Liverpool FC Forum

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 10:59 pm

Use this template -

Reina -
Johnson -
Carragher -
Kyrgiakos -
Konchesky -
Shelvey -
Spearing -
Poulsen -
Jovanovic -
Meireles -
Ngog -

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -
Eccleston (Poulsen) -
Lucas (Ngog) -

by **Zidane** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:04 pm

Reina - 6 (Nothing to do really)
Johnson - 7 (Got us a Pen.)
Carragher - 6.5 (Meh, same old stuff I guess?)
Kyrgiakos - 8 (Won literally every header, again.)
Konchesky - 6 (Didn't do much at all)
Shelvey - 6.5 (Solid performance but at times he seems a little lost.)
Spearing - 6.5 (Solid.)
Poulsen - Edit: a 5 is too high, 4. (Solid cr@p.)
Jovanovic - 6.5 (I thought he was doing well and shouldn't have been subbed, oh well.)
Meireles - 6 (Could have done so much more.)
Ngog - 6.5 (So so.)

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) - 10

Eccleston (Poulsen) - 7 (Added much needed pace to our attack.)
Lucas (Ngog) - 7 (Great tackle to get Stevie his third.)

by **metalhead** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:12 pm

Reina - 6
Johnson - 7
Carragher - 5
Kyrgiakos - 6
Konchesky - 6
Shelvey - 5
Spearing - 5
Poulsen - 2
Jovanovic - 5
Meireles - 5
Ngog - 6

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) - 10000000000000000 to the ten of the tenth infinite
Eccleston (Poulsen) - 6
Lucas (Ngog) - 6

by **Thewaykokid** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:15 pm

Reina -6
Johnson -6
Carragher -5
Kyrgiakos -6
Konchesky -4
Shelvey -4
Spearing -6
Poulsen -2
Jovanovic -5
Meireles -5.5
Ngog -5

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9
Eccleston (Poulsen) -6
Lucas (Ngog) -6

by **Benny The Noon** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:16 pm

Reina -6
Johnson -7
Carragher -5
Kyrgiakos -6
Konchesky -4
Shelvey -7
Spearing -6
Poulsen -1
Jovanovic -6
Meireles -6
Ngog -6

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -10
Eccleston (Poulsen) -7
Lucas (Ngog) -6

by **metalhead** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:16 pm

Thewaykokid wrote:Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9

only? 9? He deserves an oscar for that performance..

by **mart** » Thu Nov 04, 2010 11:23 pm

Reina -6
Johnson -6
Carragher -4
Kyrgiakos -7
Konchesky -4
Shelvey -4
Spearing -5
Poulsen -2
Jovanovic -6
Meireles -5
Ngog -6

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9
Eccleston (Poulsen) -5
Lucas (Ngog) -6

by **bigmick** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 12:10 am

Reina - 8. Couple of handy saves, fantastic goalkeeper.
Johnson - 5. Won us the penalty, but too often gave the ball away and looks totally devoid of confidence. Would have been a 4 but got a point for tying his hair back for once.
Carragher - 7. Our best defender back to somewhere near his best.
Kyrgiakos - 6. Once or twice had time on the ball and distribution isn't his strong point. Still did OK though.
Konchesky - 6. Solid but unspectacular.
Shelvey - 3. I thought he was pretty poor to be honest, but he's only a kid so you get that.
Spearing - 6. Solid, got his foot in and tried his best.
Poulsen - 3. Never recovered from giving the ball away for their goal. Terrible on the night, but like the manager it saddens me when I hear the treatment he gets from our own fans. He's not El Hadji Diouff, he's a player who's confidence is shot.
Jovanovic - 4. Apparantly on 70K per week. Oh dear.
Meireles - 5. Disappointed in Raul tonight and I like him as a player.
Ngog - 5. Needs a bit of devil in him, like you need to slap him around a bit to get him wound up pre match. Lucky not to have his leg snapped by a terrible tackle. Wish he'd look down the fecking line and not go offside so much as well.

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) - 10. What can you say?
Eccleston (Poulsen) - 5. Not really sure what this lad is.
Lucas (Ngog) - 6. Thought he did well when he came on, albeit only for a brief time.

