Page 2 of 3
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 12:29 amby Fowler_E7
Starting Line Up
Reina - 9
Johnson - 6
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 5
Konchesky - 7
Maxi - 5
Poulsen - 4
Lucas - 4
Jovanovic - 5
Gerrard - 6
Torres - 5
Subs
Agger (Konchesky) - 6
Meireles (Lucas) - 6
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 2:26 amby aCe'
Use this template -
Game : Birmingham (Away)
Date : 12/09/10
Starting Line Up
Reina -10
Johnson - 2
Carragher - 7
Skrtel - 6
Konchesky - 7
Maxi - 4
Poulsen -4
Lucas - 3
Jovanovic - 5
Gerrard -5
Torres -6
Subs
Agger (Konchesky) - 6
Meireles (Lucas) - 6
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 7:05 amby TarnRed
Reina - 10
Johnson - 4
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 4
Konchesky - 7
Maxi - 4
Poulsen - 5
Lucas - 4
Jovanovic - 5
Gerrard - 5
Torres - 5
Subs
Agger (Konchesky) - 5
Meireles (Lucas) - 6
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 8:44 amby SouthCoastShankly
I'll post the results around 5ish, interesting to see how opinions on players differ so much.
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 8:56 amby Benny The Noon
This is a very good idea mate and cheers for suggesting it and cheers for doing it and hopefully keep it going - the majority seem to rate the players around the same sort of area with the one exception - one player getting 3's or 4's and the odd 5 and then one person giving same player a 7 and our best outfield player .
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:07 amby bigmick
Eh 
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:36 amby woof woof !
Reina - 10
Johnson - 4
Carragher - 5
Skrtel - 5
Konchesky - 5
Maxi - 3
Poulsen - 4
Lucas - 4
Jovanovic - 5
Gerrard - 6
Torres - 5
Subs
Agger (Konchesky) - 4
Meireles (Lucas) - 5
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:39 amby bigmick
The one mark I'm surprised about form the general consensus, is that Carragher didn't rate higher. I thought he was absolutely excellent and our best outfield player. His form this season continues to be a big step forward from last IMHO, and long may it continue.
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:47 amby SouthCoastShankly
bigmick wrote:The one mark I'm surprised about form the general consensus, is that Carragher didn't rate higher. I thought he was absolutely excellent and our best outfield player. His form this season continues to be a big step forward from last IMHO, and long may it continue.
Is it possible to rate the subs. Rate them on a pro-rata basis. If I put 0 or blank the results will be skewed.
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:51 amby bigmick
SouthCoastShankly wrote:bigmick wrote:The one mark I'm surprised about form the general consensus, is that Carragher didn't rate higher. I thought he was absolutely excellent and our best outfield player. His form this season continues to be a big step forward from last IMHO, and long may it continue.
Is it possible to rate the subs. Rate them on a pro-rata basis. If I put 0 or blank the results will be skewed.
Sorry mate fair enough.
Agger 6
Mereiles 6
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 9:59 amby Benny The Noon
Carra was part of a defence that continuously allowed the Brum players to get free headers on goal - he lost his man a few times in the box hence why he for a low mark . It's like rating Konchesky highly when most of the crosses that provided the clearcut chances came from an area he should be closing down - the left side .
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 10:10 amby matt_liverpool
Reina - 10
Johnson - 4
Carragher - 6
Skrtel - 5
Konchesky - 6
Maxi - 3
Poulsen - 4
Lucas - 3
Jovanovic - 5
Gerrard - 4
Torres - 4
Subs
Agger (Konchesky) - 6
Meireles (Lucas) - 6
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 12:11 pmby SouthCoastShankly
Benny The Noon wrote:Carra was part of a defence that continuously allowed the Brum players to get free headers on goal - he lost his man a few times in the box hence why he for a low mark . It's like rating Konchesky highly when most of the crosses that provided the clearcut chances came from an area he should be closing down - the left side .
Without this becoming a debate over the performance. I think most here would attribute the constant pressure to our goal from an ineffective midfield. When a defence has no real protection, exposure happens.
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 3:36 pmby SouthCoastShankly
Voting for the Birmingham game will close at 4pm.
Posted:
Tue Sep 14, 2010 5:47 pmby Aussie Style
Reina- 10
Johnson- 4
Carragher- 6
Skrtel- 5.5
Konchesky- 6.5
Maxi- 3.5
Lucas- 3.5
Poulsen- 5
Jovanovic- 5
Gerrard- 6
Torres- 4.5
Meireles- 5
Agger- 5