see is man management. If you're a Rafa-esque kind of coach who find the best answer to every game, you might be tempted to find solutions for certain games that do not imply 2 strikers, and Rafa seems to like our 4-2-3-1. We cannot buy Villa to have Torres in the bench or viceversa.

JoeTerp wrote:is there a single change or player that can be brought to the team that will instantly allow us to adopt to a new system and execute it to an even higher level than before?

bigmick wrote:I must confess I might be in the significant minority on here and I'm setting myself up for a huge fall, but I'm actually yet to be convinced that Villa and Torres actually fit as a partnership. Now I know they've banged in some goals so far in the Euro's, but they don't to me look like a natural partnership. FWIW, I actually agree with whoever it was who said Torres may not be the type of striker which would have a natural partner. If you're not going to go with the "big guy, little guy" partnership which most teams don't these days, then you at least want your two strikers to give you a bit of depth. By that I mean you you ideally want one to drop in readily, to come and play in and around the holding midfielder and intersperse with wide midfielders. I'm not actually sure that either Villa or Torres do that, both seem to me to be more the predator.
For this reason, and against top-class defending I think they'll struggle. I actually think the Italians will put Spain out and neither Villa nor Torres will impress. Least nobody can accuse me of sitting on the fence. I'll even go futher and guess that the Russians will cause Holland as many problems as they can cope with. The difference is that the Russians have a lot of depth in their attack. One of their guys drops in readily. He's only played the one game so far and in it he scored a goal. He also provided the first time incisive pass for the other goal, from the half way line, wide out on the right touchline. If you are going to play a 4-4-2 (which incidently I don't think Rafa is, and I kind of don't blame him either which is a bit of a novelty these days) then this fella is the perfect fit for Torres and Gerrard IMHO. Arshavin.
The bandwagon had already pulled out of the sheds and been around the track a few times before I actually saw him play so he's by no means my spot. I'm happy to climb aboard though as I think he's a wonderful little player. Whoever gets him is getting as bargain for anything less than a huge wedge of cash IMHO.

bigmick wrote:then this fella is the perfect fit for Torres and Gerrard IMHO. Arshavin.
The bandwagon had already pulled out of the sheds and been around the track a few times before I actually saw him play so he's by no means my spot. I'm happy to climb aboard though as I think he's a wonderful little player. Whoever gets him is getting as bargain for anything less than a huge wedge of cash IMHO.
bigmick wrote:For this reason, and against top-class defending I think they'll struggle. I actually think the Italians will put Spain out and neither Villa nor Torres will impress. Least nobody can accuse me of sitting on the fence. I'll even go futher and guess that the Russians will cause Holland as many problems as they can cope with.

bigmick wrote:bigmick wrote:For this reason, and against top-class defending I think they'll struggle. I actually think the Italians will put Spain out and neither Villa nor Torres will impress. Least nobody can accuse me of sitting on the fence. I'll even go futher and guess that the Russians will cause Holland as many problems as they can cope with.
Half of the prediction came true which is nice. Arshavin was once again absolutely top-drawer as well. Given his age it makes you wonder where he's been hiding all these years.
JoeTerp wrote:I know we might not even bid for him, but it applies to Liverpool in general going after another top class forward. Would it be like buying an HD DVD player without having an HD TV or an HD satellite package?
If we buy another striker in the Villa mold, he would HAVE to start alongside Torres, meaning a 4-4-2 (unless we switchted to a 5-3-2 or 3-5-2) Do we really have the players to play a 4-4-2 at the moment? Especially if you are in the camp of Gerrard must be played in the middle he is the captain that is where he belongs that is his best position. Then it is a decision of can Kuyt and Babel play these kind of less advanced, less help from the middle, wide positions? I am not so sure, and Babel would be pretty mad because he sees himself moving more and more central and more and more forward and this would be a step back in both directions. Now all that is left is Pennant (who I actually rate higher than most) and Yossi. In my opinion an 4-4-2 even with VIlla and Torres wouldn't be as good as our main starting XI from the end of last year if Pennant and Yossi are the wingers. SO now we would find ourselves right back where we started a while ago needing Two wingers with maybe not even enough money to buy one at the type of quality level that we are looking for.
So now I am not sure what to buy. it seemed like the main weakness of the 4-2-3-1 last year was maybe the fullbacks and MAYBE the "other" defensive midfielder. Well we have addressed both fullbacks already (assuming we officially sign Dossena) and I am guessing Barry would be played alongside Mascherano if brought in (or played alongside Gerrard making a 4-1-4-1 out of the 4-2-3-1). After that I can't really see any more improvements we can make. Kuyt has made that position his own and I am afraid the whole thing could implode if he was taken out of the equation even though a lot of people think we can probably add a more clinical finisher or a better crosser or someone with more flair. Babel has so much upside I would be worried about bringing in a replacement for him as well. I think in a way we are stuck with this team unless we want to "blow it up" and have a huge firesale to raise funds for a 4-4-2 starting XI


