Liverpool FC Forum

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 12:22 am

Reina -
Johnson -
Skrtel -
Agger -
Enrique -
Henderson -
Lucas -
Adam -
Downing -
Suarez -
Carroll -

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) -
Bellamy (Carroll) -

by **aCe'** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 1:16 am

Reina - 7
Johnson - 6
Skrtel - 6
Agger - 6
Enrique - 7
Henderson - 2
Lucas - 5
Adam - 4
Downing - 5
Suarez - 6
Carroll - 5

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 4
Bellamy (Suarez) - 5

manager:
Kenny - 4 ; For a side trying to win a home game against a promoted side, our effort and overall application was lacking. Starting Henderson was a mistake imo but what was even more disappointing was how slow we were to Swansea taking the initiative and attacking us. We did nothing to add balance to the middle of the park, and were very late in trying to add creativity to the final third.

by **only me** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 8:48 am

Reina - 5 ,not a good game for our keeper ,couldn't hold to the ball ,almost conceeded a ridicules goal ,not a confident game
Johnson - 6 ,Had an OK game ,capable of doing much more in support of attack.
Skrtel - 6 ,Fair game
Agger - 6 ,Fair game
Enrique - 7 ,Was very active and involved
Henderson - 3 ,i thought he had 10 promising starting minutes but then again nothing ,lost the ball too easilly and contributed nothing.
Lucas - 5 ,Lost the midfield to Swansea players.
Adam - 4 ,Lost the midfield to Swansea players ,really needs to work on game fitness and quickness of thought.
Downing - 5 ,again glimps of talent but not good enough.
Suarez - 6 ,ok game ,disturbed the defence had a couple of attempts ,should work on his passing game ,barely completes a pass.
Carroll - 5 ,no service no Andy ,horrible miss in the beginning.

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 6 ,The only one which worked ,but Dirk isn't the answer anymore
Bellamy (Suarez) - 5 ,not enough time to be felt

Kenny - 4 ,leaving individual player aside ,this is NOT how a Liverpool team approaches a game. The whole team wasn't prepered mentaly for this game ,no energy ,no commitment ,no pressure ,no passion. Kenny shouldn't accept such a performance from his team ,play the youth squad if this bunch aren't up for the task. Again Kenny played players out of position (if i'll see Downing again on the Right i'm gonna explode) ,Very Late subs (again and again). Failed to impact the game from the sidelines.

by **supersub** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 8:56 am

Reina - 6
Johnson - 5
Skrtel - 6
Agger - 6
Enrique - 7
Henderson - 3
Lucas - 6
Adam - 5
Downing - 4
Suarez - 6
Carroll - 4

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 5
Bellamy (carroll) - 5

by **Johnny Boy** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 9:14 am

Reina - 6, mixed game a very good double save but also looked nervous at times too. A goalkeeper should never be captain, how can he see what's going on from back there?
Johnson - 6, seemed reluctant to get forward and overlap at times, nearly won it at the end
Skrtel - 6, did ok
Agger - 6, as above and what I did like is how you could see his anger at what was going on up ahead, constantly shouting at people - should have been captain
Enrique - 6, not outstanding but probably MOTM for me
Henderson - 3, poor, looked uncomfortable on the ball, played out of position AGAIN, never looks forwards always looking for the sideways or backwards pass. Finding it hard to justify why we bought him to be honest.
Lucas - 4, his worst game for some time slow and pedestrian against a midfield that has pace, good passing and movement (make a note of that Kenny)
Adam - 4, as above
Downing - 5, a couple of very good crosses one from which Carroll should have scored, but his confidence is low and his performance up and down
Suarez - 6, not at his best and his passing and hold up play were poor, still better than others though
Carroll - 5, worked hard but missed a sitter, starting to look like a £35m misfit.

