Liverpool FC Forum

[SouthCoastShankly]

Last Game: Birmingham (A)

Game Average
Reina 9.53
Konchesky 6.59
Carragher 6.09
Meireles 6.00
Gerrard 5.65
Skrtel 5.24
Agger 5.24
Jovanovic 5.18
Torres 4.94
Poulsen 4.82
Johnson 4.29
Maxi 4.06
Lucas 3.59

Season Average
See above!

[Benny The Noon]

I think those marks pretty much reflect the performance we saw as well .

[metalhead]

Ok this is my rating as far as I go against Birmingham

Reina - 9 - two brilliant saves that kept us in the game nuff said..

Konchesky - 7 - Solid debut, some brilliant crosses and he never put a foot wrong

Carragher - 7 - game reading was excellent again, did well

Skrtel - 6 - a bit dodgy, caught ball watching a couple of times, but he tackled well

Johnson - 5 - one of his worst game in the Liverpool shirt, nothing went for him, dispossessed, didn't go forward too much, caught out of position, need to get his old form back

Maxi - 5 - Absolutely poor, I thought in the second half he picked it up a bit, especially in the first 10 minutes of the 2nd half with his good passing, but went back to being quite.

Lucas - 4 -  awful, poor passing, poor positioning, conceding silly freekicks, dispossessed the ball, couldn't give a forward pass (even when he did it ended up with the opposition), has to be dropped

Poulsen - 6 - showed some quality passing in the first half, but he needs to be more assertive. Gone really quite in the 2nd half.

Jovanovic - 6 - Better than Maxi, very determined, runs, tries to link up, plays short passes and one - twos. However, he seems static, runs into players.

Gerrard - 6 - some decent balls, when shifted to center mid he did very well to contain birmingham's midfield and we did play better in the last 15 minutes.

Torres - 5 - starved off service, looked frustrated with the passes he got, showed a bit of rustiness as well (his first touch).

Subs:

Agger - 6 - did well, can't say much, did nothing wrong

Meireles - 6 - changed the  game in our favor, good forward passing, he looks very dynamic as well, I hope we see more of him

[Benny The Noon]

Mh - SouthCoast Shankly is doing a weekly update type thread and ratings are posted here -

http://www.liverpoolfc-newkit.co.uk/viewtopic.php?p=1045410#p1045410

this is just the thread to keep a running score

[metalhead]

lol! cheers.. too late for me to submit my scores then

[bigmick]

Last Game: Birmingham (A)

Game Average
Reina 9.53
Konchesky 6.59
Carragher 6.09
Meireles 6.00
Gerrard 5.65
Skrtel 5.24
Agger 5.24
Jovanovic 5.18
Torres 4.94
Poulsen 4.82
Johnson 4.29
Maxi 4.06
Lucas 3.59

Season Average
See above!

Intersting scores. Lucas is a bit high IMHO.

[Benny The Noon]

That's the good thing about what Scs is doing - it shows how the whole forum rates him on an average and think it will be close enough throughout the season to how they actually play

[lakes10]

Reina 9
Konchesky 6
Carragher 6
Meireles 5
Gerrard 7
Skrtel 6
Agger 5
Jovanovic 4
Torres 3......sorry but he is well out of it right now.
Poulsen 5
Johnson 5
Maxi 3.....oh dear
Lucas 2...if that, he looked ok when he had the ball...untill he gave it away.

[red till i die!!]

Ok this is my rating as far as I go against Birmingham

Reina - 9 - two brilliant saves that kept us in the game nuff said..

Konchesky - 7 - Solid debut, some brilliant crosses and he never put a foot wrong

Carragher - 7 - game reading was excellent again, did well

Skrtel - 6 - a bit dodgy, caught ball watching a couple of times, but he tackled well

Johnson - 5 - one of his worst game in the Liverpool shirt, nothing went for him, dispossessed, didn't go forward too much, caught out of position, need to get his old form back

Maxi - 5 - Absolutely poor, I thought in the second half he picked it up a bit, especially in the first 10 minutes of the 2nd half with his good passing, but went back to being quite.

Lucas - 4 -  awful, poor passing, poor positioning, conceding silly freekicks, dispossessed the ball, couldn't give a forward pass (even when he did it ended up with the opposition), has to be dropped

Poulsen - 6 - showed some quality passing in the first half, but he needs to be more assertive. Gone really quite in the 2nd half.

Jovanovic - 6 - Better than Maxi, very determined, runs, tries to link up, plays short passes and one - twos. However, he seems static, runs into players.

Gerrard - 6 - some decent balls, when shifted to center mid he did very well to contain birmingham's midfield and we did play better in the last 15 minutes.

