Liverpool FC Forum

Mingolet - 4, Shoddy ,and careless
Manquillo - 5 I don't think he was bad enough to be withdrawn at the interval
Skrtel - 5 Like he was somewhere else in the first 15 minutes ,but gradually looked more composed
Toure - 6 Gives this defence a leader
Johnson -4 No heroics this time ,nothing special
Henderson - 6 Good take for the goal ,but generally speaking he's not the dynamo we remember from last season.
Lucas - 8 Completely pivotal to the solidity of our team 
Gerrard - 8 Second half performance he grabbed the game by the proverbial's  and was the driving force behind the victory .
Sterling ,7 His pace is his greatest asset ,but with a football brain he would be unstoppable.
Lallana - 7 Classy performance
Lambert 5 Not as involved as he has been of late ,but the headed knock down for the goal was simple but brilliant.

damjan do you think you will be able to do player of the month based on averages ofthe average ?

Leicester vs Liverpool player's average (by 10 voters):

Mignolet - 4.1

Manquillo - 4.7
Skrtel - 5.1
Toure - 6.1
Johnson - 4.8

Lucas - 5.9
Henderson - 5.7
Gerrard - 7

Sterling - 6.9
Lallana - 6.9
Lambert - 5

Subs (by 4 voters):

Moreno - 5
Allen - 5.7
Lovren - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Steven Gerrard
Newkit flop of the match: Simon Mignolet

damjan193 » Fri Dec 05, 2014 5:34 pm wrote:Leicester vs Liverpool player's average (by 10 voters):

Mignolet - 4.1

Manquillo - 4.7
Skrtel - 5.1
Toure - 6.1
Johnson - 4.8

Lucas - 5.9
Henderson - 5.7
Gerrard - 7

Sterling - 6.9
Lallana - 6.9
Lambert - 5

Subs (by 4 voters):

Moreno - 5
Allen - 5.7
Lovren - N/A


Newkit man of the match: Steven Gerrard
Newkit flop of the match: Simon Mignolet

Thanks again for this mate, nice seeing members going the extra mile 

Newkit player of the month November

Games:

Newcastle (A)
Real Madrid (A)
Chelsea (H)
Crystal Palace (A)
Ludogorets (A)
Stoke (H)


Candidate:                        Rating:                    Games played:

Simon Mignolet                  5.7                          6
Philippe Coutinho               5.8                          4
Kolo Toure                         6.4                          3
Lucas Leiva                       6.7                          3


And the winner is..........    LUCAS LEIVA    congratulations lad, pick up your award tomorrow


NOTE: For the record guys, I wouldn't mind if you were to help in some way with the averages, be it the averages of a single game (if I'm late for example) or something else, like this player of the month thing. Suggestions and requests are most welcome, doing them yourselves would be even better.

Thanks again Damjam, i am stunned that mongolet got into the final 4, stunned, but the numbers dont lie

Well deserved to Lucas 

damjan193 » Fri Dec 05, 2014 7:02 pm wrote:Newkit player of the month November

Games:

Newcastle (A)
Real Madrid (A)
Chelsea (H)
Crystal Palace (A)
Ludogorets (A)
Stoke (H)


Candidate:                        Rating:                    Games played:

Simon Mignolet                  5.7                          6
Philippe Coutinho               5.8                          4
Kolo Toure                         6.4                          3
Lucas Leiva                       6.7                          3


And the winner is..........    LUCAS LEIVA    congratulations lad, pick up your award tomorrow


NOTE: For the record guys, I wouldn't mind if you were to help in some way with the averages, be it the averages of a single game (if I'm late for example) or something else, like this player of the month thing. Suggestions and requests are most welcome, doing them yourselves would be even better.

Good job there mate

I do think waiting till a day before the next match is a good idea as some posters might post their predictions after you have sumbmitted the averages etc

On the helping part I would have done but didnt want to step on your toes 

Cradiff-red - well Mign was man of the match vs Stoke (along with Lucas), apparently had a good game against Real and accumulated an average rating in a few other games (while other players were below average). He was horrible against Ludogorets though (flop I believe) and it's a well known fact that everyone forgets when you did good once you make a mistake

LFC1990 - yeah I thought it would be a good idea to wait as long as possible in case there are late submissions. It has happened, once or twice, people posting their ratings after I've posted the averages so I've had to edit my post because of that or not include them at all. As for the helping part, now you know that you can . This goes for everyone, not just you. Help is most welcome.

