Liverpool FC Forum

[RichardLFC1]

Well this week we will see the Top 5 players who have shook the kop. We havent seen stars like rush Gerrard Dalglish and in my opinion these will be the top 3.  your opinions

[alessandromagno]

Has Barnes already appeared?

[CousinIT]

Don't know what order but my top 5 will be:
Paisley
Dalglish
Rush
Gerrard
Emlyn Hughes

[PabloAimar]

i think it'll be....

1. steven gerrard

2. ian rush

3. kenny dalglish

4. robbie fowler

5. john barnes

[Rafa D]

1) Kenny Dalglish
2)Robbie Fowler
3) Ian Rush
4)Steve Gerrard
5)John Barnes

[alessandromagno]

1. Dalglish
2. Rush
3. Barnes
4. Gerrard
5. Fowler

[PabloAimar]

they'll put gerrard top because he's a current player,

rush second because of his scoring record,

dalglish above fowler because of his success as player/manager (rare),

fowler up there in top 5 because he is god,

barnes will be number 5 although personally i'd put him number 1 coz he's my hero

[J*o*n*D*o*e]

My top 5 would be

1) King Kenny
2) Ian Rush
3) Stevie G
4) Robbie Fowler
5) John Barnes

[account deleted by request]

1. Dalglish
2. Rush
3. Barnes
4. Gerrard
5. Fowler

Thats the one I would pick

[alessandromagno]

What about Roger Hunt? Did he already appear? It's all c.rap really because today's players obviously get an unbalanced boost by being contemporaries. As a player, Souness might deserve to be in the top 5 too.

[Rafa D]

Kenny will defo be top. I didn't see him play live, but he is a Mr Liverpool for every Liverpool fan pre 90's . King Kenny!!

[account deleted by request]

What about Roger Hunt? Did he already appear? It's all c.rap really because today's players obviously get an unbalanced boost by being contemporaries. As a player, Souness might deserve to be in the top 5 too.

I only ever saw Hunt in his fading years but from what I saw he wasnt in the same class as Rush, but I saw Souness at his peak and believe me he was better than Gerrard. The only thing Souness lacked was pace. He was like Hamman and Gerrard rolled into one, with a bit of Ben Thatcher for good measure.

[drummerphil]

1. Dalglish
2. Rush
3. Barnes
4. Gerrard
5. Fowler

Thats the one I would pick

cannot argue with that,given the choice of these 5 players........although,,,in my top 5 souness(3) and ray(2) kennedy would feature with kenny at (1.)......positions 4 and 5 are difficult.....with Fowler,Gerrard,Barnes,crazy horse,ian callaghan,ian st john and keegan fighting out two places.

[crazyhorse]

1. Dalglish
2. Rush
3. Barnes
4. Gerrard
5. Fowler

Thats the one I would pick

cannot argue with that,given the choice of these 5 players........although,,,in my top 5 souness(3) and ray(2) kennedy would feature with kenny at (1.)......positions 4 and 5 are difficult.....with Fowler,Gerrard,Barnes,crazy horse,ian callaghan,ian st john and keegan fighting out two places.

Agree there.

Crazyhorse was my own idol, so he would get in my top 5.

[NiftyNeil]

I'd go for

1 Dalglish
2 Gerrard
3 Rush
4 Fowler
5 Barnes

Personally, I don't think Fowler warrants a place in the top five, and how the hell did Carragher make number 7 ??