Page 2 of 2
Posted:
Thu Oct 23, 2003 3:35 pmby simic_ie
3-1 in Strachans favour I'm afraid Red
Posted:
Thu Oct 23, 2003 3:36 pmby big al
So far red between you, has and myself thats a 2-1 vote
I make that currently 66.6% recurring good enough for me. Strachan the man then. But Could I interest you in Cheesey for assistant.
Posted:
Sat Oct 25, 2003 8:03 pmby Redlester
Strachan has a lot to commend him - Southampton are having a brilliant run of results under his managership [certainly better than we are getting from ours] but for some reason I still think that the only person who can turn this around is Martin O'Neill and to those who don't like his tactics - I think they would change when he left Celtic and I think that he bases his tactics on the players he has and the type of league he is playing in
Posted:
Sat Oct 25, 2003 8:43 pmby Simlinford
I coulnt agree more the board would never sack Houllier unless o'Neil was a guarenteed replacement
Posted:
Mon Oct 27, 2003 4:41 amby greenred
Strachan isnt the worst option.
Posted:
Mon Oct 27, 2003 10:24 amby THEBARON
Yes I agree that Strachan wouldn't be a bad choice. He played at the top level himself which should help earn the respect of all the players ( the lack of playing at the top level has been used against Houllier by players and managers < Souness > ) and I like his blunt and uncomprimising approach. If his team have got beat and played sh##e then he will admit that ....rather than waffle about the fact that we have the most shots on goal in the premiership.
I have 2 concerns..
(1).Coventry were relegated. Yes they were never world beaters previously and he did well to keep them up previously but statistics like relegation are not the best indicators for success.
(2).Would he get a fair crack of the whip from all supporters given his ex Man U connections ? I can still remember his celebrations in 1988.
All this is purely academic however as the board will continue to back Houllier whatever the results. This is the same crew who should have shown Souness the door earlier and persevered with Evans for too long.
Who knows maybe they have a surprise for us all ?
Another partnership perhaps ?
Posted:
Tue Oct 28, 2003 5:54 pmby JBG
I still think Houllier is in trouble, despite the win over Leeds.
Strachen is ok but he's not good enough for the job at Liverpool. I think Steve Bruce is a better choice than Strachen.
Personally I think Martin O' Neill is the only realistic candidate.
Posted:
Tue Oct 28, 2003 5:58 pmby Cool Hand Luke
Yes Gordan Strachan was relegated with coventry but look at the team he had.
Posted:
Tue Oct 28, 2003 6:02 pmby Cool Hand Luke
REDTILLDEAD wrote:why dont you ask the users of this forum if they think he is the man for the job!!.. lets set up a vote on it?? [ I will be very surprised if he comes out top in that poll??. 
So REDTILLDEAD i did set up a poll and so far Strachan has the most votes, and there genrally seems to be a lot of support for him.
But we'll see how things develop.
Posted:
Tue Oct 28, 2003 6:04 pmby Cool Hand Luke
If you want to vote go to:-
New manager? who?