Torres - 5 - starved off service, looked frustrated with the passes he got, showed a bit of rustiness as well (his first touch).

Subs:

Agger - 6 - did well, can't say much, did nothing wrong

Meireles - 6 - changed the  game in our favor, good forward passing, he looks very dynamic as well, I hope we see more of him

spot on there metal .
good scoring and honest asessment. 

[SouthCoastShankly]

I've added the late comers score, try and keep them to the game ratings thread chaps

[SouthCoastShankly]

Update -

Last Game: Birmingham (a)


Reina 9.52
Konchesky 6.60
Carragher 6.17
Meireles 5.90
Gerrard 5.71
Skrtel 5.36
Agger 5.24
Jovanovic 5.19
Poulsen 4.95
Torres 4.79
Johnson 4.38
Maxi 4.02
Lucas 3.50


Voters -

SouthCoastShankly
Thewaykokid
Redman In Wales
Lee J
europian-kings
Benny The Noon
Igor Zidane
Madmax
Rushie#9
Fauxy
bigmick
Cool Hand Luke
Fowler_E7
aCe'
TarnRed
Woof Woof
matt_liverpool
metalhead
lakes10
Aussie Style
red till I die!!

[SouthCoastShankly]

Last Game: Steaua Bucharest (h) - 16/09/2010

Game Average
Cole 7.84
Spearing 7.03
Ngog 7.00
Reina 6.79
Meireles 6.68
Lucas 6.68
Agger 6.42
Kyrgiakos 6.32
Kelly 6.13
Babel 5.97
Konchesky 5.89
Maxi 5.87
Pacheco 5.68
Eccleston 5.53

Season Average
games in brackets
Reina 8.16 (2)
Cole 7.84 (1)
Spearing 7.03 (1)
Ngog 7.00 (1)
Kyrgiakos 6.32 (1)
Meireles 6.29 (2)
Konchesky 6.24 (2)
Carragher 6.17 (1)
Kelly 6.13 (1)
Babel 5.97 (1)
Agger 5.83 (2)
Gerrard 5.71 (1)
Pacheco 5.68 (1)
Eccleston 5.53 (1)
Skrtel 5.36 (1)
Jovanovic 5.19 (1)
Lucas 5.09 (2)
Poulsen 4.95 (1)
Maxi 4.95 (2)
Torres 4.79 (1)
Johnson 4.38 (1)

[SouthCoastShankly]

Last Game: Man Utd (a) - 19/09/2010

Game Average
Gerrard 7.64
Meireles 7.17
Cole 6.36
Torres 6.06
Reina 6.03
Johnson 5.67
Poulsen 5.61
Carragher 5.17
Agger 5.11
Skrtel 5.11
Ngog 5.06
Jovanovic 4.67
Konchesky 4.47
Maxi 4.00

Season Average

Reina 7.45 (3)
Cole 7.10 (2)
Spearing 7.03 (1)
Gerrard 6.66 (2)
Meireles 6.57 (3)
Kyrgiakos 6.32 (1)
Kelly 6.13 (1)
Ngog 6.03 (2)
Babel 5.97 (1)
Konchesky 5.68 (3)
Pacheco 5.68 (1)
Carragher 5.66 (2)
Agger 5.59 (3)
Eccleston 5.53 (1)
Torres 5.43 (2)
Poulsen 5.21 (2)
Skrtel 5.20 (2)
Lucas 5.15 (2)
Johnson 4.97 (2)
Jovanovic 4.92 (2)
Maxi 4.63 (3)

[Dundalk]

Added this in the Forum Index

[SouthCoastShankly]

Last Game: Sunderland (h) - 25/09/2010

Game Average
Gerrard 6.58
Cole 6.04
Torres 6.04
Skrtel 6.00
Reina 5.96
Ngog 5.58
Agger 5.58
Kuyt 5.50
Meireles 5.42
Carragher 5.00
Konchesky 4.33
Johnson 4.00
Poulsen 3.50

Season Average
Reina 7.08 - 4
Spearing 7.03 - 1
Cole 6.75 - 3
Gerrard 6.63 - 3
Kyrgiakos 6.32 - 1
Meireles 6.28 - 4
Kelly 6.13 - 1
Babel 5.97 - 1
Ngog 5.88 - 3
Pacheco 5.68 - 1
Torres 5.63 - 3
Agger 5.59 - 4
Eccleston 5.53 - 1
Kuyt 5.50 - 1
Skrtel 5.47 - 3
Carragher 5.44 - 3
Konchesky 5.31 - 4
Lucas 5.15 - 2
Jovanovic 4.92 - 2
Johnson 4.65 - 3
Poulsen 4.64 - 3
Maxi 4.63 - 3