LIVERPOOLANYTIME wrote:![]()
This thread has had some good debate and has been good reading, just like to add my two pence to the argument.
I have to say that Owen is NOT a 'World Class' striker.
He is a good striker and if you go on his scoring record then this is easily backed up and you cold even argue that he has a 'world class' scoring record, which to be honest, probably cant be argued against.
However in my opinion this DOES NOT make him a world class striker by any means. Maybe a contradiction of terms but i dont think it is!!
His all round game is poor and apart from puting it in the back of the net, what does he actully bring to the team as a whole. I know some will argue that bringing goals is all that matters when talking about strikers, which to a point is correct, but for ME you need to bring and show more (main reason we are looking at crouch IMO).
He cannot hold the ball up well, and when he does he tends to be selfish with his passing. What makes me say this is that, i have seen Owen MANY times, play a ball to say a winger, but in such a way that the only otion for the player receiving the ball is to play Owen in, he tends to play the ball very wide or behind the oncoming teammate as to give HIMSELF time to get in the box!! For me this shows a selfish attitude (though this can be expected from strikers you might say,but then you look at Henry and this isnt the case).
Michael Owen has very little skill, and often gets between defenders, not through skill, but through getting lucky knocks off the defenders legs etc; (anyone who disagrees....you need to really need to check this out), and being so small he is able to squirm past players,who are often worried about fouling him in the area.
I dont think Rafa likes his style of play and on the whole doesnt really rate him,hence he was allowed to leave without much of a fight. He simply doesnt fit into Rafa's style of play. Owen is at his best when playing off the shoulder of defenders and relying on his pace to get onto the through balls.
With rafa, i see a more methodical style of play, and personally i dont think owen has the attributes to play this way, he is a SIMPLE player and wants it put through so he can run on to it, otherwise he finds it difficult to score.
After the 2001 treble,why do you think we struggled - in my opinion - it was because teams had cottoned on to the way that we played and always looked for Owen via a SG long through ball.
So it comes as no surprise that we win the CL after he left, IMO, if he was still here we would ave played a lot differently and the players would still have focused the attention on getting the ball to SG, in the hope he would find Owen and thats how we would get our goals.
Owen hardly EVER scored from outside the box, and was unable to score an array of different types of goals - he just reminded me of Lineker to be honest. Compare to another Anfield hero - Fowler - he could score from outside the box, volleys and even free kicks!! Cant imagine Owen taking a free kick can you?
Some people will obviously disagree with a lot i ave said no doubt, but personally i look at football and footballers as a whole package, and although Owen does score a lot of goals, his WHOLE package is poor IMO.
The thing is IF he ISNT scoring, then WHAT DOES HE BRING that will benefit the team??
For example we know that Mori will not be a 20-30 goal a season man, but he REALLY can link play properly and create for OTHERS (of course he still has to show this to us, but we still know he CAN do that).
Another example is Cisse, just the other night he was played out wide, though not his natural position e was still able to make a decent impact and cause problems and create chances for OTHERS. Can you imagine Owen playing out wide?? Hmmmm, dont think so!!
As (john craig i think) said, the stats dont tell the whole story, yes he does have a 1:2 ratio, which is up with the best, but a lot of these goals were against 'weaker' opposition and then we have the 10 in 6 games type of thing followed by a spell of 7 without a goal for example.
If he was world class and he supposedly wants out of Real at the moment, then how come the likes of Barca, Milan(either one) and the rest of the usual suspects dont seem to be interested?
If he was world class, then why does he have extreme problems getting past real class strikers such as raul/ronaldo??
Three managers cant all be wrong in their estimations of owen, by placing him on the bench.
Madrid only bought him, to appease their fans clamouring for a 'big name' signing, not a big player, but a big name!!
I am sorry but Owen made the decision to leave, and now he is regretting it, we should not pander to his need of playing regularly so he can be a starter at the world cup next year.
IMO Rooney/defoe would be alot more devastating than Rooney/Owen - Why, we know what Rooney can do, but Defoe has a lot more to his game than Owen does and will in time be a lot better than Owen (IMO of course!)
stu_the_red wrote:Posted: July 15 2005,13:56
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote (maximus @ July 15 2005,13:32)
Quote (LFC #1 @ July 15 2005,13:29)
Quote (banana @ July 15 2005,13:21)
To LFC#1
Don't be stupid. Owen doesn't fit in his system and into his football philosophy. Pure and simple.
