s@int wrote:Another player I think would do a great job for us is Zlatan Ibrahimovic , I know he's a lazy so and so and he also missed an open goal against us from about 2 yards, but he is also capable of creating and scoring great goals ubiquitous youtube goal
With his size and ability I could see him playing a Cantona type role for us.
s@int wrote:Toffeehater wrote:s@int wrote:If I could have my choice I would probably go for Sergio Aguero who would cost about £20million+ , Giovani Dos Santos who although still very young we could get for £10million at the moment (buy out clause)or Diego who would cost about £10/15million. Any of these would be great IMO, they would create lots of goals and score plenty as well, while linking attack and midfield and adding that little bit of much needed creativity when we come up against the top sides.
but one prob mate , they are not proven in the english league , they could be flops with great records from their own leagues , etc cissie
Was Torres proven in the English league? Maybe we shouldn't have bought him either![]()
Any player can be a flop, all buys are a gamble no matter where they come from. Clough looked ideal for the liverpool team, had already won medals and was PROVEN in England. Morientes was proven in Europe and again looked a guaranteed success. Heskey ?
Van Nistelroy, Henry etc etc came over here and were tremendously successful.
You have to pick a player on ability not on where they come from. Obviously its an advantage if they have prem experience but you also pay a high premium for that.
The point I was trying to make was rather than going for another out and out striker, we should be going for a creative second striker that will create as many goals for others as they score themselves. Players in the mould of Stjohn,Keegan, Dalglish, Beardsley, Bergkamp, Sheringham etc etc.
We are desperately short of someone with that extra creativity in attack when we come up against resolute defences and top sides, someone who will link up our midfield and attack.
As I have said before apart from Chelsea and Blackburn what was the last team to win the league without a creative second striker. Think of any great team and the chances are that they had a creative second striker.
Just think of Liverpool teams :-
1960's 2 league titles (With Stjohn)
1970's 3 league titles (with Keegan)
1970's 2 league titles (with Dalglish)
1980's 6 league titles (4 with Dalglish) (2 with Beardsley)
Then look were the gaps in our title runs occur, 1967 - 1973, 1990 - present day. Strangely Stjohn was moved back into midfield and we bought Hateley to play alongside Hunt in 1967. It wasn't till Keegan came along that we started to win titles again.
Right after Keegan left we bought Dalglish so obviously there was no interuptions to the flow of titles, then we bought Beardsley and the titles still flowed our way.
1991 we sold Beardsley and since then we haven't won the title.
Yes we have won plenty of cups because we have had some great players in the last 18 years, but to become a great team again we need a great creative second striker.
United have had a string of them Cantona, York, Sherringham, Rooney, Arsenal have had one of the best in Bergkamp, we have had Litmenen (who hardly played) and MurphyNot forgetting Kuyt, who is probably the most uncreative second striker in the league
![]()
In fact probably the best partnership we have had in the last 18 years was Collymore and Fowler, but as we all know Collymore wasn't the steadiest bottle on the shelf.
LittleHobo wrote:ibrahimovic is dream land
as is berbatov
santa cruz has had a good half season, dont buy him based on that, file along side the portsmouth striker who is also unproved
dont think anelka is the right partner for torres although i rate him highly...file along side defoe and david villa......villa and torres never really clicked at international level
the ones i would like are just miles away from us signing at the moment......ibrahimovic and berbatov
Toffeehater wrote:yes i agree with u on the torres part but lets just say what happens if the player we buy is a flop coming with a great record , someone like morrienties , people will go like oh they spent so much and he's not performing , a good example would be shevchenko . we would have then just wasted so much cash esp in our situation , we need proven goal scorers and NOT take a gamble , cos i think all we're gonna get is 1 shot and we gotta take it , go for robbie keane or anelka , if a second striker is to be bought
s@int wrote:Toffeehater wrote:yes i agree with u on the torres part but lets just say what happens if the player we buy is a flop coming with a great record , someone like morrienties , people will go like oh they spent so much and he's not performing , a good example would be shevchenko . we would have then just wasted so much cash esp in our situation , we need proven goal scorers and NOT take a gamble , cos i think all we're gonna get is 1 shot and we gotta take it , go for robbie keane or anelka , if a second striker is to be bought
As I said ANY transfer is a gamble.
I explained in another thread that I personally don't rate Robbie Keane.