bigmick wrote:bigmick wrote:For this reason, and against top-class defending I think they'll struggle. I actually think the Italians will put Spain out and neither Villa nor Torres will impress. Least nobody can accuse me of sitting on the fence. I'll even go futher and guess that the Russians will cause Holland as many problems as they can cope with.
Half of the prediction came true which is nice. Arshavin was once again absolutely top-drawer as well. Given his age it makes you wonder where he's been hiding all these years.
SundanceKid wrote:JoeTerp wrote:I know we might not even bid for him, but it applies to Liverpool in general going after another top class forward. Would it be like buying an HD DVD player without having an HD TV or an HD satellite package?
If we buy another striker in the Villa mold, he would HAVE to start alongside Torres, meaning a 4-4-2 (unless we switchted to a 5-3-2 or 3-5-2) Do we really have the players to play a 4-4-2 at the moment? Especially if you are in the camp of Gerrard must be played in the middle he is the captain that is where he belongs that is his best position. Then it is a decision of can Kuyt and Babel play these kind of less advanced, less help from the middle, wide positions? I am not so sure, and Babel would be pretty mad because he sees himself moving more and more central and more and more forward and this would be a step back in both directions. Now all that is left is Pennant (who I actually rate higher than most) and Yossi. In my opinion an 4-4-2 even with VIlla and Torres wouldn't be as good as our main starting XI from the end of last year if Pennant and Yossi are the wingers. SO now we would find ourselves right back where we started a while ago needing Two wingers with maybe not even enough money to buy one at the type of quality level that we are looking for.
So now I am not sure what to buy. it seemed like the main weakness of the 4-2-3-1 last year was maybe the fullbacks and MAYBE the "other" defensive midfielder. Well we have addressed both fullbacks already (assuming we officially sign Dossena) and I am guessing Barry would be played alongside Mascherano if brought in (or played alongside Gerrard making a 4-1-4-1 out of the 4-2-3-1). After that I can't really see any more improvements we can make. Kuyt has made that position his own and I am afraid the whole thing could implode if he was taken out of the equation even though a lot of people think we can probably add a more clinical finisher or a better crosser or someone with more flair. Babel has so much upside I would be worried about bringing in a replacement for him as well. I think in a way we are stuck with this team unless we want to "blow it up" and have a huge firesale to raise funds for a 4-4-2 starting XI
Marvelous post. Everything is agreeable. But the most important thing is which formation is going to outscore opponents. I know it's foolish to say, but we don't need to be strong in all parts of the field if we can outscore our opponents every time, right?

Fo Dne wrote:SundanceKid wrote:JoeTerp wrote:I know we might not even bid for him, but it applies to Liverpool in general going after another top class forward. Would it be like buying an HD DVD player without having an HD TV or an HD satellite package?
If we buy another striker in the Villa mold, he would HAVE to start alongside Torres, meaning a 4-4-2 (unless we switchted to a 5-3-2 or 3-5-2) Do we really have the players to play a 4-4-2 at the moment? Especially if you are in the camp of Gerrard must be played in the middle he is the captain that is where he belongs that is his best position. Then it is a decision of can Kuyt and Babel play these kind of less advanced, less help from the middle, wide positions? I am not so sure, and Babel would be pretty mad because he sees himself moving more and more central and more and more forward and this would be a step back in both directions. Now all that is left is Pennant (who I actually rate higher than most) and Yossi. In my opinion an 4-4-2 even with VIlla and Torres wouldn't be as good as our main starting XI from the end of last year if Pennant and Yossi are the wingers. SO now we would find ourselves right back where we started a while ago needing Two wingers with maybe not even enough money to buy one at the type of quality level that we are looking for.
So now I am not sure what to buy. it seemed like the main weakness of the 4-2-3-1 last year was maybe the fullbacks and MAYBE the "other" defensive midfielder. Well we have addressed both fullbacks already (assuming we officially sign Dossena) and I am guessing Barry would be played alongside Mascherano if brought in (or played alongside Gerrard making a 4-1-4-1 out of the 4-2-3-1). After that I can't really see any more improvements we can make. Kuyt has made that position his own and I am afraid the whole thing could implode if he was taken out of the equation even though a lot of people think we can probably add a more clinical finisher or a better crosser or someone with more flair. Babel has so much upside I would be worried about bringing in a replacement for him as well. I think in a way we are stuck with this team unless we want to "blow it up" and have a huge firesale to raise funds for a 4-4-2 starting XI
Marvelous post. Everything is agreeable. But the most important thing is which formation is going to outscore opponents. I know it's foolish to say, but we don't need to be strong in all parts of the field if we can outscore our opponents every time, right?
So basically what you're saying is try to score more than the opposition to win?
Genius, why didn't I think of that one?


s@int wrote:I don't really see a problem Joe to be honest.
Reina
Degen Carra Agger Dossena
Gerrard Masch Barry
Villa Torres Babel
With attacking fullbacks, and both Gerrard and Barry comfortable in the wide areas I can't see that width would be too much of a problem.
Reina
Degen Carra Agger Dossena
Masch Barry
Gerrard
Villa Torres Babel
I prefer 4-4-2 myself so I would prefer
Reina
Degen Carra Agger Dossena
Kuyt Gerrard Masch Barry
Torres Villa
I do see a problem however if we don't buy a striker as neither Kuyt or Babel would fill me with confidence if Torres was injured or needed a rest.

Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot] and 623 guests