Liverpool v Sunderland 6/12/2014

Mignolet 6 - rarely tested
Johnson  6 - on and off
Skrtel  6 - solid
Toure  7 - solid
Moreno 6 - okayish
Lucas 6 - nothing special, defended well but no authority
Henderson 5 - anonymous
Coutinho 6 - good runs no end product
Lallana 6 - some good plays here and there but then went invisible 2nd half
Sterling 7 - our most lively player
Lambert 6 - held up the ball, but ineffective.

Subs:
Gerrard 6 - did ok
Markovic 5 - pub player

I didn't see today's game so Im not really in a position to give any marks, as for the monthly average thing - great work as always Damjan 

Liverpool v Sunderland

Mignolet 6 - did ok, 1 decent save
Johnson  5 - giving the ball away all the time
Skrtel  5 - reckless
Toure  7 - had a very solid game
Moreno 6 - ok
Lucas 6 - did ok, team better with him in it
Henderson 5 - would the real hendo please come back
Coutinho 6 - no end product, frustrating player
Lallana 6 - was ok, 25 million and the saints must be lol
Sterling 7 - was impressed with him today, tried hard
Lambert 4 - just not good enough for me, at any price

Subs:
Gerrard 6 - did ok
Markovic 5 - no time to make an impact

Liverpool v Sunderland 6/12/2014

Mignolet 6 - nothing to do really
Johnson  6 - did ok
Skrtel  6 - too many silly fouls
Toure  7 - solid
Moreno 6 - did ok
Lucas 8 - played well, our best player throughout the game
Henderson 5 - off form should be benched
Coutinho 6 - just no movement up front for him to play into
Lallana 6 - same as Coutinho
Sterling 7 - needs to improve final ball
Lambert 4 -  donkey

Subs:
Gerrard 6 - should have been on earlier
Markovic 6 - give attack extra push

Mignolet - 6 - nothing to do
Johnson - 6 - congratulations Johnson, 3rd game in a row without being a complete donkey! Had a few bad moments but did well overall both in attack and defense
Skrtel - 6 - like Johnson, had a few bad moments but did OK overall
Toure - 7 - one of the reasons why our defense looks so much better now
Moreno - 6
Lucas - 8 - it's sad how some of you are so easily disregarding Lucas' performances. I might be a bit generous with the 8 but I'm just happy that we finally have someone who can protect the back 4
Henderson - 5 - candidate for flop of the match. Should be benched
Coutinho - 5 - for me, another candidate for flop. Wrong decisions all around, expected more from him TBH
Lallana - 6
Sterling - 7 - tried hard but can't play on his own
Lambert - 5 - also candidate for flop though I guess we can't blame him for being unsuited to our style of play. Should at least work harder though.

Subs:
Gerrard - 6
Markovic - 6

MIGNOLET ,6 made some vital stops ,and his distribution has improved.   
JOHNSON ,7 Even better performance than the Stoke game ,showed he can be an intelligent defender. 
SKRTEL 6 dependable ,sturdy
TOURE 7 loves playing football and it shows
MORENO 6 some intuitive running off the ball ,but most of the time he was neglected for the decisive pass ,decent in defence also.
LUCAS ,9 If all our players gave the same amount of application and thought to their respective games we would be a significantly better team.   
HENDERSON ,3 Looked like he had just finished a pub crawl.
COUTINHO, 5 hampered by the lack of players on a similar wavelength. 
LALLANA,6 Why exactly he was substituted is a complete mystery ,just when he was coming into the game he was withdrawn     
STERLING, 5 Needs to stay on his fucking feet ,he's a strong lad but goes to ground like Nani.
LAMBERT, 4 May as well play with 10 men ,don't think I've ever seen a less effective striker in a red shirt. 
SUBS
GERRARD ,5 Done well ,and his delightful pass was the best moment of the game ,but wastes corners with annoying regularity. 
MARKOVIC 7 The lad needs to play more often ,he made our play more expansive when introduced, and his touch to give himself room for the shot was class.

mingy - 5
johnson - 5 still braindead
skrtel - 6 usual scare here and there but held it together
toure - 7 doing more than enough to keep lovren out
moreno - 5 could do with getting a run of games
lucas - 6 like toure deserves to retain his spot
henderson - 5 needs to get alongside players and use his strength
coutinho - 6 needs more movement ahead
lallana - 6 should have subbed hendo instead
sterling - 6 starting to whinge a lot when things aren't going his way
lambert - 5 tries hard
gerrard - 6 thought we looked far more dangerous when he came on
markovic - 5 thought he'd fallen off the face of the earth

overall thought we were poor and kick and rush stuff is how desperate we have become.