That may be so (debatable), but you still fail to answer my question on why you dislike the lad so much.
You once called him "mediocre", which shows a distinct lack of knowledge on the player, plain and simple.
I get the feeling you have some personal hatred of him because of his 'controversial' transfer to Real Madrid, or perhaps you have no idea what you are talking about?
I can just see Banana sitting there watching the 2001 cup final, professing that the midget is mediocre!!![]()
Fickle fans
Go drink a glass of milk lad
Talking about 2001 will get you nowhere
Rafa is thinking about 2006-2010
Owen is not in his plans. Owen is out of favour in Madrid and desperate to get some football before the world cup finals. We should not let him use LFC just to get fit for the world cup. LFC is not Owen's playground.
AND
Nothing is permanent in football. How many good seasons did Maradona have after 1988? Ok, drugs did him. So what? Owen is injury prone and has a big ego. And most importantly; Owen is not suited to play it Rafa style. Rafa is building a TEAM. He is not after 11 individuals. Apart form hanging around and putting a few goals, Owen doesn't bring much to the table. i care about the WHOLE game. I do not care about how many goals a single player scores or what car he drives. Owen doesn't take part in the build up play, he is not working hard for his team mates, and he has not the skills required to be first striker at LFC. Accept it.
Go and drink a glass of milk scott... whats that gotta do with anythin?![]()
Owen has injury problems and yes he will be missing for 2 months every season. Whats your point? He still manages MORE than double the amount of goals Baros scored. In fact, i bet if we got him fit for one season, he'd treble what Baros scores.
As for not being suited to Rafa's style... you're surely having a laugh? Under Houllier Owen had to do it all alone with no support from midfield and only Murphy and Gerrard capable of playing the balls he needs to do most damage, no he'd have Zenden, Gerrard, Alonso, Luis Garcia and Morientes in there, all with a brain and all clever players who play the sort of football Owen has always played. Which is on the floor, fast and intelligent football.
Owen hangs around and puts a few goals in? Well i've got news for you lad. Goals win you games. Now i'm not bein funny, but the reason our away record under Houllier was so good is because of Owen. He scored away from home at any ground and where we'd lose 1-0 away, we might have drew 1-1, or won 2-1, or where we'd draw 0-0 we'd win 1-0. How many games has Baros WON for us this season with his goals or how many games has he saved us from defeat? Millwall and Palace? i can't think of any more off the top of my head.
As for Owen not being hard working, you're simply talking out of your. The lad doesn't charge round like Baros like a headless chicken. He simply looks at the defenders, splits them up, makes them play into a certain area and doesn't let them pick him off as easily as Baros does, he holds his position which is the more sensible and knowledgable thing to do. Anyone who thinks he's lazy, has simply never watched him play. Its as simple as that.
You say he doesn't bring much else to the team except goals. Well, again, i encourage you to actually watch him play live. He's a goal threat every second he's on the pitch and keeps two defenders occuppied at nearly all times. He also does't conceed possession as stupidly and needlessly as Baros and he also releases the ball quicker than Baros and normally to a player in space aswell. Again if you'd watched him play, he recieves the ball, he plays a pass and the fans clap... the fans don't clap because its Owen, they clap because its a good pass to a player with alot of space. This is why fans are very annoyed with Baros, he just fails to do this EVERY time he gets the ball.
When you're a striker and you're 35 yards away from goal and the ball comes into you with your back to goal you look for a pass to a player in space or on the move who's going to help you get closer to the goal, you then make your move once you've released the ball to that player in space who in turn again has to do something positive, this keeps the momentum going. With the fabulous headless chicken Baros, this momentum breaks down ALL the time. The things is this side now has the ability to get the very best out of Owen. We have more players on his wave length in a similar class. 4 years ago, we didn't.
cisses_gona_get_ya wrote:I would take Owen back tomorrow, I bet he is kicking himself that he left. We would have some team with him upfront with Morientes or Cisse, they would be banging goals in for fun.
We are in desperate need for a 20+ a season striker, what if Morientes and Cisse cant hack the prem this season? Do we just rely on Risse, Gerrard and Garcia to score goals for us again?
