Liverpool FC Forum

Mignolet - 6
Johnson - 4
Skrtel - 5
Lovren - 4
Moreno - 4
Gerrard - 5
Allen - 4
Henderson - 3
Coutinho - 4
Sterling - 4
Balotelli - 4

Liverpool vs Swansea player's average (by 4 voters):

Jones - 5.5

Manquillo - 6.7
Toure - 6
Lovren - 6.2
Johnson - 6.2

Lucas - 6.5
Henderson - 6.7
Coutinho - 8

Markovic - 4.5
Borini - 6.2
Lambert - 4.7

Subs (by 4 voters):

Balotelli - 6.5
Lallana - 5

Newkit man of the match: Philippe Coutinho
Newkit flop of the match: Lazar Markovic

Newcastle vs Liverpool player's average (by 4 voters):

Mignolet - 6
Johnson - 2.6
Skrtel - 4.7
Lovren - 3
Moreno - 3.2

Gerrard - 4.5
Allen - 4
Henderson - 3

Sterling - 4.5
Coutinho - 4.5
Balotelli - 4.5


Newkit man of the match: Simon Mignolet
Newkit flop of the match: Glen Johnson

REAL MADRID vs LIVERPOOL

MINGOLET - 8 had a really good game, tremendous display of shot stopping
MANQUILLO - 7 this lad is going to be a hell of a player when he's 24/25
TOURE - 8 a rock at the heart of our defence
SKRTEL - 6 one or two shaky moments but played well
MORENO - 7 both fullbacks were magnificent, both in defence and raiding down the flanks
LUCAS - 7 anchored the midfield superbly
CAN - 7 powerful display from the young German
ALLEN - 6 passing a bit sloppy at times but part of a midfield that pressed high up the pitch and took the game to Madrid
MARKOVIC - 7 caused Madrid problems with his direct running, much more like it!
LALLANA - 7 worked hard and unlucky not to score after a great turn that left the Real defence flat footed
BORINI - 6 worked his @rse off and did well

Very generous, mind you a loss is respectable these days.

Everyone a 6 apart from Toure 8, Lucas 7, Markovic 3 an Borini 4.

Stu the Red » Tue Nov 04, 2014 11:08 pm wrote:Very generous, mind you a loss is respectable these days.

Everyone a 6 apart from Toure 8, Lucas 7, Markovic 3 an Borini 4.

Well considering it was a scratch team playing probably the best side on the face of the planet ATM I think those marks are justified.

So it's all about context for you and not quality? Fair enough, as long as I know where you stand

Stu the Red » Wed Nov 05, 2014 1:08 am wrote:Very generous, mind you a loss is respectable these days.

Everyone a 6 apart from Toure 8, Lucas 7, Markovic 3 an Borini 4.

I agree, more or less.

Anyway, will those be your ratings Stu? I'll need confirmation for the ratings.

Yes mate, even 6 for the subs, thought it was tactically OK and had we had better than Borini and Markovic we would have had a chance of snatching something

Mignolet - 7 - good game, especially at the start
Manquillo - 6 - I think he's had better games, and partly at fault for the goal
Skrtel - 6 - did ok
Toure - 7 - good game
Moreno - 6
Lucas - 7 - another good game for Lucas
Can - 6 - starting to get into form
Allen - 5 - useless with the ball
Markovic - 5 - improved greatly as the game went on and had a few promising runs at Real's defenders. Still needs to do better though
Lallana - 6
Borini - 4 - had we a better player up front we would have scored I believe. It's not always down to lack of creativity by the midfield, sometimes they just have no one to pass it to

Subs:
Sterling - 6
Gerrard - 5 - tried some of them Hollywood passes but they never came of.
Coutinho - 6

Stu the Red » Wed Nov 05, 2014 1:24 am wrote:Yes mate, even 6 for the subs, thought it was tactically OK and had we had better than Borini and Markovic we would have had a chance of snatching something

Yep, I agree. Thanks for the confirmation I'll need it for the averages

Mignolet - 7 - done much better past few games, just wish he would catch the bloody ball ffs, stop parrying it
Manquillo - 7 - solid enough, must start instead of GJ
Skrtel - 6 - solid enough
Toure - 7 - very impressed with him after not playing much football, puts pressure on lovren now for chelsea match
Moreno - 6 - did ok, thought he could have done better when up the field
Lucas - 7 - did really well, played it simple
Can - 7 - he is a star in the making, can see him getting to the top of the game
Allen - 5 - not good
Markovic - 5 - he seemed more comfortable at this pace of match
Lallana - 6 - looked ok, made a couple of nice dribbles
Borini - 5 - worked hard but lacking in quality

Subs:
Sterling - 5 - no real impact - would have been different if he started and might have pinched something
Gerrard - 5 - ok
Coutinho - 5 -ok

MINGOLET - 8
MANQUILLO - 7
TOURE - 8
SKRTEL - 6
MORENO - 7
LUCAS - 7
CAN - 8
ALLEN - 6
MARKOVIC - 7
LALLANA - 7
BORINI- 6

Mignolet - 6 -
Manquillo - 5 -
Skrtel - 6 -
Toure - 7 -
Moreno - 6 -
Lucas - 8 -
Can - 7 -
Allen - 5 -
Markovic - 5 -
Lallana - 7 -
Borini - 5 -

Subs:
Sterling - 4 -
Gerrard - 4 -
Coutinho - 5 -

Mignolet - 8 -
Manquillo - 7 -
Skrtel - 6 -
Toure - 7 -
Moreno - 7 -
Lucas - 7 -
Can - 7 -
Allen - 5 -
Markovic - 6 -
Lallana - 7 -
Borini - 5 -

Subs:
Sterling - 6 -
Gerrard - 5 -
Coutinho - 5 -