Anelka is a different type of gamble, would his personality be happy playing second fiddle to Torres? Could he stay happy long enough to be a worth while buy?
When he was here last time we made a big mistake letting him go, but now I am not so sure about him coming back. Certainly he would be better than Kuyt but maybe we could get better for the money.
Toffeehater wrote:s@int wrote:Toffeehater wrote:yes i agree with u on the torres part but lets just say what happens if the player we buy is a flop coming with a great record , someone like morrienties , people will go like oh they spent so much and he's not performing , a good example would be shevchenko . we would have then just wasted so much cash esp in our situation , we need proven goal scorers and NOT take a gamble , cos i think all we're gonna get is 1 shot and we gotta take it , go for robbie keane or anelka , if a second striker is to be bought
As I said ANY transfer is a gamble.
I explained in another thread that I personally don't rate Robbie Keane.
Anelka is a different type of gamble, would his personality be happy playing second fiddle to Torres? Could he stay happy long enough to be a worth while buy?
When he was here last time we made a big mistake letting him go, but now I am not so sure about him coming back. Certainly he would be better than Kuyt but maybe we could get better for the money.
ok fair enough saint , 10 mill is anelka price tag , any player on ur mind mate ? better for that kind of cash?
s@int wrote:Toffeehater wrote:s@int wrote:Toffeehater wrote:yes i agree with u on the torres part but lets just say what happens if the player we buy is a flop coming with a great record , someone like morrienties , people will go like oh they spent so much and he's not performing , a good example would be shevchenko . we would have then just wasted so much cash esp in our situation , we need proven goal scorers and NOT take a gamble , cos i think all we're gonna get is 1 shot and we gotta take it , go for robbie keane or anelka , if a second striker is to be bought
As I said ANY transfer is a gamble.
I explained in another thread that I personally don't rate Robbie Keane.
Anelka is a different type of gamble, would his personality be happy playing second fiddle to Torres? Could he stay happy long enough to be a worth while buy?
When he was here last time we made a big mistake letting him go, but now I am not so sure about him coming back. Certainly he would be better than Kuyt but maybe we could get better for the money.
ok fair enough saint , 10 mill is anelka price tag , any player on ur mind mate ? better for that kind of cash?
Not better as there are few better than Anelka at that price (Owen maybe), but different. I think Diego would be around that figure, but his price may have rocketed due to his recent form.
Personally I would rather wait if necessary and buy bigger and better as we did with Torres. Once you get to the £20million mark I think there are quite a few that would be better.
I think we have made too many stopgap signings already, and I think Anelka would be a stopgap not a longterm signing. Not because he lacks ability but maybe just his character.
Toffeehater wrote:LittleHobo wrote:ibrahimovic is dream land
as is berbatov
santa cruz has had a good half season, dont buy him based on that, file along side the portsmouth striker who is also unproved
dont think anelka is the right partner for torres although i rate him highly...file along side defoe and david villa......villa and torres never really clicked at international level
the ones i would like are just miles away from us signing at the moment......ibrahimovic and berbatov
berbatov getting back to form , he's just scored 4 goals against reading , the team we lost 3-1 to
LittleHobo wrote:Toffeehater wrote:LittleHobo wrote:ibrahimovic is dream land
as is berbatov
santa cruz has had a good half season, dont buy him based on that, file along side the portsmouth striker who is also unproved
dont think anelka is the right partner for torres although i rate him highly...file along side defoe and david villa......villa and torres never really clicked at international level
the ones i would like are just miles away from us signing at the moment......ibrahimovic and berbatov
berbatov getting back to form , he's just scored 4 goals against reading , the team we lost 3-1 to
my point is i just cant see us signing berbatov or ibrahimovic
bigger teams than us would get them
username wrote:LittleHobo wrote:Toffeehater wrote:LittleHobo wrote:ibrahimovic is dream land
as is berbatov
santa cruz has had a good half season, dont buy him based on that, file along side the portsmouth striker who is also unproved
dont think anelka is the right partner for torres although i rate him highly...file along side defoe and david villa......villa and torres never really clicked at international level
the ones i would like are just miles away from us signing at the moment......ibrahimovic and berbatov
berbatov getting back to form , he's just scored 4 goals against reading , the team we lost 3-1 to
my point is i just cant see us signing berbatov or ibrahimovic
bigger teams than us would get them
But this is Liverpool, the biggest and greatest football team in the world.
Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 53 guests