Page 2 of 3
Posted:
Sun Nov 07, 2010 11:20 pmby RED BEERGOGGLES
metalhead wrote:RB you didn't rate Kelly.. I suppose its an 8? 
well actually no.... its a..... its a..... its a ....its a ...its a
Ok its an 8 
Posted:
Sun Nov 07, 2010 11:20 pmby centarec
Reina- 9 ( did a couple of great saves )
Kelly-8 ( was quite solid, and i predict this lad a really bright future at Liverpool)
Carragher - 8 ( did a good job at commanding the back 4)
Skrtel - 6.5 ( he did o.k , but he looks shaky at moments)
Konchesky- 5.5 ( some say he played good today , i say he was terrible as usual, not good enough for Liverpool )
Kuyt - 7.5 ( great assist , and again he ran allot 
)
Lucas- 9.5 ( i would say his best ever performance , if it weren't for Nando he would easily be MOTM for me )
Gerard- 8.5 ( good game, Liverpool is a tottaly different team when he plays good )
Meireles-7.5 ( did well , he's gonna be an important player for us )
Maxi- 6.5 ( couldn't really step up to the tempo of the game , but he did hve his moments)
El Nino Fernando Torres- 10 ( do i have to say anything) ?
Posted:
Sun Nov 07, 2010 11:58 pmby Reg
Its a shame we dont have a Team Score for the games as I feel todays performance was geater than the sum of the parts. They played for eachother and the workrate was phenomenal.
Also, feel its a waste of time to rank subs, most aren't on long enough to make a proper impact.
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 2:08 amby Thewaykokid
Reina -7
Kelly -7
Carragher -7
Skrtel -6
Konchesky -7
Kuyt -7.5
Lucas -8
Gerrard -8
Meireles -6.5
Maxi -6
Torres -9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) -5
Ngog (Torres) -6
Spearing (Meireles) -5
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 8:57 amby Benny The Noon
Reina -8
Kelly -8
Carragher -8
Skrtel -6
Konchesky -6
Kuyt -7
Lucas -9
Gerrard -8
Meireles -8
Maxi -6
Torres -9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) -5
Ngog (Torres) -6
Spearing (Meireles) -was only on for 2 mins
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:03 amby europian-kings
Reina - 8
Kelly - 7
Carragher - 7
Skrtel - 7
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 8
Lucas - 9
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 8
Maxi - 7
Torres - 9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) - 6
Ngog (Torres) - 6
Spearing (Meireles) - 6
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 10:48 amby jacdaniel
Reina - 8 (crucial saves at crucial times)
Kelly - 8
Carragher - 8
Skrtel - 6
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 7
Lucas - 9
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 7
Maxi - 6
Torres - 9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) - 6
Ngog (Torres) - 6
Spearing (Meireles) - 5
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:26 amby Dundalk
Reina - 8
Kelly - 7
Carragher - 7
Skrtel - 7
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 7
Lucas - 9
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 7
Maxi - 7
Torres - 8
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) - 6
Ngog (Torres) - 6
Spearing (Meireles) - 6
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:30 amby woof woof !
Reina - 8
Kelly - 7
Carragher - 8
Skrtel - 7
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 8
Lucas - 8
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 7
Maxi - 7
Torres - 9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) - 5
Ngog (Torres) - 5
Spearing (Meireles) - 5
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:50 amby Reg
I'll go with that Woof.
Reina - 8
Kelly - 7
Carragher - 8
Skrtel - 7
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 8
Lucas - 8
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 7
Maxi - 7
Torres - 9
Subs:
Shelvey (Kuyt) - 5
Ngog (Torres) - 5
Spearing (Meireles) - 5
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 11:58 amby stmichael
Reina - 8
Kelly - 7
Carragher - 8
Skrtel - 7
Konchesky - 7
Kuyt - 8
Lucas - 9
Gerrard - 8
Meireles - 7
Maxi - 7
Torres - 9
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 12:22 pmby SouthCoastShankly
Reg wrote:Its a shame we dont have a Team Score for the games as I feel todays performance was geater than the sum of the parts. They played for eachother and the workrate was phenomenal.
Also, feel its a waste of time to rank subs, most aren't on long enough to make a proper impact.
It makes no difference to overall ranking for subs and besides if we didn't rank subs you wouldn't of been able to rank Gerrard vs Napoli.
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 12:57 pmby Benny The Noon
Maybe only rank subs if they come on for more than 15 or 10 mins
Posted:
Mon Nov 08, 2010 3:09 pmby Reg
Gerrard is the exception !!
But if a player comes on for 15 minutes and scores nemerous 5's his average score for the season will suffer badly.
I guess we need to present the scores as ratings as a starter, and rating when used as a Sub.
