by bigmick » Mon May 04, 2009 9:06 pm
It comes back to that debate we had a week or so ago about whether it's who has been the best player in terms of who has contributed the most to the teams success, or who has played nearest to the absolute pinnacle of his ability.
On the first question (which if I'm honest is how I think it should be judged, even though in our case the result every year would be pretty boring) the winner is Gerrard by an absolute distance. Not even close, not even by head and shoulders above, probably from about the waist up. It's a funny thing this because when you make such statements, you normally get somebody accusing you of being "plastic" or "in love" with all things Gerrard. That or you are clueless, or not a real fan.
They're wrong on all counts I think. Gerrard is probably as Ace indicated, almost certainly infact the most important single player in any team in the Premier League. It's a strange phenomenon that some regular matchgoers can sit twenty yards from the action and can't see something as obvious as that, but there you go. A good way of judging who is/has been player of the season would be to ask all the other managers in the league who is our most important and best player. There are nineteen other Premiership managers, and if you'd asked them this season I should think nineteen would say Gerrard. That'll do for me.
On the second question there have been some strange names thrown into the mix which makes you wonder sometimes if people watch the same game as you, but in the main most everyone thinks it's either Kuyt or Alonso. Once again it's stating the obvious a bit, but as it's true why try swimming against the tide. My take is it's Alonso. If you ask me who out of him and Kuyt is playing closer to his absolute potential, it's probably a dead heat because they've both many times this season played at their absolute best. Football being football though, everybody has an off day from time to time. I give it to Alonso for two reasons. Firstly and quite simply because his absolute best is much better than Dirks, in that he's a much more talented player. It then follows of course that on Xabi's occasional off-days, he doesn't quite plumb the depths of Dirk when it's not one of his days. On those days I'm reminded of that old football song "If Lee Dixon can play for England then so can I".
Full marks to both, but for me it's Alonso in this vote.
Last edited by
bigmick on Mon May 04, 2009 9:08 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"se e in una bottigla ed e bianco, e latte".