Liverpool FC Forum

by **alessandromagno** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 9:22 am

Agree about Carragher: fine player but never should be number 7 in a list of all time greats. Just goes to show how the current players have a built in advantage.

by **PhiLFC** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 4:06 pm

Dalglish
Rush
Gerrard
Fowler
Barnes

I would like to have seen Keegan in there but its a special list isn't it? Gerrard and Rush will battle it out for 2nd place. Phil Neal's honours list is just f.ucking awesome.

Question... how the f.uck did Collymore get in above Craig Johnston? In fact how the f.uck did he get in there at all? For me Razor would have got in before Collymore the c.unt just for breaking Cole's legs with one tackle ha ha ha ha ha :buttrock

And take a look at who is at number 66... I honestly did not know that he played for us. Number 66 too the little devil :devil:

by **clik** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 5:01 pm

1 Dalglish
2 Gerrard
3Rush
4 Fowler
5 Whelan
Dont know if Ronnie has already appeared but he was a legend:)

by **CardinalRed** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 7:36 pm

J*o*n*D*o*e wrote:My top 5 would be

1) King Kenny
2) Ian Rush
3) Stevie G
4) Robbie Fowler
5) John Barnes

Ditto

by **alessandromagno** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 8:10 pm

Always moot these decisions about the greatest players. One great team would be:

Ray Clemence

Phil Neal Alan Hansen Tommy Smith Alan Kennedy

Steven Gerrard John Barnes Graham Souness Ray Kennedy

Kenny Dalglish Ian Rush

by **alessandromagno** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 8:21 pm

By the way, most people put RF in the top 5--but I doubt that he'd get into the greatest Liverpool team of many people here.[B]

by **woof woof !** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 8:56 pm

Is this a question about players who really shook the kop ,or just who our favourites are ?

IMO
players (not neccesarily my favourites) who shook the kop are

Dalglish
Ian St John
Rush
Keegan
Owen

Players that shook me

Dalglish
Rush
Souness
Grobbelaar (am I the only one to put a goalie in his top 5 ? )
Gerrard

by **Mikz** » Mon Oct 02, 2006 11:57 pm

Players that shook the kop for me brother...

Dalglish

Keegan

Rush

Gerrard

Hughes

by **red37** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 12:32 am

ill have for my top 100 last 5 pwstk:

1) dalglish
2) gerrard
3) rush
4) barnes
5) fowler

personally id pick:

1) dalglish
2) souness
3) keegan
4) rushie
4) gerrard

by **drummerphil** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 12:56 am

its a generation thing........top 5

?

??........imo........no player really from 1990.----.2006...would get near atop 5 from players around from 1974----1989

by **Lando_Griffin** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 1:05 am

Well Robbie has to be in the top 5 due to his scoring record and affinity with the fans.

The top 5 should be:

Dalglish
Rush
Fowler
Hughes
Liddel.

They are the fans' favourites of their respective era's.

My personal top 5 (as I'm too young to remember most of them):

God
Barnes
Rush
JC
Sami.

Obviously I only saw Rush and Barnes in the a*se-end of their careers, but could see the quality they once had.

by **account deleted by request** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:20 am

drummerphil wrote:its a generation thing........top 5 ? ? ??........imo........no player really from 1990.----.2006...would get near atop 5 from players around from 1974----1989

I think Emlyn Hughes got it right when he said that the modern teams would probably beat the team of the 70's and 80's because they are bigger, fitter, and faster, but that the modern team wouldnt get a touch of the ball for the first 70 minutes.

by **drummerphil** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:36 am

s@int wrote:
drummerphil wrote:its a generation thing........top 5 ? ? ??........imo........no player really from 1990.----.2006...would get near atop 5 from players around from 1974----1989

I think Emlyn Hughes got it right when he said that the modern teams would probably beat the team of the 70's and 80's because they are bigger, fitter, and faster, but that the modern team wouldnt get a touch of the ball for the first 70 minutes.

totally agree,these kind of threads are :censored:

really,unless you have lived and can remember the players week in week out,and performances over 30 years.Its far too easy to go with only what you have seen recently.WATCH VIDEOS AND DVDS And talk to people who were there.........then these type of best of threads can work properly.

by **crazyhorse** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 2:45 am

drummerphil wrote:
s@int wrote:
drummerphil wrote:its a generation thing........top 5 ? ? ??........imo........no player really from 1990.----.2006...would get near atop 5 from players around from 1974----1989

I think Emlyn Hughes got it right when he said that the modern teams would probably beat the team of the 70's and 80's because they are bigger, fitter, and faster, but that the modern team wouldnt get a touch of the ball for the first 70 minutes.

totally agree,these kind of threads are really,unless you have lived and can remember the players week in week out,and performances over 30 years.Its far too easy to go with only what you have seen recently.WATCH VIDEOS AND DVDS And talk to people who were there.........then these type of best of threads can work properly.

In full agreement Phil.

by **Mikz** » Tue Oct 03, 2006 7:48 am

Agree Phil, So many really great players, I know you mentioned Ray Kennedy and rightly so, but what about Terry McDermott too, what a dynamo he was. I can still see that goal he scored against Spurs.
And Steve Nicol too, not flashy by any means but nobody gave any more than him.

Liverpool FC Forum

100 players who shook the kop - Top 5

Who is online