Liverpool FC Forum

Nice one mate, all your effort is much appreciated 

ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Fri Sep 11, 2015 8:05 pm wrote:Nice one mate, all your effort is much appreciated 

Thanks mate, but I'd thank the ones who had the will to rate the players after that game.

Newkit player of the month AUGUST

Games:

Stoke (A)
Bournemouth (H)
Arsenal (A)
West Ham (H)

Candidate:                        Rating:                   Games played:

Simon Mignolet                      6.6                         4
Nathaniel Clyne                     7                            4
Emre Can                              6.6                          4 (started 2)
Phillipe Coutinho                   6.8                          4
Christian Benteke                  6.5                          4



And the winner is..........    NATHANIEL CLYNE. Although Coutinho has the most man of the match awards (two), Clyne has regularly kept a high rating and has been the more consistent of the two

damjan193 » Fri Sep 11, 2015 6:18 pm wrote:

ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Fri Sep 11, 2015 8:05 pm wrote:Nice one mate, all your effort is much appreciated 

Thanks mate, but I'd thank the ones who had the will to rate the players after that game.

Yeah they deserve a medal 
I only listened to it on the radio, I watched the goals on MOTD and that was bad enough

I apologise for not doing player ratings...I was there and have spent the last 2 weeks trying to erase the memory

damjan193 » Fri Sep 11, 2015 7:18 pm wrote:

ycsatbjywtbiastkamb » Fri Sep 11, 2015 8:05 pm wrote:Nice one mate, all your effort is much appreciated 

Thanks mate, but I'd thank the ones who had the will to rate the players after that game.

I didn't vote as I (fortunately ?) didn't see the West Ham game, but Cheers Damjan for keeping the thread alive.

UNITED V LIVERPOOL

Mingolet - 6 can't really fault him for any of the goals but he looked shaky in possession
Clyne - 7 one of our better performers on the day
Skrtel - 5 not one of his best games, in fact he just gave United's new £36m signing a huge boost of confidence thanks to his inept defending
Lovren - 5 the usual, how the hell he is in the side ahead of Sakho God only knows
Gomez - 5 looks good at times but also makes a lot of mistakes, going to be a top player but he's also got a lot to learn
Lucas - 6 tried to get about United's midfield but didn't have much success, one or two very loose passes as well
Milner - 4 Mr Anonymous, can't believe Rodgers wants to build our midfield around him and Hendo
Can - 7 he wasn't spectacular but at least he looked @rsed
Firmino - 5 struggled to influence the game
Ings - 5 hard to judge him when he was obviously playing to orders and doing a job for the team
Benteke - 8 feel sorry for him having to lead the line in a team like this, no help or support but still managed to score a great goal.

UNITED V LIVERPOOL

Mingolet - 5
Clyne - 5
Skrtel -3
Lovren - 5
Gomez - 3
Lucas - 3
Milner - 4
Can - 6
Firmino - 4
Ings - 6
Benteke - 7 - great goal

Rodgers - 0 - fk off out of our club u utter cnut

Mingolet -4
Clyne - 5
Skrtel -3
Lovren - 3
Gomez - 0
Lucas - 3
Milner - 3
Can -4
Firmino - 3
Ings -3
Benteke - 6

Rodgers - 0

Mignolet - 5 - can't blame him for any of the goals but some of his mistakes were Sunday league stuff
Clyne - 4 - struggled at times and was poor going forward
Skrtel - 4
Lovren - 4
Gomez - 3 - I don't blame him though, he's a kid, I blame Rodgers for overusing him
Lucas - 4
Milner - 4 - I'm starting to hate this guy with a passion, I cringe every time I see him with the armband
Can - 5
Frimino - 4 - wasted out wide
Ings - 5 - also wasted out wide but I though he did OK defensively
Benteke - 6 - for the goal

Subs:
Ibe - 5 - had a good shot at goal once, no more than that
Origi - 5 - lively, but didn't (and couldn't) do much
Moreno - N/A

