Liverpool FC Forum

[drummerphil]

Just noticed the vote on the clubs  main site.....
this is the current vote how it stands now.

Bill Shankly  5361
Bob Paisley  3703
Rafael Benitez  1604
Kenny Dalglish  415
Gerard Houllier  175
Joe Fagan  53
Roy Evans  46
Graeme Souness  31
John McKenna  15
Phil Taylor   8
Don Welsh   7
William Barclay   6
Matt McQueen   5
George Patterson   4
George Kay   3
David Ashworth   2



are there really 31 people out there who thought souness was our best manager....beggars belief

[red37]

id have put joe fagan higher.. and i have thought that through!!

[stmichael]

Phil Taylor   8

should have stuck to darts.

[dward]

Phil Taylor   8

should have stuck to darts.

heh heh

[Roger Red Hat]

I would swap the top two around, only my opinion though. King Kenny should be just above Rafa due to the time in management, but Rafa should be a strong 3rd in 6 seasons time.

[drummerphil]

i agree,rafa needs to win the title

[zarababe]

Benitez's Euro triumph and his dignified personality seems to have convinced many to vote for him. I agree that at present Dalglish anf Joe Fagan would be above Benitez for now, but in a few years well the Boss will make-up ground.. "for sure"   Oooh I lurve Benitez .. respect to the Boss

[dxavier]

I have to say, Fagan should be much Higher. Third or perhaps fourth just behind Benitez who I believe will win alot more in the years to come. If winning the Champions League in your first year is anything to go by, then we have alot of good times ahead.

[SouthCoastShankly]

I think Rafa's rank is purely based on hysteria around the Champions league win. I'm surprised at the lack of votes for Kenny - i thought he'd reach 3rd at least

[Cisse's Beard]

I'd have wanted it to turn out like this:
Bill Shankly
Bob Paisley 
Joe Fagan
Kenny Dalglish
Rafael Benitez
Roy Evans 
Gerard Houllier
Graeme Souness
John McKenna
Phil Taylor   
Don Welsh   
William Barclay   
Matt McQueen   
George Patterson   
George Kay   
David Ashworth   

Benitez is only that high because he's relitavly new, won the champions league, and hasn't had the time to do something wrong.

[JohnBull]

There are 15 people out there who honestly think that Phil Taylor and Don Welsh deserve a vote ?

I blame Margaret Thatcher for stopping free school milk. Christ it was terrible being a red kid in the taylor/welsh years

[Cisse's Beard]

Luckily for me, I'm growing up as a teenager in the Rafa years!

[drummerphil]

I grew up in the paisley years so i must be even luckier

[DrTNT]

In eight to ten years Rafa will be up there with Shankly and  Paisley, he has done well so far (maybe thats an under statement  ) but I believe he will bring back the glory years to Anfield in the near future.   

[XSD]

Fagan is below Benitez and Houllier? :/