bigmick wrote:Kharhaz wrote:Its down to pure luck, when luck isnt involved, you will win a small amount, but luck is the majority of the game. You get the players bragging "its down to skill", then you can counter argue why they have lost so many "good" hands. Of all the card games I have played, poker is the most fate reliant game there is, what other game can you win with a 2 of spades and A queen of clubs? Even snap has some sort of skill involved, that would be reaction ! Poker is a convenience game, just like blackjack. Doesnt it make you wonder why the two biggest games of luck are the two biggest games in casinos?
Hey I absolutely totally disagreee with you mate, but that's what aforum is for. If it was luck, the same players would win 2000 seat tournaments all the time though. IMHo it's got an element of luck toit roughly the same as a game of football. Put a top player in a room with each and every member of the forum with even numbers of chips, and they'd come out on top on most occasions.
Check out some of the footage on Youtube. Check out Joe's pick Daniel Neagranu, no luck involved when the fella can tell what cards you've in your hand, and actually tells you.
It is more luck than skill. I've been playing long enough to realize that. What Neagranau does is nothing special. He often gets it wrong as much as he gets it right when deducing hands, though he is better than most at doing it, though it's usually premium hands that are by the book, made hands like wired pairs (usually paint) and AK, AQ etc etc. I've called out people's exact hands before, usually by just watching them for a bit and figuring out their betting pattern. You can get massive reads off betting patterns. Forget the poker face. That's usually a myth, as the biggest tells are how people bet. It's far easier to play against a good poker player, than it is against a maniac player who is very loose and wreckless. For these players, you really do need to be tight and check them into the nuts when you have it. Cuts out the risk of bad beats.
The skill in poker is knowing when to play a hand, and knowing when to fold a good hand if you've got one, knowing you're beat. Far too many people look at hands like KQ or QJ and think these are made hands. They aren't. I usually toss them if I'm not getting the value, whereas a lot of poor players will pay limpers tax by flat calling, then getting busted by seeing top pair on the flop, but being kickered. The skill is knowledge, experience, and observation of your opponent.
The scenario you described is a perfect example of seeing the flop for cheap and having a draw with a few outs. Usually when a low flop comes down, and it's a rainbow (various suits) and someone pushes, it's an indicator of protection of an over pair the player has in the hole, or top top. I'd only call an all in in that situation if I was short stacked and getting the value depending on how many outs I had. Usually, an open-ended straight draw is a no-no for me to call my chips away with, though again this depends on my stack and if I'm getting the value.