Liverpool FC Forum

[Santa]

Not a chance, Fergie isn't stupid and would never let him go to us

well he is stupid enough to let Forlan goes to Villareal...now he ended up top scorer in La Liga    Well done Diego for sticking two fingers up Fergie's a*ss 

being fair to ferguson he looked sh` 1te for united, except when he played against us the f@cker.
being from a latin background the move to spain obviously made the lad feel more at home and his game prospered. he was obviously a decent footballer because i cant imagine anyone who`s totally rubbish getting to the pro level in south america. there`s too much competition for places. some might not settle in europe or adapt to the change in culture but they must have been good at some point. there`s probably lads cleaning windows in rio who would put half the prem to shame but just never got spotted.

I know what you mean but still ...   

[barnesrush]

The lad wont cost 6 million as he only has 12 months left on his contract and hes not signing another one.Manure will take between 2 or 3 million i would imagine.Hes a long way off being the finished article and hes got a lot to learn,but who would bet against Rafa bringing out the best in him?He reminds me of a young Tony Adams,awkward,gangly,but he went on to become the best defender in england.We should bite the sc.ums hand off if theyre willing to sell him to us at a fair price.

best post on the subject in my view. allthose sayin fergie wont sell him would do well to realise where the power at manure lies these days. glazer said he wouldnt promise to not make these decisions himself (tricky sentence) so it aint all up to rudolph. and as many have said he is nearly out of contract so im sure they would like a bit of cash if he aint signin a new one. id welcome any quality player who wants to play for us, as if he was truly manc scum then he wouldnt want to come here would he eh

good on the ball, strong, determined, two good feet, used to the premiership, adaptable to cover a variety of positions, allows us to stick two fingers up at the mancs when they realise what they are missin, i could go on.....

[RedorDead]

I agree, he is a good young player with a lot of potential and for 2-3 mill would be a bargain in my opinion.

[stapo1000]

I dont like the thought of us buying manc rejects. Have we ever bought a player off them before?
I know we bought ince from inter after he was wit them and matt busby played for liverpool before he played with them but has there ever been a player to move directly between the 2 clubs ?

[L-type]

Well to be fair O' Shea tried to help us win earlier in the year, but Mike Riley not to be outdone decided to give Silvestre 2 goals from imaginary free kicks.

[LFC #1]

I dont like the thought of us buying manc rejects. Have we ever bought a player off them before?
I know we bought ince from inter after he was wit them and matt busby played for liverpool before he played with them but has there ever been a player to move directly between the 2 clubs ?

Yes, as somone mentioned earlier, Shanks bought Phil Chisnall directly from Manure.

[The Manhattan Project]

He can join LFC if he calls a press conference and p*sses on a Manure shirt.

[Paul C]

He can join LFC if he calls a press conference and p*sses on a Manure shirt.

That would be mint 

[hawkmoon269]

He can join LFC if he calls a press conference and p*sses on a Manure shirt.

Ummmm..... now that's one to see!!!!!     Do you think you can get him to 5h.1te  on it as well?

[Ace Ventura]

I would be very surprised to see him sold to lfc, but would be happy with it.
If he is a Man U reject but they keep Brown...just shows Fergie is losing the plot.
O'Shea is decent with the ball, good in the air an not short of pace either.
For 3 million he would be a useful signing.

[woof woof !]

If he's that good why are they letting him go ?

[MilitiaRusher]

If he's that bad why are we trying to buy him?

[taff]

If and I mean IF this is true I think he would be a good buy

Assuming its cheap cos of 12 months left on contract and assuming he doesnt see a future for himself at Man Utd.

But something doesnt smell right about this to be honest

[MilitiaRusher]

Sense conspiracy? Fat Fergie delibrately sending O'Shea over to destroy our team?

[desperado0831]

I think we should go for it despite he's a manu player right this term. For example, i still remember lots of people was talking dirty behind carra long time ago when he's first played in our team but now he become the most useful prospect for us. O'shea and carra are same kind of player that can handle all those defensive position. I would like to see him at anfield next season if he's going to be cheap at 2-3m. Compared with our lovely Traore , oshea is more reliable and consistent as well. Besides, if we dun like him at all,why not we grab him to warm the bench with HARRY.  

Why not we go for Robert Huth or Jonathan woodgate. Both strong in air and replacable for Hyypia.