Roy Hodgson-9. Lucky manager tonight, but everyone needs a bit of luck. 3 wins and a draw from the next four matches after the Everton defeat is good going. Well done Roy.

by **RED BEERGOGGLES** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 12:37 am

Reina -7 good display ,could do little to prevent the goal
Johnson - 5 wasteful in possession
Carragher - 6 much better performance back in the center
Kyrgiakos -7 solid and efficient display
Konchesky -4 cant see how anyone could describe him as solid
Shelvey -5 the kid was overawed Tonight and played in an unfamiliar position
Spearing -5 far too many stray passes which if the opposition were better would see us punished
Poulsen - 5 the ball through to Ngog was nothing short of brilliant ,best thing I have seen him do in a Red shirt ....but wouldn't say he was any worse than Spearing
Jovanovic -4 clearly in no respect a winger
Meireles -5 Luis Garcia ...the frustrating one
Ngog -5 took an unbelievably horrendous tackle ...but should have slotted from the sublime pass of Poulson

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9 Stevie G won the game single handedly .... showed the fire and the passion missing from the first half
Eccleston (Poulsen) -5 some neat touches, but needs to work the ball better
Lucas (Ngog) - 7 Lucas's pass for Gerrard was perfect ....closed their attacking threat down completely in his brief cameo

The fans 8/10 best atmosphere for a while now

by **metalhead** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 12:40 am

RED BEERGOGGLES wrote:Poulsen - 5 the ball through to Ngog was nothing short of brilliant ,best thing I have seen him do in a Red shirt ....but wouldn't say he was any worse than Spearing

I said that in the poulsen thread, that was a great pass to ngog, but other than that he did nothing

by **SouthCoastShankly** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 12:41 am

Reina -6
Johnson -6
Carragher -6
Kyrgiakos -7
Konchesky -6
Shelvey -5
Spearing -5
Poulsen -3
Jovanovic -5
Meireles -5
Ngog -6.5

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -10
Eccleston (Poulsen) -7
Lucas (Ngog) -7

by **Thewaykokid** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 1:39 am

metalhead wrote:
Thewaykokid wrote:Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9

only? 9? He deserves an oscar for that performance..

lol sorry mate i'm of the opinion that noone can be perfect

bit of a

ain't I?

by **radun5** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 9:36 am

Reina -6
Johnson -6.5
Carragher -6
Kyrgiakos -6.5
Konchesky -6
Shelvey -6
Spearing -5
Poulsen -4
Jovanovic -5
Meireles -5.5
Ngog -6.5

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) -9 (it was not a perfect game, but such performance will do

Eccleston (Poulsen) - 6.5
Lucas (Ngog) -7 (nice impact)

by **only me** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 10:04 am

Reina - 5 ,not because he was bad he just had no work to do.
Johnson - 4 ,over rated over payed ,if it wasn't for the penalty would get a lower score.
Carragher - 6 ,was focused alert and made some good interceptions..
Kyrgiakos - 6 ,solid defending.
Konchesky - 4 ,can't believe we picked him over salcido.
Shelvey - 6 ,like the lad not afraid to ask for the ball was very much involved.
Spearing - 5 ,mediocre ,doesn't take the chances he get ,perhaps not good enough.
Poulsen - 3 ,oh well ,if a player makes Lucas look good he deserve $hit ,terrible mistake let to goal.
Jovanovic - 4 ,guess we seen the last game from him tonight ,pitty he looks very talented to me but he and Roy are just not synced.
Meireles - 4 ,poor game lost ball bad passes lost his nerve ,so far not one great performace in Liverpool
Ngog - 6 ,I like him ,he gets a lot of :censored:

from supporters ,but he is quick on his feet ,gets to position and usually scores.

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) - 9 ,nuff said
Eccleston (Poulsen) - 6 ,looked quick and detarmined.
Lucas (Ngog) - 5

Roy - 4 ,not good enough Roy ,poor selection of team ,can't say he wasn't saved by Stevie and a poor Italian defence.

by **woof woof !** » Fri Nov 05, 2010 10:22 am

Reina - 6
Johnson - 5
Carragher - 6
Kyrgiakos - 6
Konchesky - 5
Shelvey - 4
Spearing - 5
Poulsen - 4
Jovanovic - 4
Meireles - 5
Ngog - 5

Subs
Gerrard (Jovanovic) - 10
Eccleston (Poulsen) - 5
Lucas (Ngog) - 5

Liverpool FC Forum

Napoli (h) - player ratings - 04/11/10

Who is online