Liverpool FC Forum

RED BEERGOGGLES wrote:Correct me if I am mistaken ......... but  I was under the impression this thread  was just meant as a gauge to determine a players performance over the course of a season ,not a vehicle for the thread starter to argue against the scores given by other posters ,or debate the ability of a player in that specified game ..... am I wrong  ? ...its just there is enough arguing in other threads without this being corrupted also .....

SouthCoastShankly wrote:

RED BEERGOGGLES wrote:Correct me if I am mistaken ......... but  I was under the impression this thread  was just meant as a gauge to determine a players performance over the course of a season ,not a vehicle for the thread starter to argue against the scores given by other posters ,or debate the ability of a player in that specified game ..... am I wrong  ? ...its just there is enough arguing in other threads without this being corrupted also .....

Your right, it's the wrong place.

But FWIW we weren't arguing. I think with all the actual arguing going on round here, actual debates get misconstrued.

RED BEERGOGGLES wrote:

SouthCoastShankly wrote:

RED BEERGOGGLES wrote:Correct me if I am mistaken ......... but  I was under the impression this thread  was just meant as a gauge to determine a players performance over the course of a season ,not a vehicle for the thread starter to argue against the scores given by other posters ,or debate the ability of a player in that specified game ..... am I wrong  ? ...its just there is enough arguing in other threads without this being corrupted also .....

Your right, it's the wrong place.

But FWIW we weren't arguing. I think with all the actual arguing going on round here, actual debates get misconstrued.

I wasn't being deliberately pedantic SCS its just it would be such a shame if the debates deterred people from posting their evaluations in this thread ....