Liverpool FC Forum

RedAnt » Mon Mar 02, 2015 3:51 pm wrote:Damjan, if you fancy doing the sums I'd be interested to know who's our best Newkit player thus far. I'd guess maybe Skrtel or Coutinho. Both have been immense, but Skrtel has been my player of the season up to this point.

Thus far this month or thus far for the whole season? If it's for the whole season, I've tried mate but it really takes a lot of time. I did it once (around November) but I remember it took me a good amount of time and I haven't been able to do the same since then.

damjan193 » Mon Mar 02, 2015 5:25 pm wrote:

RedAnt » Mon Mar 02, 2015 3:51 pm wrote:Damjan, if you fancy doing the sums I'd be interested to know who's our best Newkit player thus far. I'd guess maybe Skrtel or Coutinho. Both have been immense, but Skrtel has been my player of the season up to this point.

Thus far this month or thus far for the whole season? If it's for the whole season, I've tried mate but it really takes a lot of time. I did it once (around November) but I remember it took me a good amount of time and I haven't been able to do the same since then.

Actually I meant for the month but thought the season would be easier for some reason. My brain could never figure such out.

RedAnt » Mon Mar 02, 2015 7:27 pm wrote:

damjan193 » Mon Mar 02, 2015 5:25 pm wrote:

RedAnt » Mon Mar 02, 2015 3:51 pm wrote:Damjan, if you fancy doing the sums I'd be interested to know who's our best Newkit player thus far. I'd guess maybe Skrtel or Coutinho. Both have been immense, but Skrtel has been my player of the season up to this point.

Thus far this month or thus far for the whole season? If it's for the whole season, I've tried mate but it really takes a lot of time. I did it once (around November) but I remember it took me a good amount of time and I haven't been able to do the same since then.

Actually I meant for the month but thought the season would be easier for some reason. My brain could never figure such out.

Player of the month is easy, takes a few minutes. I'll do it this week and I'll try to do it regularly. Player of the season might not take too much time either I guess but I want to make it nice, with average ratings of all the players that have played, with first, second and third place, best player that has played more than say 15 games etc.

Thanks mate, I'll look forwards to reading it.

Newkit player of the month FEBRUARY

Games:

Bolton (A)
Everton (A)
Tottenham (H)
Crystal Palace (A)
Besiktas (H)
Southampton (A)
Besiktas (A)

Candidate:                        Rating:                    Games played:

Simon Mignolet                  7.7                          7
Martin Skrtel                     7.4                          7
Emre Can                          7.3                          7
Jordan Ibe                         7.2                         5


And the winner is..........    SIMON MIGNOLET    what an U turn this lad has made

I expect Skrtel or Can to take the official award but Mign would deserve it just as much.

damjan193 » Tue Mar 03, 2015 4:00 pm wrote:Newkit player of the month FEBRUARY

Games:

Bolton (A)
Everton (A)
Tottenham (H)
Crystal Palace (A)
Besiktas (H)
Southampton (A)
Besiktas (A)

Candidate:                        Rating:                    Games played:

Simon Mignolet                  7.7                          7
Martin Skrtel                     7.4                          7
Emre Can                          7.3                          7
Jordan Ibe                         7.2                         5


And the winner is..........    SIMON MIGNOLET    what an U turn this lad has made

I expect Skrtel or Can to take the official award but Mign would deserve it just as much.

Good work Damjan, cheers.

Mignolet is a fine example of how confidence can effect players. Skrtel too for that matter. Both have played a big part in recent results.

damjan193 » Tue Mar 03, 2015 4:00 pm wrote:Newkit player of the month FEBRUARY

Games:

Bolton (A)
Everton (A)
Tottenham (H)
Crystal Palace (A)
Besiktas (H)
Southampton (A)
Besiktas (A)

Candidate:                        Rating:                    Games played:

Simon Mignolet                  7.7                          7
Martin Skrtel                     7.4                          7
Emre Can                          7.3                          7
Jordan Ibe                         7.2                         5


And the winner is..........    SIMON MIGNOLET    what an U turn this lad has made

I expect Skrtel or Can to take the official award but Mign would deserve it just as much.

Nice work mate. 
We certainly played a lot of games in February, its one of the shorter months of the year as well.