Mingolet - 4 still doesn't inspire confidence.
Clyne - 5 got forward when he could but given a run around by young in the 2nd half.
Skrtel - 4 thought he did ok
Lovren - 4 better with 8 men within 5 feet of him because there is less chance of him fooking up.
Gomez - 4 poor game but typical rodgers playing lads out of position until eventually they get exposed.
Lucas - 4 Not great today, careless at times in all the confusion.
Milner - 3 Fooking Plodder but again it would be hard to think of anything else when someone has their head embedded up your hole.
Can - 4 Seen him looking frustrated with a few and I'd say he ran a marathon during that game.
Firmino - 3 Didn't think he showed an awful lot in his previous games and showed nothing today.
Ings -3 Only got a game because of his defensive work and then got shafted to let Origi partner benteke. Keeps running with his head down and chases shadows.
Benteke - 5 It would have been a 3 only for that goal because he did fooking nothing. He doesn't have to worry about it though because after the first 5 games and the fact that we created absolutely fooking shyte in all of them the Genius is going to maybe have a look at that for you.

Mignolet 4 - looks nervous with the ball at his feet, which puts the defence on edge.

Clyne 4 - did well first half shutting out Depay. Made a mistake second half giving away the freekick for the first goal.

Lovren 4 - didn't do nothing wrong for a change, got out muscled a few times from Fellani.

Skrtel 4 - played ok, did quite well with the ariel threat of Fellani.

Gomez 3 - inexperience showed giving away the cheap penalty.

Milner 3 - Woeful, headless chicken ...  showed no leadership qualities!

Lucas 3 - he looked sluggish and gave so many free kicks away in dangerous areas.

Can 3 - gave the ball away most of the game, was slow in closing Down.. He had a stinker.

Firmino 3 - I know he's a class act, but today he was terrible and well  off the pace.

Ings 3 - tried hard but he's obviously not a winger.

Benteke 5 - he was terrible apart from the spectacular goal.

Manchester United vs. Liverpool player's average (by 6 voters):

Mignolet – 4.7

Clyne – 5
Skrtel – 3.8
Lovren – 4.2
Gomez – 3

Lucas - 3.8
Milner - 3.5
Can – 4.8

Frimino – 3.6
Ings - 4.2

Benteke - 6.2


Newkit man of the match: Christian Benteke
Newkit flop of the match: Joe Gomez

BORDEAUX V LIVERPOOL

MINGOLET - 6 no chance with the goal and made a couple of decent saves but he just doesn't fill me with confidence for some reason
SAKHO - 8 along with Rossiter my MoM, his ability to pass the ball out of defence is sorely missed in the first team, best CB at the club imo.
TOURE - 5 bit unlucky to be booked and then taken out by Mingolet in quick succession
GOMEZ - 7 the lads a CB not a LB, his recovery pace is a great asset to have. Should be used as a CB from now on.
MORENO - 7 should be the first team LB
CAN - 7 another one who looks more comfortable in the back line
ROSSITER - 8 MoM display from the lad, covered every blade of grass and used the ball well
LALLANA - 7 not his biggest fan but he did well tonight, cracking goal as well
IBE - 5 looks a bit heavy to me, I don't know if he's spending too much time in the gym beefing up or what but he has deffo lost some of his dynamism
COUTINHO - 6 not his best night but still the best player at the club
ORIGI - 5 held the ball up well but needs to get himself into more goal scoring positions

Mignolet - 6
Gomez - 6 - talented lad but his inexperience shows at times. Shouldn't be letting players get past him like that
Toure - 6 - unfortunate to be injured and subbed off
Sakho - 7.5 - wow, we have a CB in our team?
Moreno - 6.5 - OK but still looks braindead to me
Can - 6.5
Rossiter - 7 - nothing too spectacular but put a shift in
Lallana - 6.5 - good goal but otherwise awful I thought
Ibe - 6 - slight improvement from the last few games but still didn't show much
Coutinho - 6
Origi - 6

Subs:
Chirivella - 6
Ings - 6
Branagan - N/A