Liverpool FC Forum

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 8:23 am

Reina -
Johnson -
Carragher -
Skrtel -
Enrique -
Kuyt -
Gerrard -
Adam -
Downing -
Bellamy -
Suarez -

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) -
Carroll (Downing) -
Agger (Kuyt) -

by **only me** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 9:27 am

Reina - 6 ,terrible mistake on the goal but also managed a few saves.
Johnson - 6 ,decent first half ,disappeared in the 2nd.
Carragher - 5 ,avarage struggled against their attackers
Skrtel -5 ,avarage struggled against their attackers
Enrique - 5 ,rather quite game for him ,not much impact.
Kuyt - 4 ,nothing to show for ,should not be starting anymore.
Gerrard - 6 ,very quite ,little impact on the game.
Adam - 4 ,no show again.
Downing - 5 ,really starting to get worried with him. Weak Mental state.
Bellamy - 7 ,good ,solid ,focused ,scored.
Suarez - 6 ,Dr Jeckel and Mr hyde for me ,he is a nightmare for any defender but has nothing to show for ,too many misses also poor passing.

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 5 ,no impact
Carroll (Downing) - 5 ,hardly played
Agger (Kuyt) - 5 ,hardly played

Kenny - 5 ,Again late and wrong Subs.

by **Roger Red Hat** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 10:28 am

Reina - 6 , he fluffed up for the goal but he's still the best goalie in the league.
Johnson - 6 , good to see him back, give him a few more games and he'll be solid.
Carragher - 5 , Times up come on in boat number 23.
Skrtel - 5 , should be moving him on in January
Enrique - 7 , looks quality when he puts a shift in.
Kuyt - 5 , can we have our Kuyt of old back please?
Gerrard - 7 , a bit steady but
Adam - 5 , Did he play? I can't remember seeing him much
Downing - 6 , I like him. He was a bit quiet though
Bellamy - 8 , Signing of the summer. hard worker.
Suarez - 7 , he'll get silverware by the end of the season. If not a cup with LFC he should win an Oscar. drama queen.

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - no comment
Carroll (Downing) - dear oh dear oh dear. shocking miss at the end
Agger (Kuyt) - didn't see him much. not on long enough

by **metalhead** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 10:29 am

Reina - 5
Johnson - 6
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 6
Enrique - 7
Kuyt - 5
Gerrard - 6
Adam - 6
Downing - 3
Bellamy - 7
Suarez - 7

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 5
Carroll (Downing) - 5
Agger (Kuyt) - 5

by **aCe'** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 10:35 am

Reina - 5
Johnson - 5
Carragher - 5
Skrtel - 5
Enrique - 5
Kuyt - 5
Gerrard - 6
Adam - 3
Downing - 3
Bellamy - 7
Suarez - 6

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 5
Carroll (Downing) - 5
Agger (Kuyt) - none

Manager:
Kenny - 3 ( I might be a bit harsh here but there was no balance in the starting 11, and the subs were late and poor)

by **supersub** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 11:19 am

Reina - 5
Johnson - 5
Carragher - 5
Skrtel - 5
Enrique - 6
Kuyt - 5
Gerrard - 5
Adam - 4
Downing - 4
Bellamy - 7
Suarez - 6

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 4
Carroll (Downing) - 5
Agger (Kuyt) - na

by **Johnny Boy** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 11:20 am

Reina - 5 his kicks are getting worse and flapped for the cross that lead to the goal
Johnson - 6 tired towards the end but did well first half, good to have him back
Carragher - 6 struggled when Holt came on but why I don't know!
Skrtel - 6 as above
Enrique - 7 solid game, our best buy of the summer
Kuyt - 3 I thought he was terrible and should have been taken off earlier, not put on the left wing!
Gerrard - 6 Still not back to his best, some of his passing was well short of standard, though would have scored if Suarez passed to him in second half
Adam - 6 I thought he did ok, some good runs with the ball
Downing - 5 hit and miss, but then again he has been like that every game
Bellamy - 7 what Kenny was thinking about taking him off only he knows - was sat in the stand stunned at the time and still cannot believe it now!
Suarez - 7 great player, must be horrible to play against but his attitude stinks, he is becoming like Ronaldo and will be universally hated before too long. Moans all the time and goes to ground way too easy. Needs to look up and pass rather than shoot at times.

