
bigmick wrote:There are times when I just can't see this meticulous building process for the life of me.
) and the "he's too defensive" argument fails to convince me either but when it comes to the buying and selling of players, there's now enough evidence to raise an eyebrow. When Rafa's been given money he has frequently spent well, in the case of Torres, Mascherano or Alonso for example. But, that old argument has been recently sullied by the money spent on Keane and Babel and other fairly expensive signings who don't look like the players we need to fill the gaps we have in the squad. In some cases, Rafa has done brilliantly to sign unfancied players with reasonably modest transfer funds who turn out to be quality (Reina, Skrtel and Agger come to mind). In other cases, the bargain buys have not been up to it (Voronin, Pennant, Zenden, Josemi...). True, he ships them out sharpish but there seems to be a revolving door in particular positions that have been problem areas for ages. Eventually, a lad like Riera or Arbeloa come along and have enough quality to make a position their own but, if we're honest, they're still a level below the players our rivals can put out in those same crucial positions. And then there's the whole Alonso thing this summer, which was a real eye opener. I contended at the time that swapping Alonso for Barry was a major mistake and I think Xabi's subsequent form has borne me out (I'm not saying Barry's not a good player but we didn't need to waste the better part of the transfer window trying to replace a quality central midfielder with another quality central midfielder). I can't for the life of me understand why we would have been looking to move on one of our better players (and one of Rafa's most successful signings) when so many other pieces of the puzzle were still missing. So, like you Mick, I'm beginning to wonder if we're building to anything better with our signings year upon year because there seems to be a lot of trial and error going on.
They won the title then due to other teams playing absolutely shyte.Just to point out wasnt it houllier who arranged our defence.
. You can use numbers and facts to paint any reality you wish.

Sabre wrote:So, Bob, you wouldn't give him a long contract now, right?![]()
The revolving doors criticism in some positions is undeniable. The fact we're debating to bring back Heskey speaks volumes. Only Torres signing has been convincing enough upfront, and I admit that criticism.
In the CM, he has built a much stronger team than the one that Houllier had. When Mick asked Gravesen and others, he wouldn't have mounted as strong midfield as Rafa has built, so in the CM department he has done the homework. It's true he was tempted to sell Alonso, or so it seems (there's the possibility of it being a way to press Xabi or Parry). But in the CM has done his homework.
In the CB, he has done the homework. 4 years ago I was worried about how we would make the transition from Carra-Hyypia, to the next CB, and IMHO Rafa might have secured the future.
In the Goal, a crucial position, he got it right from moment one when Reina still had things to prove.
In the wings, is where the revolving doors description is true. Riera ended it in the left only recently, and in the right we have tried lots of things but none convinced bar Gerrard.
Another positive point of Rafa is that he's able to make the players thinking we're building something. Alonso didn't want to go even if it happened what happened. Mascherano doesn't want to leave. Gerrard had temptations to go some years back, now nobody is worried. Torres would deny a millionaire offer of City. So, I think, that's an unbiased sign of progress. Normally players leave when they don't see they'll win titles, or when they don't earn enough money.
At this point you have to take a decission whether that's progress or not. You can't wait until the end of season because many teams will knocking Rafa's door (I think that if other teams want him is because they see progress in our club right?), so it's the time to give him a contract, or not.
IMHO he has done enough to get it, and automatically that answers the question of the thread.

dawson99 wrote:bob, show me the last manager we had whose transfer policy wasn't suspect... evans?

Raffmaker wrote:You all take yourselves far too seiously, digging out all of this history, transfers in- transfers out, league tables, Rafa's previous record.
None of it matters, and no one cares. Using the past as a measuring stick for the future is a dangerous game.
Also, say we don't win the league this season, what will happen next season, season after and season after?
Exact same scenrario,, Chelsea, and Man ure will all be just as strong or stronger, Man City have won the jackpot. All of these clubs have got not only the cream of the Europe crop in their teams, they have also got the cream of the Europe youngsters in their academys, for at least the next five seasons we will struggle to challenge for the league, unless we strive to bring better quality in throughout.
Its so simple like 1+1=2.
It goes Money + Quality = Title.


Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot], Google Adsense [Bot], Majestic-12 [Bot] and 448 guests