Baros is practicly 99% gone, plus he couldnt lace Owens boots, and if Michael only wants to come back so that he will be first choice for Sven in the WC so what?
If he scored a bagfull of goals like Maximus said the games we lost last season we would have won or drawn alot of them.
And Banana do you know Rafa? I dont think so, so how do you know Owen wont fit in his plans?
Hes a striker isnt he? Something we are despretly lacking.
Come home Micky youve been missed Big time.
stmichael wrote:i've had this debate so many times now it's getting boring.![]()
the thing with michael owen is, like wayne rooney now, he was so good at such a young age that people are comparing him now to what he was like when he first broke through into the first team.
i suppose you could say it was the exhuberance of youth or playing without fear that originally made him so frightening for defences to play against. but as time went on, defences learned how to play against him, and michael also had terrible problems with his hamstrings.
go back to 2001. from the end of the treble season until about 6 weeks into the 2002 season he scored 29 goals in 25 games, including a hatrick for england in munich. he was the hottest property in european football after picking up the european footballer of the year award. at this stage, had he been playing for manure or arsenal, he would have kicked on to be truly world class. unfortunately he ended up playing in a team which for two years played dreadful football and strived him of service.
having said all that, he's still the one player you would put your house on to score in games that really matter. bring owen back now and he'd score a hatful, especially with the players we have now to provide the ammunition.
cisses_gona_get_ya wrote:stmichael wrote:i've had this debate so many times now it's getting boring.![]()
the thing with michael owen is, like wayne rooney now, he was so good at such a young age that people are comparing him now to what he was like when he first broke through into the first team.
i suppose you could say it was the exhuberance of youth or playing without fear that originally made him so frightening for defences to play against. but as time went on, defences learned how to play against him, and michael also had terrible problems with his hamstrings.
go back to 2001. from the end of the treble season until about 6 weeks into the 2002 season he scored 29 goals in 25 games, including a hatrick for england in munich. he was the hottest property in european football after picking up the european footballer of the year award. at this stage, had he been playing for manure or arsenal, he would have kicked on to be truly world class. unfortunately he ended up playing in a team which for two years played dreadful football and strived him of service.
having said all that, he's still the one player you would put your house on to score in games that really matter. bring owen back now and he'd score a hatful, especially with the players we have now to provide the ammunition.
Remember this time last year St you was going to get a new ID
LIVERPOOLANYTIME wrote:![]()
This thread has had some good debate and has been good reading, just like to add my two pence to the argument.
I have to say that Owen is NOT a 'World Class' striker.
He is a good striker and if you go on his scoring record then this is easily backed up and you cold even argue that he has a 'world class' scoring record, which to be honest, probably cant be argued against.
However in my opinion this DOES NOT make him a world class striker by any means. Maybe a contradiction of terms but i dont think it is!!
His all round game is poor and apart from puting it in the back of the net, what does he actully bring to the team as a whole. I know some will argue that bringing goals is all that matters when talking about strikers, which to a point is correct, but for ME you need to bring and show more (main reason we are looking at crouch IMO).
He cannot hold the ball up well, and when he does he tends to be selfish with his passing. What makes me say this is that, i have seen Owen MANY times, play a ball to say a winger, but in such a way that the only otion for the player receiving the ball is to play Owen in, he tends to play the ball very wide or behind the oncoming teammate as to give HIMSELF time to get in the box!! For me this shows a selfish attitude (though this can be expected from strikers you might say,but then you look at Henry and this isnt the case).
Michael Owen has very little skill, and often gets between defenders, not through skill, but through getting lucky knocks off the defenders legs etc; (anyone who disagrees....you need to really need to check this out), and being so small he is able to squirm past players,who are often worried about fouling him in the area.
I dont think Rafa likes his style of play and on the whole doesnt really rate him,hence he was allowed to leave without much of a fight. He simply doesnt fit into Rafa's style of play. Owen is at his best when playing off the shoulder of defenders and relying on his pace to get onto the through balls.
With rafa, i see a more methodical style of play, and personally i dont think owen has the attributes to play this way, he is a SIMPLE player and wants it put through so he can run on to it, otherwise he finds it difficult to score.