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 4 brought on to replace one of our best players so my judgement is clouded, again used on the right for some reason
Carroll (Downing) - 5 Should have scored but was brought on far too late, he scores against the bitters and hasn't started since.
Have to question why we bought him, if I was John Henry I would probably be asking why
Agger (Kuyt) - Only got a few minutes and not sure why he was brought on

Kenny - a legend but his team selection and substitutions again baffle me, I can't believe he took Bellamy off and then to play Kuyt and Henderson on the wings was again confusing to say the least

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 12:00 pm

Reina - 5
Johnson - 6
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 6
Enrique - 6
Kuyt - 6
Gerrard - 6
Adam - 6
Downing - 6
Bellamy - 7.5
Suarez - 6.5

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 6
Carroll (Downing) - 5.5
Agger (Kuyt) - 5

by **red till i die!!** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 1:25 pm

Reina - 5.goal was all his fault.
Johnson - 6,isnt fully fit.
Carragher - 5
Skrtel - 5
Enrique - 6
Kuyt - 3.offers nothing other than consistent poor performances,should be shipped out pronto.
Gerrard - 5
Adam - 4
Downing - 4
Bellamy - 7.good game by bellers and puzzled as to why he was taken off.
Suarez - 6.needs to stop just taking potshots and lift the head before letting it fly.

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 4
Carroll (Downing) - 4.why was he even brought on when we removed any chance he had of service.
Agger (Kuyt) - n/a.worst sub of the lot for me and a sure sign we were happy with a point.

by **damjan193** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 2:46 pm

Reina - 6 should have done better about the goal but he still had a few decent saves.
Johnson - 6 just average, will be better in a few games I think.
Carragher - 5 bad performance, he's just too old.
Skrtel - 5 he's sure useful in attack when needed but his primary job was to defend, in which he failed.
Enrique - 6 a bit better than Johnson but still just average.
Kuyt - 5 this guy should never be started when playing with weaker teams
Gerrard - 6.5 rusty Gerrard but still apart from Bellamy, our best player on the pitch. Made some good passing and crossing.
Adam - 5 Had a few good passes but that's about it. Terrible defensive skill.
Downing - 6 I think he wasn't that bad, he was too quite and missed a few chances but had a few good crosses as well.
Bellamy - 7.5 Good play by him and a goal.
Suarez - 5 I'm sorry, but I'm tired of him getting high rating every game with all the missed chances, theatrical dives and selfishness. He's a good player but someone needs to have a word with him about his flaws because they are costing us a lot.

Subs:
Henderson (Bellamy) - 5 Fail sub, invisible since he came in
Carroll (Downing) - 5 Should have taken his chances.
Agger (Kuyt) - n/a

Kenny - 5 I think he had a good starting line up, maybe apart from Kuyt (I've been thinking about his bad performance with smaller teams, and I think that he never and I mean literally NEVER does good against the smaller teams. Kenny should have known this), but his subs were late and wrong. He puts in Carroll who is needed for all the crossing we've made, but not before he takes of Downing and Bellamy who were actually responsible for the crossing

. Taking of Bellamy in the first place was a big mistake. Hope he learns from his mistakes but what's frightening is that he's done such mistakes before.

by **stmichael** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 2:49 pm

Reina - 6
Johnson - 6
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 6
Enrique - 6
Kuyt - 5
Gerrard - 6
Adam - 6
Downing - 5
Bellamy - 7
Suarez - 7

Subs:

Henderson (Bellamy) - 5
Carroll (Downing) - 5
Agger (Kuyt) - 5

by **Boocity** » Mon Oct 24, 2011 5:41 pm

Some harsh scoring, don't think anyone deserves only a 3

by **KennyisGod....still** » Tue Oct 25, 2011 1:46 pm

some very harsh scorin when you bear in mind the studio comments....
every1 to their own opinion i guess, but finishin aside that first half especially saw some great flowin attackin football. while its easy to say we should be hammerin opponents like norwich that 1st half was probly too easy and that leads to complacency. once the pace drops its hard to pick up again.

Liverpool FC Forum

Norwich (h) - player ratings - 22/10/11

Who is online