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 5, worked hard as ever
Bellamy (Suarez) - 6, started to stretch their defence when he came on but once again brought on far too late

Kenny, 4 - dear me, yet again I have to question the tactics and substitutions.
a) Reina should never be captain, has to be an outfield player, I would have Agger
b) Henderson again played on the right when we have better options
c) Adam and Lucas are not a midfield pairing yet he continues to use them
d) Bellamy - we need to use him more not have him sat on the bench
e) Maxi - can score goals, I would have brought him on for 20 minutes

by **RichardLFC1** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 9:22 am

Did anyone watch the game as Bellamy came on for carrol not Suarez.

by **Johnny Boy** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 9:23 am

RichardLFC1 wrote:Did anyone watch the game as Bellamy came on for carrol not Suarez.

Very true

and yes I was at the game but still didn't notice the error on the thread!

by **mart** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 10:02 am

Reina - 7
Johnson - 7
Skrtel - 7
Agger - 7
Enrique - 7
Henderson - 3
Lucas - 6
Adam - 4
Downing - 5
Suarez - 6
Carroll - 5

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 6
Bellamy (Carroll) - 5 (not enough time.)

Kenny - 4

by **RedSi35** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 1:03 pm

Reina - 6 not best of days, clean sheet still
Johnson - 6 not getting forward as much
Skrtel - 7 assured alongside agger
Agger - 7 assured again
Enrique - 7 MOTM
Henderson - 4 played out of position poorly again
Lucas - 4 let swansea run midfield
Adam - 4 let swansea run midfield
Downing - 3 good 10 mins then went awol
Suarez - 6 tries so hard for us, maybe too hard
Carroll - 5 early miss knocked his confidence

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 5 not much impact, better than hendo
Bellamy (Carroll) - 6 should have come on at half time

by **RedSi35** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 1:04 pm

doooooble post

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 5:30 pm

RichardLFC1 wrote:Did anyone watch the game as Bellamy came on for carrol not Suarez.

Oops. Fixed.

by **ethanr** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 5:44 pm

Reina - 7
Johnson - 6
Skrtel - 6.5
Agger - 6
Enrique - 6.5
Henderson - 4
Lucas - 5.5
Adam - 6
Downing - 7 in the first half but 5 in the second so a 6
Suarez - 6.5
Carroll - 6.5

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 6
Bellamy (Carroll) - 6

by **red till i die!!** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 6:33 pm

Reina - 5
Johnson - 5
Skrtel - 6
Agger - 6
Enrique - 6
Henderson - 3
Lucas - 4
Adam - 4
Downing -4
Suarez - 7
Carroll - 6

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 4
Bellamy (Carroll) - 4 both subs had very little to offer,no impact at all

by **Johnny Boy** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 7:00 pm

red till i die!! wrote:Reina - 5
Johnson - 5
Skrtel - 6
Agger - 6
Enrique - 6
Henderson - 3
Lucas - 4
Adam - 4
Downing -4
Suarez - 7
Carroll - 6

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 4
Bellamy (Carroll) - 4 both subs had very little to offer,no impact at all

Bit harsh on Bellamy, it was around 74 minutes before he came on.

by **damjan193** » Sun Nov 06, 2011 9:30 pm

Reina - 8 Don't know why he's getting low ratings since IMO he was the reason we didn't lose yesterday.
Johnson - 6 Average, didn't expect much from him
Skrtel - 6.5 Good partnership with Agger at the back
Agger - 7 good link up with our poor midfield, even had to do their job at times. Good partnership with Skrtel
Enrique - 7 Although he had a lot of trouble with Dyer, he coped with it well and was good in going forward as well.
Henderson - 4 Comparing first with second half we seemed better with him but individually he sucked and had to be replaced
Lucas - 5 probably worse game so far this season, destroyed in midfield along with Adam
Adam - 5 although he had some good passing at times, he was invisible most of the time
Downing - 6 at least he was trying and didn't disappear as much as in few previous games
Suarez - 6 not involved as much as he usually is and failed at most of the stuff he tried
Carroll - 6 Tried to do something but did nothing. His early miss proved to be costly at the end. Was great in the air though, but nothing came out of that either.

Subs
Kuyt (Henderson) - 5 useless
Bellamy (Carroll) - n/a

Kenny - 5 the usual

Liverpool FC Forum

Swansea (h) - player ratings - 5/11/11

Who is online