After the 2001 treble,why do you think we struggled - in my opinion - it was because teams had cottoned on to the way that we played and always looked for Owen via a SG long through ball.
So it comes as no surprise that we win the CL after he left, IMO, if he was still here we would ave played a lot differently and the players would still have focused the attention on getting the ball to SG, in the hope he would find Owen and thats how we would get our goals.
Owen hardly EVER scored from outside the box, and was unable to score an array of different types of goals - he just reminded me of Lineker to be honest. Compare to another Anfield hero - Fowler - he could score from outside the box, volleys and even free kicks!! Cant imagine Owen taking a free kick can you?
Some people will obviously disagree with a lot i ave said no doubt, but personally i look at football and footballers as a whole package, and although Owen does score a lot of goals, his WHOLE package is poor IMO.
The thing is IF he ISNT scoring, then WHAT DOES HE BRING that will benefit the team??
For example we know that Mori will not be a 20-30 goal a season man, but he REALLY can link play properly and create for OTHERS (of course he still has to show this to us, but we still know he CAN do that).
Another example is Cisse, just the other night he was played out wide, though not his natural position e was still able to make a decent impact and cause problems and create chances for OTHERS. Can you imagine Owen playing out wide?? Hmmmm, dont think so!!
As (john craig i think) said, the stats dont tell the whole story, yes he does have a 1:2 ratio, which is up with the best, but a lot of these goals were against 'weaker' opposition and then we have the 10 in 6 games type of thing followed by a spell of 7 without a goal for example.
If he was world class and he supposedly wants out of Real at the moment, then how come the likes of Barca, Milan(either one) and the rest of the usual suspects dont seem to be interested?
If he was world class, then why does he have extreme problems getting past real class strikers such as raul/ronaldo??
Three managers cant all be wrong in their estimations of owen, by placing him on the bench.
Madrid only bought him, to appease their fans clamouring for a 'big name' signing, not a big player, but a big name!!
I am sorry but Owen made the decision to leave, and now he is regretting it, we should not pander to his need of playing regularly so he can be a starter at the world cup next year.
IMO Rooney/defoe would be alot more devastating than Rooney/Owen - Why, we know what Rooney can do, but Defoe has a lot more to his game than Owen does and will in time be a lot better than Owen (IMO of course!)
He is a good striker and if you go on his scoring record then this is easily backed up and you cold even argue that he has a 'world class' scoring record, which to be honest, probably cant be argued against.
However in my opinion this DOES NOT make him a world class striker by any means. Maybe a contradiction of terms but i dont think it is!!
His all round game is poor and apart from puting it in the back of the net, what does he actully bring to the team as a whole. I know some will argue that bringing goals is all that matters when talking about strikers, which to a point is correct, but for ME you need to bring and show more (main reason we are looking at crouch IMO).
He cannot hold the ball up well, and when he does he tends to be selfish with his passing. What makes me say this is that, i have seen Owen MANY times, play a ball to say a winger, but in such a way that the only otion for the player receiving the ball is to play Owen in, he tends to play the ball very wide or behind the oncoming teammate as to give HIMSELF time to get in the box!! For me this shows a selfish attitude (though this can be expected from strikers you might say,but then you look at Henry and this isnt the case).
Michael Owen has very little skill, and often gets between defenders, not through skill, but through getting lucky knocks off the defenders legs etc; (anyone who disagrees....you need to really need to check this out), and being so small he is able to squirm past players,who are often worried about fouling him in the area.
I dont think Rafa likes his style of play and on the whole doesnt really rate him,hence he was allowed to leave without much of a fight. He simply doesnt fit into Rafa's style of play. Owen is at his best when playing off the shoulder of defenders and relying on his pace to get onto the through balls.
With rafa, i see a more methodical style of play, and personally i dont think owen has the attributes to play this way, he is a SIMPLE player and wants it put through so he can run on to it, otherwise he finds it difficult to score.After the 2001 treble,why do you think we struggled - in my opinion - it was because teams had cottoned on to the way that we played and always looked for Owen via a SG long through ball.
So it comes as no surprise that we win the CL after he left, IMO, if he was still here we would ave played a lot differently and the players would still have focused the attention on getting the ball to SG, in the hope he would find Owen and thats how we would get our goals.
Return to Liverpool FC - General Discussion
Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], Google [Bot] and 127 guests