Liverpool V Burnley - 5th March

Mignolet - 8 - did well again
Can - 8 - immense
Skrtel - 8 - solid
Lovren - 7 - did ok, one dodgy back pass but ok
Henderson - 9 - best game for a long time and scored a belter
Allen - 8 - another solid game (lucas who ?)
Moreno - 7 - thought he played well before being subbed
Lallana - 7 - played well, but thought he picked wrong pass on a couple of occasions
Sterling - 8 - much better performance
Coutinho - 8 - looking class in every match
Sturridge - 7 - thought he was selfish and wasteful, but took his header well

Subs:
Johnson - no score
Toure - 6 - did ok
Lambert - no score

Mignolet - 7
Can - 8
Skrtel - 8
Lovren - 7
Henderson - 9
Allen - 8
Moreno - 7
Lallana - 8
Sterling - 7
Coutinho - 9
Sturridge - 7

Mignolet - 7 - not a whole lot to do but did well in aerial duels (loved that header outside the box )
Can - 8 - the usual stuff
Skrtel - 8 - likewise
Lovren - 7 - solid again
Allen - 8 - picked up where he left off against City
Henderson - 9 - good game again plus a goal and an assist
Sterling - 7 - worked really hard and how many positions did he play?
Moreno - 6 - I wasn't really happy with him TBH. His final ball was poor going forward and left Lovren exposed a few times when defending.
Lallana - 7 - not the best with the ball but fantastic off the ball work-rate
Coutinho - 7.5
Sturridge - 7 - not too happy with his performance but he's here to score goals so he did his job I guess

Subs:
Toure - 6
Johnson - N/A
Lambert - N/A

Really excellent to read proper player ratings from other reds fans on here. It gives a better appreciation of how we are playing. Keep up the good work guys..

Liverpool vs. Manchester City player's average (by 9 voters):

Mignolet - 6.9

Can - 7.4
Srktel - 8
Lovren - 7.1

Allen - 8.2
Henderson - 8.4

Markovic - 5.5
Moreno - 7
Lallana - 7.4
Coutinho - 9.3

Sterling - 6.9


Subs (by 7 voters):

Sturridge - 6
Toure - 6.3


Newkit man of the match: Philippe Coutinho
Newkit flop of the match: Lazar Markovic

Liverpool vs. Burnley player's average (by 3 voters):

Mignolet - 7.3

Can - 8
Srktel - 8
Lovren - 7

Allen - 8
Henderson - 9

Sterling - 7.3
Moreno - 6.7
Lallana - 7.3
Coutinho - 8.2

Sturridge - 7


Subs (by 2 voters):

Toure - 6
Johnson - N/A
Lambert - N/A

Newkit man of the match: Jordan Henderson

No flop

LIVERPOOL V BLACKBURN ROVERS

MINGOLET - 7 didn't have that much to do, did make one terrific save though
JOHNSON - 4 hasn't played in a while and it showed
SKRTEL - wasn't on long enough to give a mark, hope the big fella is alright
LOVREN - 5 did okay defensively but still prone to giving the ball away in dangerous positions
HENDO - 6 worked hard but passing radar off today
CAN - 7 did quite well when on the ball, prefer him at CB though where he has the potential to become world class
MARKOVIC - 6 thought he was doing okay, personally I would have subbed Lallana
STERLING - 7 quiet-ish first half but probably our best attacker on the day
LALLANA - 5 physical game like that not really his forte
COUTINHO - 5 same as Lallana, he can't be a world beater every week
STURRIDGE - 5 didn't have much service

Mignolet - 7 - kept a clean sheet with a good save, not a lot to do other than that
Johnson - 6 - not terrible but as bad and as nervous as the rest of the CB's
Skrtel - N/A
Lovren - 6 - see Johnson
Hendo - 6
Can - 6 - wasn't really happy with him tbh, should have done better when he had the ball with him. Should stick with the back 3 from now on
Markovic - 5.5 - would have rather subbed Lallana as Yakka says but Marko wasn't a lot better tbh
Sterling - 6.5 - did alright, and had to do some defensive work as well
Lallana - 5 - poor game
Coutinho - 5.5 - slightly better than Lallana but overall poor as well
Sturridge - 6 - had poor service but did alright when he had the ball

Subs:
Toure - 6 - maybe the best in the back 3 but he also had poor moments, got caught out of position a few times and should have scored with the header really
Balotelli - 6